9 min read

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — An East Tennessee woman convicted of child neglect in her teenage daughter’s cancer death is asking the state Supreme Court to declare that she is innocent because she relied on prayer to heal the girl.

Jacqueline Crank was sentenced to unsupervised probation after her 15-year-old daughter died of Ewing’s Sarcoma in 2002. Despite the light sentence, Crank has continued to pursue the case, arguing that faith-healing should be legal for everyone.

The Tennessee Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in the case in Knoxville on Thursday.

State law makes it a crime to fail to provide medical care to children, but there is an exception for those who rely on prayer alone for healing. However, the Spiritual Treatment Exemption Act applies only to faith healing performed by an accredited practitioner of a recognized church or religious denomination.

In turning to prayer for her daughter’s healing, Crank relied on the advice of Ariel Ben Sherman, who called himself the girl’s “spiritual father.” Testimony showed Sherman was accredited by the Universal Life Church, which will accredit anyone who fills out an application.

Advertisement

Records from the Department of Children’s Services said Crank and her children lived “in a cult type religious environment with many people (estimated 30) living in their home and all of whom they consider ”˜family,’ although none are actually related.”

In briefs, Crank argues that Tennessee’s Spiritual Treatment Exemption Act is unconstitutional because it treats some faith healing as legitimate while allowing other faith healing to be criminalized.

The state Court of Criminal Appeals ruled against Crank in 2013, saying that even if the state’s faith healing law were unconstitutional, striking it down would not undo Crank’s conviction. It would simply erase the exceptions for faith healing, leaving the law intact that makes it illegal not to seek medical treatment for a child.

Crank argues in a brief to the state Supreme Court that simply deleting the faith healing exemption would have the effect of punishing her for an act of which she is innocent.

Crank initially was charged with a felony. Those charges were later downgraded after doctors said that her daughter Jessica most likely would have died even if she had gone to a hospital right away. Jessica was eventually taken into the custody of the Department of Children’s Services and admitted to East Tennessee Children’s Hospital.

According to court records, the cancer caused a grapefruit-sized tumor on the girl’s shoulder that appeared to give her severe pain.

Advertisement

Pediatric oncologist Dr. Victoria Castaneda testified that while Jessica likely could not have been cured by early treatment, “it would have helped in dealing with her condition and symptoms, and positively impacted the quality of her life.”

Sherman was convicted with Crank of misdemeanor neglect in 2012. Both appealed the conviction, but before the appeal was complete, Sherman died. Records showed he was suffering from cancer and had sought medical help for himself, dying in a hospital.

Public gets 1st look at priceless Mormon artifacts

By BRADY McCOMBS

Associated Press

SALT LAKE CITY ”“ In one glass case sits a weathered page from the original Book of Mormon manuscript that Latter-day Saints believe was translated from ancient Egyptian and dictated to scribes by founder Joseph Smith 185 years ago with help from God.

Advertisement

In other nearby cases are Smith’s first journal and the first printed editions of books that contain commandments, doctrine and covenants based on early revelations Smith received while forming The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in upstate New York in 1830.

They are part of a new public exhibit that features some of the faith’s most treasured artifacts dating back to the early days of Mormonism. The priceless collection of 26 books, manuscripts and documents was unveiled Wednesday at a news conference with church leaders that marks the latest example of the faith being more forthcoming about its history and tenets.

“These four display cases comprise our most precious documents,” said Steven E. Snow, church historian and recorder. “They go to the foundation of our faith. These are our spiritual roots.”

The religion founded with 30 followers now counts 15 million worldwide after experiencing a tripling of membership in the past three decades. As Mormons became more prominent in America and questions emerged about the burgeoning faith, some criticized it as being secretive about its beliefs and practices.

In recent years, the Salt Lake City-based church has taken concerted steps to change that image.

A year ago, it began releasing books containing historical documents that shed light on how Smith formed the church. The religion also has issued a series of in-depth articles that explain or clarify some of the more sensitive parts of its history that it once sidestepped, such as the faith’s past ban on black men in the lay clergy and its early history of polygamy.

Advertisement

The church’s website has become a treasure trove of information about its doctrine, gospel and practices.

The new “Foundations of Faith” exhibit, which opens to the public this week at the church’s Salt Lake City history library, is another illustration of the religion’s push to open its vault and take on questions, said Terryl Givens, professor of literature and religion and the James Bostwick chair of English at the University of Richmond.

The collection should generate widespread interest among Mormons who will be able to see, in person, the artifacts associated with keystone events in church history, Givens said.

The items have been in the church vault, taken out from time to time to show, but they have never before been displayed in one collection. Church leaders hope the exhibit will bolster members’ faith and help non-Mormons better understand the religion.

“We need to be open and transparent,” Snow said. “There are questions that arise occasionally, and we need to deal with them in an honest, forthright way, which we are trying to do.”

The document likely to draw the most interest is the page from the Book of Mormon, considered the religion’s most valuable manuscript, said Richard E. Turley, assistant church historian and recorder.

Advertisement

Before he was killed by a mob in 1844, Smith buried the entire manuscript in the cornerstone of a building under construction in Nauvoo, Illinois, the city Mormons fled to in the mid-1800s to avoid religious persecution. The water-damaged manuscript was found in the rubble of the unfinished hotel some 40 years later. The church has only about one-fourth of the manuscript in its archive today, Turley said.

The exhibit also includes a collection of sacred hymns chosen by Smith’s wife, Emma, in 1835; documents that show the early foundation of the faith’s organization for women and girls; and the first translations of the Book of Mormon into non-English languages such as Danish and Spanish.

Church officials declined to give a monetary value for the collection, saying only that many items are priceless and irreplaceable. They have implemented new security measures in the library to protect them.

Philip Barlow, professor of Mormon history and culture at Utah State University, equated the experience of seeing the documents to Americans viewing the U.S. Constitution for the first time.

“There’s something really important about the tangibility for the public of these documents in their original form,” Barlow said. “It’s a link with the past that has a sort of visceral power to change consciousness.”

Cardinal to lead St. Pat parade with 1st gay group

Advertisement

By RACHEL ZOLL

AP Religion Writer

NEW YORK — There is no more natural spot for Roman Catholic Cardinal Timothy Dolan ”“ a proud, ebullient Irish-American ”“ than grand marshal of the city’s historic St. Patrick’s Day Parade. But the honor now has an added significance: Parade organizers said Wednesday they will allow the first gay group to march under its own banner.

Dolan was quick to issue a statement of support for the parade organizers, accepting their decision. While supporters of gay and lesbian Catholics are cheering, some conservatives want the archbishop to withdraw from the event.

“I think we’re seeing the Catholicism of Pope Francis come to the Archdiocese of New York,” said J. Patrick Hornbeck, chairman of the theology department at Fordham University. “Cardinal Dolan’s statement is welcoming. He did not make this decision, but sees the parade as an opportunity for unity.”

Pope Francis last year said church leaders should focus more on mercy than on divisive social issues. He famously said, “Who am I to judge?” when asked about gays and lesbians who are seeking God.

Advertisement

But Pat Archbold, a writer for the theologically conservative National Catholic Register, called Dolan’s decision to remain as grand marshal a “total capitulation to gay identity groups.”

Dolan said in a statement the parade organizers have “my confidence and support” and he thanked them for keeping the parade “close to its Catholic heritage.” He said he and his predecessors have never determined who could march in the parade, but left that decision to the organizers.

However, in 1993, Cardinal John O’Connor opposed the campaign by the Irish Lesbian and Gay Organization for permission to march under their own banner. More than 200 gay rights protesters staged a countermarch that year and were arrested.

“Irish Catholics have been persecuted for the sole reason that they have refused to compromise church teaching,” O’Connor said. “What others may call bigotry, Irish Catholics call principle.”

Dolan’s position on the parade is the latest of his gentler comments on gays and lesbians.

Last year, Dolan was asked on ABC’s “This Week” about gay and lesbian Catholics who felt rejected by the church. “Well, the first thing I’d say to them is, ”˜I love you, too. And God loves you. And you are made in God’s image and likeness,’” Dolan said.

Advertisement

When Missouri defensive end Michael Sam announced he was gay earlier this year, Dolan said, “Good for him.”

“I would have no sense of judgment on him. God bless ya,” Dolan said in an appearance on NBC’s “Meet the Press.” ”˜’The same Bible that tells us that ”“ teaches us well about the virtues of chastity and ”“ and the virtue of fidelity and marriage also tells us not to judge people. So I would say, ”˜Bravo.’”

At the St. Patrick’s Day Parade last March, Dolan said he supports individual gays and lesbians participating in the parade and hoped it could be a day of unity and joy. “I know that there are thousands and thousands of gay people marching in this parade,” he said. “I know it. And I’m glad they are.”

The parade has no direct ties to the church, but celebrates a Catholic saint and has always been a key event for the city’s Irish Catholics.

Philip Lawler, the Boston-based editor of the theologically conservative Catholic World News, said Dolan should step down as grand marshal.

“My phone has been ringing off the hook with people who are upset,” Lawler said. “Cardinal Dolan said, ”˜I’m sure there have been lots of homosexuals marching in the parade before,’ but homosexuals identifying themselves seems a contradiction in honoring a Catholic saint.”

Advertisement

Lawler said the New York parade is more of a civic event that has already lost much of its ties to religion. “Why don’t we just admit it has no religious significance?” Lawler said.

Francis DeBernardo, executive director of New Ways Ministry, a Catholic gay rights group, said he thinks Dolan feels freer to take positions like his stand on the parade now that he is no longer the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.

“I think he’s able to be more of a pastor to the people of New York than he had been when he was on the national stage, bishops primarily are pastors and teachers, and I think he’s fulfilling that role,” DeBernardo said. “I think Pope Francis has been teaching the bishops what being a pastor means.”



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.