6 min read

The results of the Westbrook Democratic caucus earlier this month have caused a rift in the party and have raised questions about how the caucus was conducted.

More than 150 people filed into the gym at the Westbrook Community Center on Sept. 6 and cast ballots to nominate candidates for mayor, City Council and School Committee in the upcoming November election. The night yielded a number of contested races and a large turnout due to the high-profile mayoral race. Party officials considered it a success.

Michael Shaughnessy, a relatively new Westbrook resident, and president of the Friends of the Presumpscot River organization, surprised retired veteran public safety officer and City Councilor Mike Sanphy by winning the mayoral vote in an 87-69 tally. Shaughnessy’s nomination was endorsed by Mayor Colleen Hilton, who is nearing the end of her third term and not seeking re-election.

Some within the party, including Sanphy, have questioned how the caucus was conducted and who exactly was allowed to cast ballots. He, among others, believe that a number of independent, Green Party or unenrolled residents were allowed to vote during the caucus, which may have skewed the final tallies.

However, party officials have said a party caucus is more informal in nature compared with an official election, and can sometimes rely on the honor system.

Due to the large turnout, Deputy City Clerk Ashley Rand assisted a city election volunteer in checking in people prior to the votes. The pair attempted to write down the name of every person who entered the gym.

Advertisement

Lynda Adams, the former Westbrook city clerk and Democratic nominee for Ward 5 city councilor, also had questions following the caucus. That night, she said, she took photos of the sign-in papers, and in the days following went through the names.

According to her analysis, 153 city Democrats were listed on the pages, with another 11 listed who are not Democrats, for a total of 164. During the mayoral vote, 158 ballots were cast, with one throw-away.

“The numbers just don’t jive,” Adams said Tuesday, adding that when she was city clerk and a volunteer for the committee, she would check each name on the caucus list against the city’s list of registered voters.

Sanphy did not shy away this week from his criticism of how the caucus was handled, and said many supporters have also shared concerns for how the caucus was run.

“It’s tainted, it’s not a valid caucus,” Sanphy said.

City Clerk Angela Holmes, who was not at the caucus, said it is the city’s responsibility to have an official there to register voters, but that all other operations are “completely a party function.”

Advertisement

Sanphy said prior to the caucus that if he were not chosen as the party’s nominee, he would submit nomination papers to run anyway, leading to concerns that the Democratic vote could be split on Election Day. Independent James Tranchemontagne and unenrolled candidate Jason Jerrier are also running. The day after the caucus, Sanphy took out his nomination papers, which he returned in about a week.

Westbrook resident and registered Democrat Dan Austin told the American Journal during the caucus that he walked into the gym without being checked in, and voted in the caucus. His name does not appear on the list obtained by Adams.

Westbrook State Rep. Drew Gattine, who had served as committee chairman until the end of the Sept. 6 caucus, said Tuesday that he didn’t run the event any differently from how he has in the past. He estimated that it was his eighth caucus as chairman. He said no one has contacted him to discuss any concerns with the caucus, and that he’s only heard rumors of concerns.

“It’s a pretty open process,” he said Tuesday, stating that a caucus is not run the same way a primary is handled. But, he said, “we’re very careful.”

He also said he’s proud that the city Democratic committee had such a large turnout, with many contested races.

“I would welcome any questions about how it was run,” he said.

Advertisement

The party caucus is open to the public, which can also lead to some confusion. At the caucus, prior to any votes, Gattine asked non-Democrats to stand in the back of the gym.

“There are always people at our caucus who are not caucus members,” he said, referring to family members who are not registered in Westbrook, children or observers from other political parties. “Transparency to me doesn’t mean closing the door and locking people out.”

Deb Shangraw, a Westbrook business owner and a registered Republican in Gorham, attended the caucus as a spectator with a small number of fellow Republicans. She said the group was handed ballots prior to a vote, but declined them.

When the caucus breaks into separate wards, Gattine said, there is a “reliance on people being honest” that they will vote in the correct ward.

City Councilor Brendan Rielly, the vice chairman of the Democratic committee, said Monday that he discussed the caucus with Adams the next day, but that no one has come forward with concrete information about the potential problems.

“We take this seriously, and no one has brought any specific information to the party chair,” he said.

Advertisement

Rielly said he believes there may have been a small number of unenrolled voters who made the switch to Democrat that night, but does not believe it could have swayed vote tallies.

Gattine said if they had received the concerns or concrete evidence in the days following the caucus, they would’ve looked at it closely.

According to Katie Baker, communications director for the Maine Democratic Party, local party committees are self-governing.

The Maine election code’s party rules state, “The members of a party within a municipality shall determine the method of election, the terms of office and the duties of their political committees.”

“The nomination process is governed by the Westbrook city charter, and any appeal would go through the city and then through the courts,” Baker said.

While both Adams and Sanphy realize it’s too late for anything to be done, they believe party officials should have acknowledged the issue.

Advertisement

Hilton said Wednesday that no one has reached out to her regarding the caucus either. She said the only concerns she heard were over the number of Republicans who attended a Democratic caucus.

But Adams also had other concerns with the caucus, including its location at the gym, lack of PA system and microphones, and overall “miscommunication and disorganization.” She questions why the committee didn’t check the list of voter names following the caucus.

She’s also concerned with some party tactics since the caucus. Next week, the city’s Democratic committee, which is now chaired by Malory Shaughnessy, wife of Michael Shaughnessy, will take out advertisements featuring the party’s nominees for municipal seats, including Michael Shaughnessy, City Council at-large candidate Ann Peoples and Ward 2 candidate Victor Chau.

Sanphy, along with fellow Democrat Veronica Bates, who submitted papers to run against Chau for Ward 2, will not be included in the ads.

Malory Shaughnessy said Wednesday that the ads are designed to include all city candidates who were nominated by the party in primaries or the caucus.

“It is a fairly standard thing for municipal committees to do to encourage people to vote for their nominees,” she said in an email.

Advertisement

Adams said she opted out of the advertisements. She’s running unopposed in Ward 5.

Sanphy said Tuesday that he knows the party has been split and that some within the party are upset he is continuing to run. He said he’s been a member of the Westbrook Democratic Committee for 49 years.

“The party is split, but who split it?” he said.

The Westbrook Democratic caucus on Sept. 6 brought out over 150 voters to nominate candidates for mayor and other municipal seats, including a small number that may not have been registered Democrats.

City Councilor and mayoral candidate Mike Sanphy speaks with supporters at the Westbrook Democratic caucus Sept. 6.

Comments are no longer available on this story