3 min read

Some gifts are not really gifts at all. A gift of St. Bernard puppies might be problematic for someone living in a small apartment. A drum set for a toddler– maybe not the stuff of sincere parental “thank yous.”

With this in mind, how should we interpret the earmarked “gift” from a private company of $2,500 for the purchase of Tasers to the South Portland Police Department? This “gift” was bundled with other contributions from businesses and individual citizens for various civic facilities and was gratefully accepted – with no eyebrows raised – by the South Portland City Council on Nov. 17.

Why Tasers? Is there some uptick in the crime rate in South Portland that necessitates Tasers? Is there some longstanding problem of lethal force by the SoPo PD that will allow Taser to ultimately save lives? Emphatically “no” on both counts.

Tasers were originally marketed as a more humane alternative to lethal force, but with their massive deployment in increasingly militarized police forces across the world, they are now considered “intermediate weapons.” Presumably, this means that they are intermediate between deadly and just really nasty, but in practice what this means is that really nasty weapons can be used in situations where really nasty weapons are not necessary.

Just this week in Victoria, Texas, a lawyer for a police officer that was fired for Tasing a 76-year-old man for a minor traffic stop claimed that there “was nothing unreasonable” about using that level of force. A dash cam caught the whole incident on video and is available online. This incident is not isolated.

Amnesty International reported that more than 500 individuals in the United States have died from the use of Tasers between 2001 and 2012, and 90 percent of those individuals were unarmed. Rather than being used as an alternative to lethal force in situations where the officer is threatened by armed suspects, they are used increasingly to punish non-compliance with an order. Lack of uniform standards of conduct has allowed Taser abuse to proliferate. Incidents are increasing where the elderly, mentally ill, people already in handcuffs or other physical restraints and even children are being Tased.

Advertisement

But the plot thickens.

The “gift”-giver of Tasers to the SoPo PD was none other than Portland Pipeline Corp. Yes, this is the same corporation that continues to threaten to sue the city for adopting the Clear Skies Ordinance this summer. Yes this is the same corporation that marshaled some $700,000 to defeat the similar Waterfront Protection Ordinance initiative the previous year – a year that saw massive public rallies and demonstrations in support of the ordinance. Yes this is the same corporation that is increasingly opaque about its operations and future plans and is, by some accounts, struggling to survive in a rapidly shifting global oil market. Why the sudden interest in Tasers?

Portland Pipeline seems to REALLY want to export Canadian tar sands despite strong local opposition. And if through hook or crook they get their way, might there be opposition? Organized opposition? Acts of civil disobedience? In Texas in 2012 two Keystone XL protesters were pepper-sprayed and Tased while in handcuffs by police and with the encouragement of a senior TransCanada manager who as at the site. TransCanada is the owner of the KeystoneXL project. Is this what Portland Pipeline has in store for South Portlanders?

Portland Pipeline has a bit of a PR problem these days in order to reconcile its aggressive actions toward South Portland citizens with its motto of “Safety, Environment, Customer, Community.” Community outreach should not take the form of barbed electrodes.

South Portland’s newly elected City Council should consider new ordinance language that narrows the use of Tasers only for armed suspects and expressly forbids their use for acts of civil disobedience and non-compliance with orders. Such restrictions are encouraged by Amnesty International. They should be used only with body cams so that the public can review any claims of necessity of use. If these measures were adopted by the council, it would be interesting to see if Portland Pipeline publicly opposes them. Perhaps we can then understand the motive for their “gift.”

Eben Rose lives in South Portland.

Comments are no longer available on this story