7 min read

Staff Writer

BIDDEFORD — Your sneakers smack the tar at a steady clip, you can feel your heart thumping faster and faster, and sweat trickles down your forehead.

Later a friend might ask, “How was your afternoon run?” and you might shrug and say, “Pretty good.”

That is unless you’re wearing a fitness-tracking band ”“ one of those sleek straps of rubber that seem to be taking over the exercise landscape. In that case you could tap into your smartphone and within seconds give a much more detailed report: “I ran 2.33 miles in 25 minutes and 16 seconds and burned 312 calories.”

Fitness bands come in a variety of sizes, brands, and, of course, prices ”“ from the cheapest devices, which cost about $50 to $100, to the most expensive ones, which can cost up to $250. Essentially, the cheaper the device, the less it can do. The $100 Fitbit Flex, for example, tracks the number of steps you take, the distance you travel, the calories you burn and your sleeping patterns, while higher-priced bands can track your heart rate, how many flights of stairs you climb and even show you texts and emails.

Advertisement

Most bands can also sync, or connect with, a smartphone, such as an iPhone or Android device, to let users view comprehensive fitness statistics from weeks and even months in the past.

But as more people throw their watches aside in favor of these multi-functional alternatives, health experts contemplate the benefits ”“ as well as the drawbacks ”“ associated with this new technology. Many wonder, specifically, whether or not these bands are actually changing their users’ exercise behavior.

Michael Sheldon, a physical therapist and director of the University of New England’s Department of Physical Therapy, said Wednesday that he views fitness bands in both a positive and negative light.

In terms of what’s good about them, Sheldon said they allow users to set reasonable exercise goals for themselves, perhaps helping them develop better exercise behavior ”“ at least temporarily.

“With these types of devices you can set reasonable goals,” he said, and once you achieve those goals, you become motivated to set and overcome more of them.

Michael Burman, an associate professor of psychology at UNE, relayed a similar theory about fitness bands last week.

Advertisement

“Very specific goals work, and very general goals don’t,” he said.

For example, said Burman, if you say, “I want to be healthy,” that goal isn’t specific enough. You’ll be instantly satisfied by just saying or thinking it, he said, whereas if you specify your goal, which these bands allow you to do easily, you won’t be satisfied until you meet that goal.

“When I say, ”˜I want to take 10,000 steps a day,’ I won’t be happy until I do it,” he said. “The specificity of our goal guides our behavior change.”

On Friday, Greg Hatheway, a sports performance coach at the OA Performance Center in Saco, put this notion of goal setting into terms of the technology’s ability to let its users “quantify a baseline.”

A baseline, as it relates to exercise, is simply a person’s starting point. For example, on day one, how much can you bench-press? How fast can you run a mile? How many pull-ups can you do without stopping?

“I think they’re great as far as being able to quantify a baseline of what people are doing day to day,” Hatheway said about fitness bands. “If you’re someone who’s looking to just increase your activity level, and you know your baseline amount of steps per day is 500, obviously it’s easy to increase that to 1,000. ”¦ So I think as far as being a measuring tool, they’re really beneficial for someone who’s working out on their own. It gives them an idea, numbers-wise, of what they can do, what they need to do to improve.”

Advertisement

Hatheway stressed that it’s harder to increase your level of exercise when you “have no objectifiable measurement of what you’ve been doing every day.”

Similarly, Melissa Densmore, a personal trainer at Saco Sport and Fitness, spoke Friday about fitness bands’ ability to motivate people to exercise more.

“The more information people have, the better choices they can choose to make, so I do think that they certainly have a place,” she said. “They’re valid. They’re a useful tool, and I really like the ones that monitor heart rate. ”¦ I think the ones that do the heart rate and calories and track your steps and all of that are a great motivating tool for people.”

But, at the same time, Densmore said she doubts whether the lower-priced fitness bands, which “mostly just track your steps,” are worth their price tag.

But while health experts may see plenty of benefits tied to fitness bands, that’s not to say they don’t raise any concerns at all. For one, explained Sheldon, they’re a very young technology, which means the long-term effects they have on their users isn’t fully understood yet.

“They’ve really not been around that long,” he said, and while some research suggests there’s a link between fitness bands and a short-term behavior change pertaining to exercise, “those same studies have pointed out ”¦ they may not hold that motivation in the long-run.”

Advertisement

Burman brought up a similar point. Although it’s easy to set and meet goals using fitness bands, it’s just as easy to forget about meeting those goals, he said. It’s not like you have a personal trainer breathing down your neck, urging you to take one more lap or push through one more rep.

Sheldon said he thinks there are currently two tangible drawbacks to fitness bands. One, they are prohibitively expensive to some people. “I would question whether there’s accessibility across the socioeconomic scale,” he said.

And two, they can be difficult to use ”“ at least to their full potential ”“ for people who aren’t very tech savvy.

Furthermore, said Sheldon, we see tech trends come and go all the time, so who’s to say fitness bands aren’t just “a novelty” ”“ merely “the newest ”˜next big thing’”? That conjecture aside, he thinks fitness bands are here to stay ”“ and in a potentially revolutionizing way to boot.

When you go to the doctor’s and have your heart rate and blood pressure measured, that only provides physicians with data from a single point in time, said Sheldon. But as fitness bands become more technologically advanced and perhaps even able to measure blood pressure, they could be incorporated into the health information system, he said, helping keep both patients and doctors more informed and 24-7.

“You bring (the band) with you ”¦ and the physician gets a look at your activity level since the last time they’ve seen you,” he said. “That’s going to be a very powerful health information tool.”

Advertisement

Specifically in the world of physical therapy, Sheldon said he sees these bands becoming a valuable tool for determining whether a patient is continuing to be active after, for example, being released from a rehabilitation facility.

“(A person) may go to rehab,” he said, “and then they get discharged from that setting, and a question that everybody’s interested in knowing is: When they go home, do they continue to be active?”

But Sheldon also acknowledged that as this technology dives deeper and deeper into medicine, more and more privacy issues will likely surface.

“I don’t think that’s been well thought through with these devices, because now, all of a sudden, I’m carrying around a bunch of protected health information,” he said. “I can see the potential for misuse of this health information.”

And while some may be weary of fitness bands, others simply don’t see the need for them. Kyle Sikes, owner and trainer at CrossFit207 Training Center in Sanford, said Friday that while these bands may have a place somewhere, he doesn’t think that place is CrossFit.

CrossFit, a form of exercise that has gained popularity in recent years, measures how quickly you can do things, such as lift a certain weight, said Sikes.

Advertisement

“It’s just generally about work capacity,” he said, so a simple timer does the trick in assessing a person’s progress in CrossFit. In other words, there’s no need for all the frills of an expensive device.

So, what’s the verdict on fitness bands? For the most part, health and fitness experts agree they’re a valuable tool for exercise. But the jury is still out on just how valuable.

When looking at the “big picture,” Sheldon said he’s undoubtedly on board with anything that might get people exercising ”“ or even just moving ”“ more frequently.

“A lot of the chronic diseases we deal with as a society have some relationship to inactivity,” he said, and one of the best things about these bands is the fact that they allow people to find a means of increasing activity through everyday life.

“People may not be thinking about taking the stairs at work ”¦ versus taking the elevator as exercise,” he said, but these bands change that. “(They) get people to re-conceptualize what exercise is, and they can do it ”¦ in the course of their daily life.”

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.