BIDDEFORD — The Biddeford High School football program’s potential move to Class B took one step closer to fruition on Tuesday night when an open public forum to discuss the shift was met with little negative sentiment.
In front of a low turnout of a dozen people, Biddeford athletic director Dennis Walton led the discussion, intended to both educate the community on the possible reasons for the move as well as afford people an opportunity to express concern or support for the switch, which would see Biddeford, with its steadily declining enrollment, move from its traditional home in Class A to the smaller schools of Class B.
The forum lasted just under an hour, with Walton primarily fielding questions on the ins and outs of how such a move would take place, and not whether or not it was the right thing to do.
Despite the low turnout, Walton said the open forum had accomplished just what he had intended, and that he didn’t think that said anything larger about the overall support or enthusiasm surrounding the football program.
“My feeling when I saw the low turnout isn’t that people don’t care, just go to Waterhouse on a Friday night and you’ll see people care. People are busy, and people might not be quick to give an opinion in a public forum, and that’s their prerogative,” Walton said. “We had no clue what the turnout was going to be, we weren’t concerned about what the turnout would be, we just needed to afford people the opportunity.”
Tuesday’s was a stark difference to the mood of two years ago, when the Maine Principal Association’s realignment to four football classes from the traditional three had originally moved Biddeford from its longtime home in Class A, the largest football Class in Maine, down to Class B.
That sparked a reaction nearing outrage from a town whose school has won more Class A football state championships than any other in Maine. With a much larger crowd at that first public forum, the response was nearly unanimous in the wish to stay in Class A, with those in attendance saying a move to Class B could potentially lead to the downfall of what is one of the most tradition-rich football programs in the state.
Walton said he felt that meeting had been dictated more by emotion and tradition than common sense, which he took responsibility for.
“We were always a Class A school and this put us in Class B. The newness of that, that led to a lot of negativity,” Walton said. “The error on my part, probably because I didn’t know then what I know two years later, is that I didn’t have this kind of discussion. I was as new to that as anyone.”
As a result of that prior meeting, Walton also said that it was his feeling that the low turnout on Tuesday is a sign that the sentiment in the community is starting to shift.
“I think we’re in a different place than we were two years ago. If you believe in this direction, there wasn’t much reason to show up tonight,” Walton said. “We’ve offered this opportunity tonight, and if this is the direction we go in I hope people will be respectful of it.”
While Tuesday night’s attendance for the public forum was low, Walton said he had fielded several calls and heard numerous reactions, both positive and negative, since his initial presentation to the School Committee on July 8.
Here are five of those key questions surrounding Biddeford’s potential move to Class B football:
Ӣ Why is Biddeford moving to Class B in football and not other sports?
First the basics: The MPA classifies schools by enrollment, meaning that in every sport a school plays a schedule that is made up of games against schools of a similar size. To make this easier, schools are organized into Classes, with Class A the largest, Class B the second largest and so on. Most sports in Maine consist of three classes, while larger sports like football, baseball and basketball have four classes.
However, schools can be in different classes for different sports, as the cutoff number is not the same across the board.
For instance, while the Class A enrollment cutoff for football is 875 students, it’s typically much lower for other sports, usually anywhere from 725-775. That means that Biddeford, with its enrollment of 775, can be, and is, classified as Class B in football and in Class A most other sports.
Under its current enrollment, the only other sport besides football where Biddeford is classified as Class B is boys ice hockey, which uses a unique Tier system that allows smaller schools to still stay in Class A but play a weaker schedule if it wishes. Biddeford has retained a Class A, Tier I schedule in hockey, but could easily move to a Tier II schedule and still stay in Class A if it wished.
What all of this means is that Biddeford, under the current classification cutoffs, can play a Class B football schedule but keep its traditional Class A schedule in all other sports.
Some other schools already do this: Westbrook and Marshwood both play in Class B for football, but play in Class A for every other sport.
And by the numbers, it makes a lot more sense for Biddeford to play in Class B than Class A in football. With 775 students, Biddeford is a full 100 under the cutoff and would be the smallest school in Class A West by 80 students. Further, it would be nearly 600 students smaller than the biggest school in the conference, Thornton Academy.
In Class B, Biddeford would be the third-largest school as currently constituted. The largest school in that conference, Gorham, would have 109 more students, while York, the smallest, would have just 169 students less, a much-smaller spread than in Class A.
”¢ Is it possible Biddeford’s enrollment will go back up, and with it the football team back up to Class A?
It is possible, but considering the not so gradual slide in Biddeford’s enrollment, it isn’t likely the Tigers will be considered a Class A school enrollment-wise for a long time.
Consider that in the spring of 2012, when the idea of a four-class football system was put into motion, Biddeford High School’s enrollment was 830 students. On April 1 of this spring, it was down to 775 students. According to Superintendent Jeremy Ray, by 2018 that number will be down in the range of 720 and possibly lower, meaning that Biddeford will be even more of a Class B school in the coming years than it is now.
Ӣ If it happens, exactly when will Biddeford be playing a Class B schedule?
This is where things get slightly complicated.
Due to Biddeford petitioning up to Class A, it locked the school into staying in Class A for two full cycles, or four years. The first year of the first cycle was this past fall, meaning that under the clause in the MPA agreement, Biddeford is required to play in Class A for three more seasons, through the fall of 2016.
However, there is the opportunity for any school that believes it made a mistake in petitioning up to re-petition the MPA to revoke the clause, and as a result move back down to the Class where it was originally placed.
If Biddeford were to successfully re-petition, it would wipe out the commitment for the final two years and put the Tigers back in Class B starting in 2015.
Walton said over the previous weeks he has had discussions over the phone about the possible withdrawal with South Portland Athletic Director Todd Livingston, the outgoing chairman of the MPA football committee, as well as Mike Burnham, an assistant executive director at the MPA, and that they had “really made me believe that this is something that’s possible.”
“Our belief is that if we made a mistake two years ago, and we’re starting to believe we did, by petitioning up, then why make two full classes of student athletes suffer from that?” Walton said. “If we’re going to go to B, why not put them in the position where they should be rather than paying for our mistakes.”
If Walton isn’t able to revoke the clause, Biddeford would have to wait until 2017 to play in Class B. But either way, the switch to Class B will eventually happen.
“The writing is on the wall, in my opinion,” Walton said. “Whether we opt out now or don’t, we will be Class B (in 2017). To ask a school of 720 to compete with a school of 1,450 is beyond unfair.”
Ӣ What about the Battle of the Bridge?
The hardest part of this for many people to swallow, not just in Biddeford but likely Saco as well, is the likely loss of the annual rivalry game between Biddeford and Thornton Academy, one of the most-anticipated and well-attended games on the Maine high school sporting calendar.
But the reality is, if Biddeford does make the move to Class B, the Battle of the Bridge game as we now know it almost undoubtedly goes with it. With Biddeford in Class B and Thornton still in Class A, they won’t be on each other’s regular-season schedule.
And the likelihood of the two playing a crossover game is close to nil due to the fact that the MPA is very reluctant to allow crossovers due to the scheduling nightmare it would create, as well as the fact that it would make little sense for Thornton to play a Class B school, which would count for fewer points in the standings than a Class A opponent and thus harm T.A.’s playoff positioning.
Walton ”“ who has previously mooted the possibility of playing Thornton in an after-season exhibition game, such as on Thanksgiving, to keep the traditional rivalry alive ”“ is under no allusions to the fact that the T.A. regular-season game is all but gone with a switch to Class B.
“If the MPA football committee ever considered crossovers, that would be a new problem they’d have to figure out with the points. I don’t think that formula exists,” Walton said. “They’re not just going to say, you want to play (Thornton), so we’ll do it. You can’t just request one, because it’s not going to happen.”
”¢ What’s the short-term timetable now?
Walton is set to attend the MPA football committee’s meeting on Aug. 5, where he will discuss attempting to gain a release from the clause requiring Biddeford to stay up in Class A for two more years due to petitioning up.
If Walton gains the football committee’s approval, the matter then moves on to the MPA interscholastic management committee, which will make a decision some time in October. If that committee agrees to release Biddeford from the second cycle of the Class A commitment, then the last step is a yes vote from the Biddeford School Committee ”“ which was overwhelmingly supportive of the move during the July 8 meeting.
If those things all happen, which Walton said he is increasingly confident of, then this upcoming season could be the last in Biddeford’s storied history as a Class A program.
— Staff Writer Cameron Dunbar can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 323 or cdunbar@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less