3 min read

Morton Gold
Morton Gold
The second concert in the classical series of the Portland Symphony took place at Merrill Auditorium on Nov. 10 under the direction of their resident maestro, Robert Moody.

Dickens wrote “A Tale of Two Cities” and this concert could be described as one of two very distinct parts, before and after intermission.

The first selection consisted of the first suite excerpted from the ballet Cinderella, Op. 107, by the eminent Russian 20th century composer Sergei Prokofiev. It was evident from the start that Mr. Moody was fully engaged in bringing this piece to life and his orchestra responded in kind. There were eight scenes from the ballet, each depicting in music events from the story. There were many complimentary things that this listener observed: the sonority of the violins, especially in the first scene, the solo clarinet and trumpet in the second, the solo bassoon in the third, the seemingly effortless changes of tempi in the fourth, including some superb performances by the solo flute and violas, and the solo trumpet in the fifth. The sixth, (Cinderella goes to the Ball) was simply delightful. The seventh, Cinderella’s Waltz is the strangest waltz one can experience, (it is that way on purpose, again because of the story). The last is the most powerful and emotional scene, where the orchestra portrays the chiming of the clock, and there is the last appearance of Cinderella’s theme. Mr. Moody and the orchestra should be congratulated for a reading that was musically and dramatically moving.

Following the Prokofiev, the stage was reset to accommodate the reduced orchestra for a gem of a performance of the Symphony No. 69 by Franz Josef Haydn. It seemed to me that the musicians really enjoyed playing this work, as well they might. It is full of Haydn’s arsenal of things now known as his style. These include sudden stops, (grand pauses), a real crescendo (gradual increase of volume), and in this piece is the idea of joy. There were many exemplary things to observe, the ensemble of the first violins in the first movement, the delicious ritards at the end of phrases (in the minuet) as well as the solo oboe playing. Yes, and the leadership of Mr. Moody who really knew this symphony and drew a lovely performance of it from the orchestra.

Now we come to the one work following intermission, An Alice Symphony by David Del Tredici. The composer is a distinguished teacher and recognized composer. (Forgive me readers as I feel the Dark Side rising at this point.) How shall I count the ways? … The work is supposed to describe events in the Alice In Wonderland story. It could also be described as the Full Employment Practices Act for percussion players. They made an incessant racket nearly the breadth of the piece. My reaction to it was outraged boredom. The trombones and tuba played passages, which sounded like mischievous boys making noises on first playing their instruments. The winds made a variety of sounds in similar fashion.

Advertisement

The soprano soloist, Margaret Carpenter Haigh probably has a beautiful voice although one could not be certain of that as she was given a nearly impossible part to traverse. She screamed, hollered, and if that were not loud enough had to do the same with the aid of a bullhorn. There were also dancers involved, the Portland Ballet with choreography by Roberto Forleo. In their lurid red costumes they shimmied, sashayed and engaged in, ah … pelvic thrusts. Some might describe their efforts as examples of modern dance. I would describe the dancing simply as being tasteless. While I do applaud the performance of Alice, and the effort that went into it by Moody and the PSO, I can only wonder why it was programmed. I have no animus with atonal music (I think Berg’s Wozzeck is a masterpiece) but this piece is far from being a masterpiece. It may be a poster boy for all that went wrong with concert music in the 20th century. Sorry, I can only call them as a see (and hear) them. My problem is with the message, not the messenger.

The concert will be broadcast over Maine Public Radio on Wednesday, Nov. 25 at 8 p.m. and you can judge for yourself.

— Dr. Gold is a composer/conductor, retired educator and an arts reviewer for the Journal Tribune.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.