2 min read

BIDDEFORD — The attorney for Dylan Collins, the Biddeford teenager who has been charged with murder and arson in connection with an apartment fire that killed two people last year, has filed a motion to suppress certain evidence from the trial, arguing in part that Collins was detained illegally.

Attorney William Ashe filed the motion at York County Superior Court in Alfred on March 24. Collins, 19, has been charged with starting a fire in a stairwell at 35 Main St. on Sept. 18, 2014, which resulted in the deaths of James Ford, 21, and Michael Moore, 23, who rented a third-floor unit in the apartment building.

Collins’ mother, Donna Pitcher, called police with concerns over her son’s mental health both before and after the fire, Biddeford police told the Journal Tribune in November.

On Nov. 5, police took Collins into custody while he was working at Monkey Trunks in Saco and then transported him to Southern Maine Health Care for observation. Pitcher made a call to police earlier that day, but a transcript of the call does not detail what she said.

On Nov. 7, Collins was arrested and charged with two counts of depraved indifference murder and two counts of arson in connection with the fatal fire, and in December, he pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Advertisement

In the motion, Ashe writes, “(Collins) was detained without reasonable articulable suspicion that a crime had been committed.”

Ashe also claims police interrogated Collins without first reading him his Miranda rights, searched and arrested him “without adequate warrant” and later identified him using “an overly suggestive lineup.”

According to Justia.com, an online resource for legal information, a lineup in which only one person matches the witness’s description of the suspect, while the others look nothing like it, would be an example of a “highly suggestive lineup.” A 2008 article published in the journal Law and Human Behavior states that although common, “the defense argument for suppressing the identification in light of even the most highly suggestive procedures almost never prevails.”

In an email Monday, Ashe said he did not have a comment at this time regarding the motion.

A hearing has been scheduled for 1 p.m. on July 16 to address the motion to suppress evidence in the trial. Before that hearing, Justice Paul Fritzsche will also preside over a hearing to address the state’s request for access to some of Collins’ medical records, through a motion in limine, which was filed on April 24.

“The State would like access to the medical records of Mr. Collins from Southern Maine Health Care and Spring Harbor Hospital for the period shortly before the alleged murders and arson,” that motion reads. “The defendant, through counsel, objects and has not consented to the release of those medical records.”

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com. Associate Editor Dina Mendros contributed to this report.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.