Last week the city council and school board held the public hearing on the proposed 2015-16 budget. While the budget may change over the next two months, past history has shown that very little will change in the final budget. The taxpayers of South Portland will once again be ignored and there will be another unnecessary tax increase of about 3 percent.
I spoke at the public hearing, requesting that the city and school officials stop preparing “dishonest” budgets and if they did there would be no need to have any tax increase. Many dislike my “outrageous” classification of the budget as dishonest (and therefore the city officials as dishonest). However, the facts are clear, the budgets for the past five years have been prepared using either dishonest or irrational revenue and expense estimates. If these budgets were honestly prepared, then the city officials are not dishonest, they are just incompetent. Either way, there is no justification for the yearly budgeting errors that would get officials in other cities fired. Only in South Portland could excessive tax collections due to either dishonest budgeting or incompetence be defended and rewarded.
I have written several times in the past about the irresponsible spending in South Portland. While there can be some weak arguments made to support the current level of spending, there should be no debate about raising excessive taxes from budgeting errors. The resulting accumulation of surpluses and assets, well in excess of South Portland’s needs and well in excess of surrounding communities and cities of similar size, should never be allowed. The problem is that the city manager and the superintendent are not held accountable for budgeting errors.
The size of the budgeting errors and excessive surpluses is outrageous, especially when city officials are “crying wolf” claiming there would be significant financial impact if the governor’s tax proposal is passed and revenue sharing is eliminated for the 2016-17 year. In February, South Portland’s finance director testified in Augusta against the proposed cut in revenue sharing. While I agree that revenue sharing should be restored and will have a significant impact on many cities and towns, South Portland is not one of those cities. The total proposed cut to South Portland would be about $1.2 million. This $1.2 million needs to be compared to the average budgeting errors of $3.3 million a year for the four years ended June 30, 2014, as reported in the audited financial statements. The resulting excessive property tax collections averaged 6 percent per year more than needed.
For the year ended June 30, 2014, the actual revenues were $2.5 million more than budgeted and the actual expenses were $1.1 million less than budgeted for a net budgeting error of $3.7 million. It is not like these budgeting errors were from unknown issues, as I had warned the City Council more than a year ago that the 2014 budget would have at least a $3.5 million budgeting error and that the 2015 budget should be corrected to reflect this fact. I have correctly predicted similar budgeting errors every year for the past four years. South Portland’s budgets for the past several years can best be described as dishonest, non-transparent and prepared with very little concern with the many taxpayers who struggle to pay the yearly unnecessary tax increases.
The city will argue that it needs to have a surplus, so overcharging taxes is required to build a responsible surplus to cover future unexpected costs and to pay for non-bonded capital acquisitions. I agree that the city does need to have a reasonable surplus, but the facts make it clear it has accumulated excessive surpluses. The city’s net assets, which is the value of its assets (cash, investments and property) less its liabilities (short-term accounts payables and debts) is the best measure of its financial position. The June 30, 2014, audited financial statements reported total city net assets of $167.1 million, which was a $3.8 million increase over the prior year. If you exclude the business-type assets (sewer district and other) the governmental activities net assets were $105.9 million. The $105.9 million, when compared to Augusta, Auburn, Bangor and Biddeford, illustrates how excessive South Portland’s net assets are.
Based on the audited actual revenue and expense numbers for the four years ended June 30, 2014, no honest financially competent city official would prepare and pass the current proposed budget. Unfortunately the city council and school board members are not financially competent. Of course they are not to blame; the blame goes to the voters in South Portland who continue to elect them.
I have always hoped that eventually the voters would wake up one day and change direction, but of course these are the same people who voted to “legalize” marijuana recently. Who knows what they are smoking on election days.
Al DiMillo is a retired CPA who lives in South Portland.
Comments are no longer available on this story