4 min read

OGUNQUIT — For those who know and love the Ogunquit Playhouse, it may not come as a surprise that the 1937 building has historic significance in Maine, but it took eight years and extensive research by historians to prove that the playhouse is one of the nation’s most important theatrical treasures.

According to Bradford Kenney, executive artistic director for the playhouse, the building was first listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1995. When Kenney and staff took over management of the playhouse in 2006, the building was almost 70 years old and in need of major repairs.

“Everything needed updating. The electrical service wasn’t appropriate anymore, we didn’t have a sprinkler system to meet fire safety codes,” said Kenney in a recent phone interview.

Kenney and his staff share a common passion for historic buildings. He assumed that because the playhouse was already listed on the National Register it would be eligible for grants from the National Parks Service, which has oversight of all nationally registered places.

Yet, when he began to apply for financial grants from the National Parks Service to bring the building up to code, Kenney learned that the Ogunquit Playhouse only had a local historic designation.

Advertisement

“There are three designations on the form: national, state and local. Unless you have that other box checked, you don’t qualify for the grants,” he said.

What’s the difference in a locally significant historic designation versus a nationally historic designation? A great deal apparently.

“You have to reapply to the United States Department of the Interior. We needed real scholarly research to demonstrate how the playhouse changed theater in America,” Kenney said.

Enter Dr. Kathryn Edney, a professor of history at Regis College in Weston, Massachusetts.

Edney met Cheryl Farley, a lifelong resident of historic York and the director of marketing and public relations at the Ogunquit Playhouse, while she was completing her Ph.D. in American History with an emphasis on American Theater. In 2008, Edney was enlisted by the Playhouse to elevate the building’s historic designation to the national level.

While those involved in the Playhouse knew all about Walter Hartwig, idolizing him as the Broadway showman who brought Manhattan’s theatrical elite to the rest of the country, Edney had to find the proof.

Advertisement

“Hartwig was in a business that was all about promotion but he himself was not a self-promoter. Summer stock theater isn’t something that has a lot of (historic) documentation so this was one of the first extensive research projects on the subject,” said Farley.

Through her research, Edney was able to demonstrate that Hartwig was a nationally significant figure within both Broadway and summer theater circles.

One example she uncovered was a telegram discovered in the private papers of “Gone With the Wind” Producer David O. Selznick.

“His secretary needed more information on a distribution matter and Selznick said: ”˜Anything you need to know about summer theater you can learn from speaking with Hartwig.’ To have these Hollywood producers immediately think of him as the go-to guy for summer theater was significant,” said Edney.

Other sources included a poem by Ogden Nash published in a 1935 edition of Life Magazine.

“The premise of the poem is that theater should not just be for those who can afford New York ticket prices, and that plays only truly exist when they are performed. These are precisely the sentiments Walter Hartwig put into action by founding the Ogunquit Playhouse,” Edney wrote in the application.

Advertisement

It was numerous examples like this that helped Edney document how Hartwig and the Playhouse influenced summer theater over time.

With the guidance of Christi Mitchell, national coordinator for the Maine Historic Preservation Commission, the Playhouse submitted a new application to the keeper of the registrar in 2009.

According to Mitchell, upgrading the historic significance from local to national distinction doesn’t happen very often.

“In the 13 years I’ve been here, we’ve only upgraded one other building to the national level,” she said.

Yet the job for Edney and the playhouse wasn’t done yet. The keeper of the registrar had the final say and according to Mitchell, the application was kicked back again for more evidence of the building’s architectural significance.

“The building is probably the only purposefully built historic playhouse in the country. Most summer theater really did take place in barns. What was needed was a reframing of the application to tell the whole story,” Edney said.

Advertisement

“Sometimes historic attention to certain properties can change over time. We all stood back and looked at the bigger picture to find what was really important. At the time the Playhouse was built, all of Route 1 was creating visually attractive locations to draw in the summer tourist,” Mitchell said.

Ultimately, it was the story of Hartwig, the location of the playhouse as a summer tourist destination, and its specific purpose as a summer theater that persuaded a review board to take yet another look five years later.

The final application was sent to the Department of the Interior on Sept. 9, 2014 and on Oct. 15, the Playhouse received notice of its upgrade on the National Register of Historic Places with both the local and national boxes ticked.

“It is a recognition by our nation’s government of both the cultural and historic influence of the Ogunquit Playhouse on what American theater is today,” said Kenney. “Now we can make some long term heritage plans for the building to ensure it can be enjoyed for another hundred years.”



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.