4 min read

 
 
ALFRED — Biddeford landlord James Pak was sentenced Thursday to two life sentences for murdering his 19-year-old tenant and the tenant’s 18-year-old girlfriend.

He was also sentenced to serve a consecutive 30-year prison term for the attempted murder of another tenant, the 19-year-old’s mother.

Pak, who is in his late 70s, pleaded guilty last week to two counts of murder for shooting and killing Derrick Thompson and his girlfriend, Alivia Welch, on Dec. 29, 2012. Pak also pleaded guilty to aggravated attempted murder for shooting Thompson’s mother, Susan Johnson, on the same night.

Assistant Attorney General Leane Zainea provided details of the crime at Thursday’s sentencing hearing at York County Superior Court in Alfred.

Above: Parents of slain teenager Alivia Welch, Jocelyne Welch and Dan Welch, speak with the media outside York County Superior Court in Alfred Thursday, while Alivia’s godmother, Michelle Houk, holds up a picture of her. Below: Biddeford......... landlord James Pak takes his seat at York County Superior Court in Alfred Thursday before being sentenced to life in prison for murdering two teenagers in 2012.
Above: Parents of slain teenager Alivia Welch, Jocelyne Welch and Dan Welch, speak with the media outside York County Superior Court in Alfred Thursday, while Alivia’s godmother, Michelle Houk, holds up a picture of her. Below: Biddeford……… landlord James Pak takes his seat at York County Superior Court in Alfred Thursday before being sentenced to life in prison for murdering two teenagers in 2012.
Pak, who was renting an apartment at his Sokokis Road home to Thompson, Johnson and Johnson’s 6-year-old son, Brayden, barged into their apartment, where Welch was visiting. He said, “I’m going to shoot you all,” and shot Johnson, Thompson and then Welch. Brayden remained in his room, listening to each person scream before being shot.

Advertisement

The shooting followed an argument over the tenants’ rental agreement, as well as parking and snow removal at the property. Just minutes before Pak shot the victims, a police officer responded to a call about the argument, but left after telling Pak and his tenants that the dispute had to be worked out through the civil process.

During the two-hour hearing, Johnson and six other relatives of the murder victims delivered emotional statements about how the tragedy has affected their lives. Pak, who was dressed in an orange prison suit, declined to make a statement.

Johnson said the shooting has left her emotionally scarred and paranoid. “I don’t feel completely safe in my own home or anywhere I go,” she said.

She also spoke about how the tragedy affected Brayden, who Zainea later referred to as “somewhat of a forgotten victim in this case.”

“The little boy’s innocence was completely taken from him that night,” Johnson said, adding that Brayden now struggles with the same fears she does. She called Pak a “monster,” and said she wished Maine had the death penalty so that it could be used in this case.

Other relatives also addressed Pak’s apparent lack of remorse for the killings, and expressed a mutual belief that he should never be let out of prison.

Advertisement

“(Pak) still has absolutely no remorse,” said Jocelyne Welch, Alivia’s mother. “He has no soul.”

“He should never have the opportunity to do this to anyone else ever again,” said George Johnson, Thompson’s grandfather.

Most of the families’ testimony, however, centered on the victims’ personalities and life aspirations.

Alivia Welch was attending college to become a nurse. Thompson, who was passionate about cars his entire life, hoped to open his own automotive detailing business.

Dan Welch, Alivia’s father, remembered Alivia as the “perfect daughter,” and said she made a positive impression on everyone she met. He said he and Thompson’s father share the belief that the couple, who had only recently fallen in love, would have stayed together forever.

After Alivia was cremated, her family placed a vial of her ashes in Thompson’s hand inside his casket.

Advertisement

The state requested a sentence of 50 years in prison for the murders, citing mitigating factors such as Pak’s age. “Because of his age, 50 years is a life sentence,” Zainea said.

But Justice John O’Neil Jr. said the victims’ young ages, the immense impact their deaths had on the community and the fact that a 6-year-old was present – among other factors in the case – influenced him to impose the most severe sentence.

O’Neil said the matter of restitution will be discussed later .

More than three years passed between the killings and Pak’s sentencing. He originally pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, and his ability to stand trial was debated at hearings in February and May 2015.

In November, the court ruled that while Pak does have cognitive limitations and struggles with the English language, he was mentally competent to stand trial.

Family members reacted positively to the sentence following Thursday’s hearing.

Advertisement

“I’m very happy with the sentence,” Susan Johnson said.

“I feel like it was validating,” said Dan Welch.

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.