2 min read

 
 
Alfred North Whitehead, an English mathematician who was the founder of process philosophy, said, “In formal logic, a contradiction is the signal of defeat; but in the evolution of real knowledge, it marks the first step in progress toward a victory.”

We are looking at deals in which one defender uses the knowledge of high-card points to progress toward victory, the defeat of the contract. Sometimes, though, a defender has to rely on his partner’s signal to dot the i’s and cross the t’s.

How does that apply in today’s deal? South is in three no-trump. West leads the spade queen: two, three, king. Declarer plays on clubs. How should West plan the defense after winning with his ace?

When South responds one no-trump, denying a four-card or longer major, North is a tad nervous about raising to three no-trump, but what else can he do? It is so unlikely that five clubs will make and three no-trump fail.

The key signal was East’s at trick one. He played the three, his lowest spade denying an honor in the suit. (Yes, South might have won the first trick with his ace, but that advertises the king because if he had only the spade ace, he would have made a holdup play at trick one.) So, West should see that if he continues spades, declarer will take nine tricks: two spades, three hearts and four clubs.

There is only one chance. West must shift to the diamond queen. Here, that generates five tricks in the suit to take the contract down two.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.