3 min read

CAPE ELIZABETH – Despite residents’ concerns at a hearing held Monday, the Cape Elizabeth Town Council adopted amendments to the town’s zoning ordinance that changes how the outer boundary of the shoreland protection zone is measured along Cape’s coastline.

Councilors voted 5-2 to use the highest astronomical tide level – measured during a 19-year period – plus 3 vertical feet, to mark the shoreland-protection boundary or the “normal high water line.” The move to change the definition was prompted by the town’s Code Enforcement Officer Benjamin McDougal.

In a memo to Cape Elizabeth Town Manager Michael McGovern, in March 2013, McDougal said that his biggest challenge during his first five weeks as code enforcement officer was determining how the town would more clearly define the normal high water line of coastal waters. He said, “On one hand it could be interpreted as the top of the bank” and “on the other hand, it could be interpreted as the limit of staining on rocks.”

“I would recommend that the town have a definition that enables land-use professionals to determine the line based on objective and scientifically sound data,” McDougal wrote.

According to the town’s zoning ordinance, the high-water line marks the 250-foot-wide band where development is regulated along the coast, and any new development is prohibited within 75 feet of the line. At Monday’s meeting, Town Planner Maureen O’Meara said the proposal was to switch to what is called the elevation method versus the visual inspection method, which the town previously used to measure the high-water line.

Cape Elizabeth’s zoning ordinance defines the high water line as “the apparent extreme limit of the effect of the tides” marked by a bank, cliff or beach above high tide. O’Meara said the new definition of measuring the shoreland-protection boundary line – using the highest astronomical tide and adding 3 feet – is a more reliable and scientific method than the Maine Department of Environmental Protection’s standard measurement of “highest annual tide,” which changes every year.

Advertisement

The Maine Geological Survey recommends that the state shift its standard from highest annual tide to the highest astronomical tide, which is based on 19 years of data, O’Meara said.

Peter Slovinksy, a marine geologist for the Maine Geological Survey, has given presentations to the Planning Board and the Town Council during the last 17 months about the effects of rising sea levels and storm surge along Maine’s coast. According to O’Meara, the amendment to add 3 feet to the highest astronomical tide measure adds setback to properties that already experience flooding challenges and puts the town in the lead in terms of environmental protection.

“We are trying to plan into the future,” O’Meara said.

About 10 residents at the hearing opposed the new definition, saying that they thought adding 3 feet to the highest astronomical tide would provide less shoreland protection and adversely affect their properties.

Frederick Aronson, a resident of Lawson Road, said, “I think we are all kind of wondering what changes when the definition changes in terms of our properties. There is also concern about protecting the environment. Those of us who have property that is affected by the shoreland definition, are wondering what happens to our properties, our tax rate,” he continued. “My property shrinks by a significant amount. Will my tax bill go down? That would be nice.”

Nancy Ahlsen, who lives on Wells Road and whose property abuts the Spurwink marsh, said she was concerned that the new shoreland-protection zone measurement could prohibit her from adding onto her home.

Advertisement

“How far up would it go on my property and would it interfere with my rights as a property owner?” she asked the council.

She added, “My question for the town would be: Are you going to send someone over to my house to meet with me and show me where the lines are and where the new lines would be and how it would impact me?”

Resident David Wennberg, of Angell Point Road, was also concerned about using the astronomical high tide measure, plus 3 feet, to mark the high water line.

“While there is concern about adding the 3 feet to protect a high bank area … adding 3 feet for those of us who are non-bank shore owners substantially reduces the amount of land that would be available for us to build on,” he said.

Comments are no longer available on this story