4 min read

 

Broder
Broder

YORK COUNTY — In a highly contentious race, three candidates are vying for the position of judge of probate, as Independent Bernard Broder and Democrat Bryan Chabot challenge incumbent Independent judge Robert Nadeau.

Nadeau, 61, is a Sanford native currently living in Biddeford with his wife, Carol. He earned his bachelor’s degree from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore in 1977, and in 1980 earned his juris doctor from Delaware Law School at Widener Uni-versity. He is the vice president of the Maine Probate Judges Assembly.

Nadeau was elected judge of probate in 1997 and served through 2008. He lost that November, but was voted back into office by voters in 2012.

Na- deau, an independent, said he is primarily concerned with probate court funding, claiming the county only funds eight judicial days per month despite handling more than 1,700 new cases filed annually.

Chabot
Chabot

“Our commissioners need to provide much more realistic support for our constituents accordingly,” Nadeau said. “Whether the county politicians like it or not, we need a judge with the honesty and courage to keep asking them for such support.”

Advertisement

Nadeau said he is also concerned with the county’s opioid epidemic, which he said has resulted in an “explosion” of child custody cases in the court over the past three years.

“The children must come first, while their parents must solve their addictions away from them,” he said.

Nadeau
Nadeau

Nadeau said if re-elected he will concern himself with protecting the dignity of incapacitated adults, the numbers of which he said is growing, and with working to expedite judicial processes.

Nadeau, seeks re-election amidst his July 21 suspension by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court as a result of a complaint filed in 2014 by the Maine Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability. The committee claimed Nadeau breached judicial canons in a letter he penned to an attorney and on social media.

He was also censured and reprimanded by the court; his 30-day suspension began on Oct. 3. Nadeau was also suspended by the court for 30 days in 2007 following misrepresentations he made about his opponent in his 2004 campaign advertising.

Broder, 58, lives in Old Orchard Beach with his partner of 14 years. An independent, he holds a bachelor’s in child development from the University of Maine and a master’s in divinity from the Andover Newton Theological School. He also holds a juris doctor form the University of Maine School of Law.

Advertisement

Broder has been a licensed attorney for more than 19 years and has practiced in York County for 17. A former district attorney, he has prosecuted many cases involving domestic violence and child abuse and neglect. He is the former executive director of the Trinity Learning Center and a former caseworker for Big Brothers/ Big Sisters of York County.

Broder said he is running because he wants the best for the county, noting frequent delays in several critical court cases.

“I’ve been a public servant in one form or another throughout my 19 plus year legal career. I’ve served York County for 17 of those 19 plus years,” he said in an email. “This is yet another opportunity to be of service to the people.”

Broder said his number one priority will be to expedite hearings in existing cases and for matters requiring emergency hearings.

“I want the judge of probate to be first and foremost focused on providing timely, just, compassionate and thoughtful service to those it serves,” he said. “It is also important to me that the judge works well with York County’s governance and that the judge prioritizes the goals of public service and fiscal responsibility. The two are not mutually exclusive.”

Chabot, a Democrat, is an attorney at Scaccia, Bartlett & Chabot in Sanford. He was born, raised and currently lives in Wells. He holds a bachelor’s degree in criminology and sociology from the University of Southern Maine and attended the University of Maine School of Law.

Advertisement

Prior to becoming an attorney, Chabot served in the U.S. Army Reserve as a military police soldier, serving tours in Bosnia and Iraq. He is also a former Wells police officer.

Chabot said he is running, “to restore integrity to the court and to make it functional and fair for all litigants, free from the recent unnecessary delays and judicial suspensions.”

“Probate Court deals with some of our most vulnerable citizens: people who have lost family members and are grieving, the elderly, and children,” he said. “I have been appalled by the news that individuals in York County have endured extended waiting times to be heard and have had to resort to filing cases in other counties so that they can seek justice.”

Both Broder and Chabot decried Nadeau in light of his conduct violations.

“This is the second time this judge has been suspended for ethical violations while on the bench, and there are more ethical violations pending. This is simply unacceptable, and York County residents deserve better,” Chabot said.

“I believe that the current judge’s involvement in multiple lawsuits as well as his being suspended for the second time for ethics violations … have contributed to the people’s business not being handled as promptly as it otherwise could be,” Broder said. “As the saying goes, ‘justice delayed is justice denied.’”

Advertisement

Nadeau hopes voters will consider his experience when they hit the polls on Nov. 8, saying he has “the courage to fight for proper levels of support for a probate court our children and families depend upon.”

Broder believes his experience and “untarnished record” of law ethics outweigh both his opponents.

Chabot hopes his character and values of courage, honor, integrity and selfless service will resonate with voters on election day.

— Staff Writer Alan Bennett can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or abennett@journaltribune.com.

 

 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.