4 min read

Bear baiting is cruel, and Maine voters should end the practice Nov. 4 by voting yes on Question 1.

It’s cruel on many levels. First off, the baiting method of hunting bear in Maine shouldn’t be described as hunting. People drop a bunch of food in the woods, set a snare, and then come back to check to see if a bear has taken the bait. They point their gun at the snared bear – who may have been stuck there for a day or two – and fire at close range. The bear dies and the “hunter” carries it out, likely on the back of an ATV or pickup truck parked nearby. No chase, no tracking, no skilled marksmanship involved. The “hunt” is demeaning for both hunter and hunted.

In Maine, we take pride in the way life should be. No matter how effective baiting supporters say it is, this is not the way hunting should be. On Nov. 4, voters will be able to rectify the situation when they answer Question 1, which asks: “Do you want to ban the use of bait, dogs or traps in bear hunting except to protect property, public safety, or for research?”

As are most issues involving animals, Question 1 is an emotional one, and it goes right to Maine’s core, since the black bear is a noble state symbol. On one side, the state’s wildlife biologists and hunters who practice bear baiting and hounding, which employs dogs to chase down a bear, want to keep the status quo, arguing that bears, which number about 30,000, will become a nuisance if baiting ceases. They cite New Jersey statistics, which found nuisance incidents skyrocketed after the state banned bear baiting.

On the other side, opponents of baiting, snaring and hounding say there are other states – several western states and nearby Massachusetts – that seem to have made their baiting bans work. The number of hunters has doubled in Washington and tripled in Colorado, for example, and nuisance bears are not an issue, they say.

While each side can employ statistics to prove what they want, we would suggest voters look at online videos of the actual practice of bear baiting and let their conscience be their guide. We believe they will conclude there is no honor in this kind of hunting.

Advertisement

Beyond the sickening reaction we have to watching a wild animal die this way, we feel bear baiting creates a bad impression for Maine sporting guides. Yes, their “sports” are nearly guaranteed of getting a bear, and we would hate to condone any legislative change that would hurt the business prospects of guide services, especially in struggling northern and eastern Maine. But there is no sport in it. By restoring honor to the bear hunt, we would think guides would be more, not less, sought out, since hunting requires tracking ability and local knowledge, not just the dropping of doughnuts to lure unsuspecting scavengers.

Guides are almost mythic here in Maine, respected by us all. We trust that once bear baiting and hounding are outlawed, guides will become more employable since bear hunters, especially ones from out of state, will seek out their expertise. Instead of relying on an odoriferous spread of stale sugary treats, the guides know where caches of the bear’s natural foods are located, such as berries and nuts. Yes, it’ll require a transition period, but our licensed Maine guides and hunters will soon convert to more natural – and, ultimately, satisfying – methods of hunting.

To be sure, the bear is a frightful and elusive animal that disappears quickly into the thick Maine woods, and many people are scared of any law change that might increase their numbers, especially since these bears may have become accustomed to human foods. Many are also instinctively trusting of our state’s wildlife biologists, who are asking us on roadside campaign signs and ads to trust them on Question 1. While nuisance bears are a real issue and it’s understandable why some believe bear baiting is practical, the answer to that concern is allowing more permits to kill bears. More hunters means fewer nuisance bears and more employment opportunities for Maine guides. It’s worked in other states and seems like a win-win for all involved.

We believe that the act of luring and killing snared bears just doesn’t seem right. It doesn’t even seem like hunting. And we’re not sure why a hunter would feel satisfied with such a kill. Instead of allowing this method of hunting to continue, bring back bear hunting the way it should be.

–John Balentine, managing editor

Comments are no longer available on this story