6 min read

By ANGELO J. VERZONI

Staff Writer

BIDDEFORD — Gov. Paul LePage’s recently proposed state budget for the next two fiscal years has ruffled more than a few feathers.

Nonprofits have been reaching for the panic button over the possibility of having to pay property taxes, while local governments are concerned ”“ among other things ”“ over the fact that the governor’s plan calls for the elimination of municipal revenue sharing.

But city officials in Biddeford say it’s too early to be worrying about the budget, and they have a point; in 2013, it took until mid-July to enact the state budget for the fiscal years 2014-15, suggesting the state is in for roughly six months of debate before anything actually comes to a head.

Advertisement

City Manager John Bubier said on Thursday that he thinks the governor’s budget proposal is more or less his way of sparking a debate about tax reform, as opposed to a reflection of his unyielding desires surrounding the issues.

“I honestly think that the signal from the governor is, ”˜I want to talk about tax reform.’ And I think that he has put some things in the proposal that need to be discussed,” said Bubier. “I don’t think he’s saying, ”˜I need all of these things at the same time.’ I think it’s designed to create a conversation.”

The governor’s proposal was released on Jan. 9, and it includes several elements that have garnered indignant reactions on the part of Maine municipalities.

Specifically, the governor’s proposal to eliminate the state’s municipal revenue sharing program has caught the critical eye of municipalities statewide, according to a Jan. 12 email written by Geoff Herman of the Maine Municipal Association. Under the governor’s proposal, municipal revenue sharing would first be reduced, before being entirely eliminated by July 2016, providing the state with an additional $250 million over the course of the next two fiscal years, according to Herman.

The amount of revenue-sharing funds Biddeford is expected to receive from the state for fiscal year 2015, which started in July of last year and will end in June of this year, is $1,173,352.08, according to the Revenue Forecasting Committee’s most recent projections. That means if LePage’s proposal passes, the city would likely be facing a loss of more than $2 million over the course of the next two fiscal years.

There are a couple of measures built into LePage’s budget, however, that aim to counter the loss municipalities would face from the elimination of revenue sharing; the most financially significant would be allowing municipalities to tax properties that are currently tax-exempt ”“ namely, nonprofits.

Advertisement

Under this part of the proposal, which would take effect on April 1, 2016, nonprofits with property valued at more than $500,000 would be required to pay 50 percent of the property taxes on any value exceeding that amount, according to Herman. In other words, if a nonprofit had property valued at $750,000, it would be responsible for paying half of what an owner would typically pay for property worth $250,000. Churches and tax-exempt properties owned by the government would be immune to this tax hike.

Nonprofits currently enjoy a 100 percent tax exemption when it comes to local property taxes, so it’s no surprise that LePage’s proposal has left many of them teed off. Educational institutions and health care facilities, which constitute some of the largest nonprofits in the state, are particularly upset.

In Biddeford, there are 143 nonprofits, 33 of which would be taxable under the proposed budget’s new regulations, Frank Yattaw, the city’s assessor, explained on Thursday. Collectively, they carry an assessment value of nearly $88.5 million, which translates to a tax revenue of $1,679,926.62 for the city, he said.

Despite the presumable appeal of extra funds in the city’s pocket, Yattaw said he doesn’t see this part of the budget passing, while Bubier pointed to the fact that taxing nonprofits is far from a new idea, implying that this aspect of LePage’s proposal isn’t something nonprofits should be necessarily panicking about.

“It’s not something that doesn’t have a lot of mileage on it,” he said. “We’ve been having this discussion about nonprofits for the last 40 years … And there’s a reason it hasn’t passed before. Part of the reason, I suspect, is because we haven’t spent enough time talking about it.”

Bubier also shed some light on the reasoning behind the idea.

Advertisement

“Those organizations utilize the city’s services,” he said of nonprofits. But at the same time, he added, the University of New England, for example, already makes payments in lieu of taxes to the tune of $100,000 each year.

During a university event on Wednesday, UNE President Danielle Ripich spoke passionately against LePage’s proposal to impose property taxes on nonprofits, making the argument that UNE is already a lucrative asset to the community.

“We are a valuable asset, and (the state needs) to help us grow and bring more students in, not do these things that limit our ability to give scholarships,” said Ripich. “It’s not smart economics.”

When Ripich called UNE students “little ATM cards,” laughter erupted from the crowd of a few dozen. But that metaphor aside, her point was clear.

According to a document provided by Ripich, UNE student spending drives $33 million in sales to Maine businesses, while over 15,000 visitors to UNE generate $11.5 million each year in sales for local businesses. Furthermore, from 2011-12, more than 1,000 UNE students provided 370,000 clinical care hours to Maine patients ”“ service valued at $21.2 million. Overall, in 2013, UNE’s total economic impact on the state of Maine was $738 million, according to the document ”“ an increase from just $550 million in 2010 and $233 million in 2007.

UNE is also a hub of employment for southern Maine, said Ripich; in fact, she said, it’s the second-largest employer in York County.

Advertisement

From 2009-13, the rate on new job creation in Maine grew by 1.6 percent, while the rate of new job creation at UNE increased more than 20 percent, she said, and for the governor to consider a measure that would hinder that growth is not smart.

Southern Maine Health Care, with major campuses in Biddeford and Sanford, as well as smaller locations throughout the county, would be hit hard by the proposal as well.

“Any increases in taxes is something that we’re gravely concerned about,” Sue Hadiaris, SMHC’s senior vice president of planning and development, said on Friday.

Last year, she said, SMHC provided $37 million in health care without compensation to people in the community, and she said this proposed tax increase would “impede (SMHC’s) ability to provide health care to people who need it.”

Hospitals in general are already facing some very “challenging financial obstacles,” she explained, especially with recent cuts to Medicaid payments. Furthermore, she said, SMHC employs 2,200 people in York County, making it the largest employer in the county ”“ and the governor’s proposal could threaten SMHC’s ability to retain those jobs.

Speaking on behalf of the LePage administration, Jonathan LaBonte, who is the director of the governor’s Office of Policy and Management, said on Friday that imposing these taxes on nonprofits is a means of alleviating the burden taxpayers currently carry so that municipalities can provide services to nonprofits ”“ such as the services of their police, fire and public-works departments.

Advertisement

“This is an opportunity for communities to provide those services to nonprofits while taking the burden off of taxpayers’ backs,” he said.

On top of cutting revenue sharing and imposing property taxes on nonprofits, Gov. LePage’s proposed state budget includes other significant changes that concern municipalities statewide. The MMA’s 70-member Legislative Policy Committee is scheduled to convene on Jan. 22 to discuss each one in detail.

— Staff Writer Angelo J. Verzoni can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or averzoni@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.