2 min read

WASHINGTON — Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders says his plan for a government run health care system from cradle to grave is like Medicare for all.

But with full coverage for long-term care, most dental care included, no deductibles and zero copays, the Sanders plan is considerably more generous. Think of it as Medicare on growth hormones.

Setting aside ideological issues, the scope of Sanders’ plan and its lack of detail have raised questions about its seriousness. Some health care experts see it mainly as a political document to distinguish Sanders’ revolutionary ideas from Hillary Clinton’s incremental approach.

Sanders runs the risk of looking “like he is living in a fantasy land, for putting forward an idea he can’t possibly deliver during his term in office,” said Drew Altman, president of the nonpartisan Kaiser Family

Foundation.

Advertisement

Last Sunday, the Vermont senator released an 8-page outline of his “Medicare For All” plan, an idea he’s long advocated. The campaign estimates it would cost $1.38 trillion a year, paid for with new taxes that would take the place of private health insurance premiums. Here’s a look at some things Sanders left out:

NOT LIKE MEDICARE

Medicare doesn’t cover long-term care, not to mention dentures, and seniors face deductibles and costsharing when they go to the doctor. Many buy an additional private insurance policy to cover Medicare gaps. “BernieCare,” as it is being called, would be above and beyond.

Even if there are important differences with Medicare, supporters of Sanders’ plan say it’s similar in the sense that virtually all seniors are covered under that program. Sanders’ approach is also called ‘single-payer,’ because the government would become the steward of the health care system, currently about one-sixth of the economy.

PATH TO SAVINGS UNCLEAR

Sanders says his plan will cost $6 trillion less over 10 years than the current health care system. But his path to savings is unclear.

Advertisement

For starters, a government takeover of health care financing would eliminate all the useful signals about value that private payers generate. A few years ago, it became obvious Medicare had a problem paying for home medical equipment when government officials could find the same items on the Internet for much less.

Altman, the Kaiser foundation president, said it’s possible a single-payer system could produce substantial savings, for example by eliminating administrative duplication among insurers.

Any significant savings would have to come from reductions in payments to hospitals and doctors, not discussed in the campaign outline, he said.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.