3 min read

AUGUSTA — The Maine Human Rights Commission has found no reasonable grounds in a complaint by the Lyman recreation director against the town.

Lyman Recreation Director Lee Schatz filed a complaint in October of 2013 with the commission, alleging he was unlawfully discriminated against in retaliation for informing the town of illegal activity in the workplace, according to a report by Investigator Michele Dion.

Schatz has been employed by the town since 2003, according to Dion’s report.

In February of 2012, Schatz raised concerns with the Lyman Board of Selectmen regarding a mowing contract he believed to be illegal, according to Dion’s report. The contract had been awarded to a former selectman and then renewed without any public process or bidding, and Schatz told selectmen that the multi-year contract was violation of state law, according to Dion.

The board allowed the former selectman to finish mowing during the 2012 season, and put the job out to bid for the next year, according to Dion. The specifications were created by Schatz and a contractor friend of his. Schatz’s friend intended to bid on the contract, and was told by the town that his participation in the creation of the mowing specifications created a conflict of interest, according to the report. Schatz believed Lyman was trying to make extra work for him, according to Dion.

Advertisement

Schatz said two board members went out of their way to make demeaning comments to him and falsely accused him of wrongdoing, according to the report.

The board signed a mowing contract in July of 2013, and Schatz told the board he thought the contract was illegal, as the board intended on making changes after it was signed.

Lyman chose a contractor to fertilize some of the town fields, a task that Schatz had overseen for ten years, according to Dion. After a dispute about the performance of the fertilizer, the town decided to discontinue the agreement with the contractor, and Schatz contacted the contractor to retrieve the town’s keys, according to the report.

A board member told Schatz he didn’t have the authority to tell the contractor to stay off the town fields, according to the report.

Schatz claims the town has continually interfered with his ability to do his job, according to the report. He said one selectmen board member redeveloped Lyman’s mowing specifications even though he had agreed with the board to give Schatz and his committee the responsibility of handling the fertilization of town fields.

The town states that in February of 2012, two days after Schatz expressed concern that an illegal procedure may have occurred, the board of selectmen sought legal advice from the Maine Municipal Association, which said that an extension of the contract made by the board was effectively an approval of it.

Advertisement

The town also sought advice from the town attorney who advised the contract was valid, according to the report.

The town stated that one of the two people that Schatz claims made demeaning comments about him was not a board member at the time of the alleged controversy.

The town stated that while Schatz may have been offended because the 2013 mowing contract was not awarded to his friend, the allegation that the contract is illegal is not supported by facts, according to Dion’s report.

Dion concluded in her report that there was no reasonable ground to believe the town of Lyman retaliated against Schatz in violation of the Whistleblower’s Protection Act.

Dion said the town took Schatz’s report of potential illegal action seriously, sought advice from the Maine Municipal Association and from the town attorney and was told the contract was not illegal.

Dion stated Schatz may have been frustrated with the Board of Selectmen for overruling some of his decisions, but the board, as his employer and supervisor, is the ultimate decision-making authority.

Advertisement

Dion said that Schatz appeared to have been in conversations that were antagonistic on both sides. She said that Schatz was not threatened, and criticism he received appears to have been related to “genuine issues” with his work performance.

The three-member commission voted unanimously at its Feb. 23 meeting that it found no grounds that the town retaliated against Schatz for engaging in protected whistleblower activity, according to meeting minutes.

— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.