3 min read

BIDDEFORD — The Biddeford football classification saga still isn’t over, as the Tigers have appealed a decision by the Maine Principals’ Association’s Interscholastic Management Committee that forces Biddeford to fulfill a four-year term in Class A that the Tigers petitioned up for.

Both Biddeford athletic director Dennis Walton and MPA executive director Dick Durost have confirmed that the school has appealed the decision the IMC made back in November.

Biddeford will get a second hearing with the IMC on Friday, Jan. 30.

The IMC’s decision in November reversed a passed motion by the MPA’s Football Committee that would have allowed Biddeford to drop down to Class B in football for the 2015 season.

Biddeford superintendent of schools Jeremy Ray said the IMC based its decision on standing firm on an MPA rule passed in 1983 that holds schools to the four-year commitment after a placement petition has been accepted. Ray said the committee also didn’t want to create bye weeks for teams in Western Class A due to Biddeford’s move down to Class B, as well as not having another team equipped to take Biddeford’s spot in Class A if it were to keep 16 teams in the highest class.

Advertisement

Biddeford stressed player safety and proper placement when it went before the Football Committee this past fall, and Ray said the same holds true with the school’s appeal.

Ray said the school officially decided to appeal the decision in mid-December, but began the process immediately after the IMC hearing in November. Durost said the process for appeal will be the same as the initial hearing with the IMC, and that the appealing “school must provide assurances that they have additional or new information not provided at the first hearing.”

Ray said Biddeford’s appeal is based on enrollment outlook, additional player safety concerns and a questioning of the MPA’s priorities.

“The reasons they gave me are not in the best interests of the kids,” said Ray.

Ray said player safety isn’t just about individual player injuries, but about attrition as well. He said Biddeford had to cancel its last four junior varsity football games this past fall due to injuries.

Ray said that projections show a continuing decline in enrollment at Biddeford High School, from 788 this school year to 742 in three years and 719 in six years. He said those numbers come in at 100 students less than the MPA’s cut-off projections for the same outlook.

Advertisement

Ray said while he understands that Biddeford is being held to a four-year commitment, he feels the MPA is arbitrary in its enforcement of some rules. For one, the MPA has allowed cooperative teams to exist in classes they are too big for ”“ co/op teams cannot be larger than the largest team in its division, which Ray contends the MPA has allowed.

Ray said the IMC’s decision makes it seem as though the MPA is more concerned with avoiding bye weeks ”“ and setting precedents ”“ than player safety.

The chances of Biddeford’s appeal being successful are cloudy. Durost said that in his 14 years as head of the MPA, and in reviewing IMC minutes from the 20 years prior, no school has ever asked to be released from a four-year commitment.

Ray believes he has a solid case for getting out of that commitment, but he also was resigned to saying “I’m not going to hold my breath.”

— Sports Staff Writer Wil Kramlich can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 323 or sports@journaltribune.com. Follow him on Twitter @WilTalkSports.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.