BIDDEFORD — A mother of an 18-year-old Biddeford man charged with arson and murder called police several times both before and after the Sept. 18 fire he is alleged to have started to get help for her son.
On Nov. 7, Dylan Collins of Biddeford was arrested for setting a fire at 35 Main St. that resulted in the deaths of James Ford, 21, and Michael Moore, 23.
While it’s easy to point the finger at police or mental health officials for dropping the ball, police said they did what they could to help Dylan Collins, but they are limited by law as to what they can do.
Mental health experts say getting help for adults who don’t want it and/or meeting the standards necessary to commit someone to a mental health facility against their will is difficult.
According to Biddeford Police transcripts, Collins’ mother Donna Pitcher called police on July 27 and said she found flammable objects and bomb-making material all over her apartment and in her son’s room. She said she found information on his computer about bomb-making and the Columbine High School massacre, that he had purchased military boots and died his blond hair jet black.
“She is afraid that he is crazy,” the transcript reads.
When police responded, Collins was reportedly working at Burger King.
About three hours later, there was a call to dispatch stating Collins was home.
Police responded and took him to be evaluated at the crisis center at Counseling Services, Inc., according Police Chief Roger Beaupre.
According to Beaupre, Collins was treated first at the crisis center and later admitted to the mental health unit at SMHC, where he remained for about one month. No one at either center would confirm whether Collins had been a patient.
Pitcher called Biddeford Dispatch again on Oct. 14 and Oct. 20.
On Oct. 14, she said he had purchased a passport online, and she believed he shouldn’t have one. When asked if he threatened her, she said he had not.
On Oct. 20, Pitcher called again. According to the transcript, Collins took the phone away from her and threatened to punch her.
The final transcript with a call from Pitcher was on Nov. 5. The transcript doesn’t detail what she said to police. That day, police took Collins into custody at his job at Monkey Trunks in Saco and brought him for observation to SMHC.
Through interviews at the hospital, said Beaupre, detectives discovered information, which was handed over to state police. Two days later, Collins was arrested on the arson and murder charges and had an initial appearance at York County Superior Court in Alfred.
Collins was not required to make a plea at that appearance.
On Monday in Biddeford District Court, Collins was charged with possession of a concealed weapon. He pleaded not guilty to that charge. He is being held at York County Jail in Alfred without bail.
Although Collins’ mother had called police with concerns about her son’s mental condition prior to the Sept. 18 incident, getting help for someone who doesn’t want it, isn’t so easy, according to both law enforcement and mental health experts.
“There’s more to the story than what’s in the transcripts,” said Beaupre. “The truth of the matter is that we started dealing with him in July. We took him into custody and brought him to the crisis unit who transferred him to Southern Maine Health Center.”
“We were trying to deal with this before it did come to a crisis,” he said, and the department devoted resources and manpower to the situation. “We went above and beyond.”
However, said Beaupre, his department is limited by law and resources as to what they can do for the hundreds of calls that come in each year that are mental health related.
“We can’t scoop someone off the street just on somebody’s say so,” he said. “We need more information.”
“All we can do is get him off the street and take him to the professional,” said the police chief.
Beaupre said he believes his department did avert a greater tragedy by picking up Collins when they did on Nov. 5. Because of the ongoing investigation, he declined to specify the nature of the tragedy to which he referred.
However, said Beaupre, by police taking Collins into custody when they did, “We don’t know how many people we saved.”
Not only are police limited in dealing with the mentally ill, so are mental health professionals.
David Sturtevant, former managing director of the National Alliance on Mental Illness, or NAMI, Maine, said committing an adult to a state mental hospital without their consent is extremely difficult.
NAMI is a grassroots organization that advocates for the mentally ill.
It has to be proven that someone is in “imminent danger” of committing harm to themselves or others, said Sturtevant.
“That’s the problem,” he said, “imminent means right now, not what they say they’re going to do in the future or what their mother says.”
In addition, said Sturtevant, when police or someone else brings someone to a crisis center or the hospital, those facilities are only set up to treat the acute incident at the moment.
“You can’t cure mental illness,” said Sturtevant. “It’s a vicious cycle.”
While she is concerned about what took place on Sept. 18, Jenna Mehnert, the executive director of NAMI Maine, said, “It should be difficult to commit someone and deny them their civil rights.”
In addition, she said, “The mentally ill are far more often the victims of crime than the perpetrators.”
Mehnert agreed that getting help for the mentally ill is difficult, in part because of funding cuts and the significant reduction over the past four years of the number of people who have access to MaineCare to pay for counseling and other mental health services.
The way to avert tragedies like the arson and associated deaths allegedly committed by Collins is to get help for people when the first symptoms appear, often in childhood.
“Nationally, 1 in 5 children display symptoms of mental illness,” said Mehnert. “We don’t take enough steps to get people help with they’re young.”
“We need to do a better job providing services early on,” she said.
— Staff Writer Dina Mendros can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 324 or dmendros@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less