4 min read

The South Portland planning and code office is now facing even more questions about a proposal by the NGL Supply Terminal Co. to move its operations from the Portland waterfront to the Rigby Rail Yard.

Last week staff with the planning department sat down with representatives from Maintenance & Turnaround Resources, or MTR, a firm providing engineering and legal guidance to NGL during which MTR argued that a local law governing above-ground storage tanks does not apply to the proposed project at the rail yard.

In a memo provided to the city of South Portland by Chuck Estabrooks, the vice president of operations for MTR, the company said what NGL is proposing to install are not above-ground storage tanks but pressure vessels, which are not regulated under the local ordinance.

In response, Tex Haeuser, the director of planning and development for the city, sent the memo along to Woodward & Curran, which was hired by South Portland earlier this month to sort through the debate regarding whether NGL’s proposed operations at the Rigby Yard comply with the city’s code.

According to an application for site plan review, which NGL submitted to the planning office earlier this year, the company wants to construct “six, 60,000-gallon, above-ground tanks to hold liquid propane” that would come in by rail and then be transferred to delivery trucks.

In addition to the new storage tanks, NGL is also proposing construction of an 1,800-square-foot office building, with associated parking and new security fencing.

Advertisement

Questions about whether the NGL proposal meets South Portland’s zoning standards were first raised by resident Eben Rose, who wrote an opinion column in the April 9 issue of the Current in which he argued the plan should have been “dead on arrival” because it violates a city ordinance that limits gas storage in excess of 10,000 cubic feet.

However, both Haeuser and Pat Doucette, South Portland’s director of code enforcement, told City Manager Jim Gailey in separate memos that they felt the proposal by NGL is a permitted use because the product being stored in the tanks would be “primarily in a liquid state.”

After Rose enlisted the help of City Councilor Brad Fox, city staff decided it would be best to hire a third party to review the issues being raised. Now Woodward & Curran has also been asked to review the pressure vessel question that MTR has brought forward.

This week Haeuser said the requested review by Woodward & Curran, an environmental engineering firm located in Portland, is still ongoing and he is unsure when the final report will be ready.

Both Rose and Fox have told the Current that their concerns with the NGL proposal are for the health and safety of residents, as well as holding city staff accountable for following the zoning rules put into place by elected officials.

In a prior interview, Fox said, “Our codes protect our citizens, and I want our city staff to follow the code of ordinances as they are written. Twenty years ago, the citizens of this city lobbied the council to limit new tanks for petroleum-based products. The council adopted section 27-1517 and staff is failing to apply it.”

Advertisement

But now, through its contractor, NGL is raising the question of whether South Portland’s ordinances even apply to its proposed project at the Rigby Yard.

In the memo written by Estabrooks, he says, “Industry codes establish two widely differing sets of standards for above-ground storage tanks and pressure vessels. This is because the former are intended to store liquids at atmospheric pressure, while the latter store liquids at pressures above atmospheric pressure, and thus must be subject to different design, construction, maintenance and inspection requirements.”

The memo further states that “The term “above-ground storage tanks” is used broadly … (but) generally speaking, they are containers for the storage of substances such as gasoline or diesel fuel that are located above ground, partially buried, bunkered or in an underground vault.”

Estabrooks argues a pressure vessel is the correct term for what NGL is proposing in South Portland since the company intends to store its liquid petroleum gas at a high pressure to keep it in a liquid state.

In closing, Estabrooks says, “The containers proposed by NGL for use in the Rigby Yard … are pressure vessels subject to specific codes for pressure vessels. They are not, therefore, above-ground storage tanks. As a result, Section 27-1517 of the South Portland code, which applies only to ‘above-ground storage tanks,’ does not apply to this project.”

This week Rose told the Current he’s disappointed that the planning staff is allowing NGL “to equivocate on terms” and that city staff is “inexplicably” accommodating the company in finding a loophole in South Portland’s zoning rules.

He also argued that the city has an overriding rule that states all “ordinances are to be read in a way the benefits the health, safety, convenience, and general welfare of the inhabitants,” which should also be applied to the NGL proposal.

Comments are no longer available on this story