3 min read

ALFRED — It took only a few hours for a jury to find Derek Poulin guilty of killing his grandmother and setting her house on fire.

Poulin, 26, stabbed and beat to death his grandmother, Patricia Noel, at her 44 Wesley Ave., Old Orchard Beach home and set it on fire on Oct. 23, 2012.

Poulin and his father, Reggie, lived at Noel’s home, but neither man was home around 2 p.m. when firefighters responded to a call the day of the fire and found the 61-year-old woman dead.

Prosecutors said there were more than 70 stab wounds found on Noel’s body, and the knife used to stab her was bent from so much use. Prosecutors said Poulin beat Noel with a golf club until the handle broke off. They said wounds in Noel’s head matched the size and shape of a wrench that was also used to beat her.

An autopsy showed that she was dead before fire broke out in the home.

Advertisement

Poulin’s trial began on June 10. Closing statements for both sides were heard Friday morning, June 19 and the jury reached its verdict. Friday afternoon. The 12-person jury found Poulin guilty of arson and intentional, knowing or depraved indifference murder.

“We’re very pleased with the verdict,” said Assistant Attorney General Leane Zainea after the jury made its decision.

As to a positive motive of the murder, Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber said letters written by Noel that were not presented to the jury documented Poulin’s abuse and disrespect toward Noel.

Macomber said Poulin was “a freeloader,” which corresponded with what he said during closing statements.

During closing arguments, Macomber said, that Poulin was an unemployed pot smoker whose mother said he needed “tough love” to get motivated to take care of tasks like making an appointment to the dentist or getting a new driver’s license.

The wife of Noel’s cousin spoke with Noel on the phone the month that she died, and testified that Noel said she wanted her grandson to leave the house, said Macomber. A letter written by Noel and found on the dining room table at the time of her death stated that Derek Poulin needed to find a new place to live, said Macomber.

Advertisement

Evidence against Poulin included him telling police the day of Noel’s death that he went to Portland to go to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles, a dental clinic and to visit his mother. However, records from the security camera at the BMV and computer system from the dental clinics show him going to the two places at a later time in the day than he told police.

Also, the clothing Poulin gave police did not match those found in BMV video footage. And, a reddish brown spot on one of his boots tested positively for blood, with Noel’s DNA being found on his boots.

Poulin’s attorney, Amy Fairfield, said she was not surprised with the verdict but she felt that the state did not thoroughly investigate the case.

During closing statements, she said, the state only focused on Derek Poulin.

Police investigators should have more thoroughly investigated Derek’s father Reggie Poulin, said Fairfield.

For instance, there was a gap between Reggie Poulin’s last job of the day at the landscaping company he worked at and the time he checked out the day of the murder, she said.

Advertisement

In addition, said she said, police should have examined Reggie’s truck, hands, as well as the clothing he wore the day of the murder.

Fairfield said she did just that. A private investigator hired by Fairfield about a month after Noel’s death collected the sneakers and clothing worn by Reggie Poulin that day. The sneakers were sent for analysis to a laboratory in Texas. Blood was found on one of the sneakers but DNA was not determined.

Reggie Poulin had his own possible motive to kill Noel.

He received $70,000 from insurance to have his mother’s house “beautifully remodeled,” and his mother’s pension was split between him and his sister.

Noel had told a friend that she wanted to change her will.

Poulin is scheduled to be sentenced on July 24.

— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.