4 min read

It was billed as a Gala Concert and that is exactly what transpired at the Merrill Auditorium on the evening of the May 2. The three living former conductors (Paul Vermel, Bruce Hangen and Toshiyuki Shimoda as well as current conductor Robert Moody) took turns conducting the Portland Symphony Orchestra. The occasion was the conclusion of the 90th anniversary season commemorating the founding of the orchestra. The layman might well wonder what the presence of a different conductor might make since the composer indicates what he wanted to take place in the written score. In actuality, it makes a huge difference. The painter has his work framed and hung up on a wall for all to see. People may discuss what it means or is supposed to be and so on, but essentially the painter’s work is finished. He does not need an interpreter. The work is there for all to see. The writer writes his words and communicates directly with the reader. While people may differ about what the words mean, the words are there for all to see. A play does need a director, but once his work is done and the actors do the director’s bidding, there is not a huge difference from one performance to the next. Character “A” enters from stage right or left, moves here or there and so on with character “B” or “C.” The lighting does not change from one performance to the next or when the music plays, the volume and speed of the music has been predetermined and so on. Yes, while there may be some variations from one performance to the next, these will usually not be structural.

There are many differences from one orchestral performance to the next and the conductor makes a world of difference. This concert proved this assertion. The first work, Beethoven’s Egmont Overture was conducted by Paul Vermel who was the orchestra’s conductor from 1967 to 1975. While he may be described as a senior citizen, he conducted with the power and passion of someone half of his age. He conducted the music, molding phrases and did not feel the need to beat time in places. He was rewarded with colors and timbre that suggested a major European orchestra to me. The saying that there is no pro like an old pro was borne out here by Vermel. The next conductor was Bruce Hangel, the orchestra’s conductor from 1984 to 1986. The work he conducted was “The Fountains of Rome” by Respighi. Mr. Hangen exhibited a fine understanding of the piece with its many changes of texture and mood. The orchestra responded to his direction with a nuanced performance. He acknowledged the efforts of soloists and each section.

The next work, “Symphonic Metamorphosis on Themes by Carl Maria von Weber” composed by Paul Hindemith. It was conducted by Mr. Shimoda who conducted the orchestra from 1986 to 2006. I have neither seen nor heard him prior to this evening. While it was obvious that he was a capable conductor who had a clear beat, there were other factors that mitigated the enjoyment of his performance for me. The tempo of the piece varied from fast to recklessly fast. The best movement of the four was the second. The soloists in the third attempted to play their lines with expression but Mr. Shimoda was more concerned with maintaining the speed that he wanted to conduct the work. He was fortunate that the flautist was able to get in all her notes at the speed he took the music. I felt that he was determined to emphasize a lighter timbre and speed over expression. It should be noted that the orchestra did what he asked of them. After intermission, the sole work performed was “Also Sprach Zathustra” by Richard Strauss. This work can be the mother lode for teachers of music appreciation. In fact, however, if one disregards the story line and even the titles of the nine sections, it is a symphony in one movement. Calling for a huge orchestra, which some might refer to as the full employment practices act for musicians because there was only room for a few slender sardines on the stage, in many places Strauss used the huge orchestra as a box of colors because he had only a few instruments playing at one time. Mr. Moody conducted the work with passion, power and understanding.

The performers seem to outdo themselves: among the many significant soloists in this piece one must single out Joseph Foley (the 1st trumpet), the first desk wind and string players, particularly concert master Charles Dimmick, and the entire string bass section. After the conclusion of the work, he brought up the three past conductors and the audience joined the orchestra in singing/playing “Happy Birthday.”

While a return appearance of each would be welcome, of the three former conductors, I for one would like to have Mr. Vermel return again. The orchestra today is head and shoulders above what he had to work with during his tenure. If today’s outing was any indication, we would all benefit from his return engagement.

It has been a memorable year of fine music making. One looks forward to another.

— Dr. Gold is a composer/conductor and an arts reviewer for the Journal Tribune.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.