SOUTH PORTLAND – The South Portland City Council is expected to hold a final vote on ordinance language that would ban the loading of so-called tar-sands oil onto marine tank vessels for export, during its meeting on Monday, July 21, at 7 p.m.
A super majority of five affirmative votes is required to pass a land use ordinance and last week, on first reading, the council voted 6-1 with Councilor Michael Pock opposed, to move the ban forward.
With the final vote looming, the pressure is mounting on the council as both sides make last-ditch efforts to persuade councilors to their point of view.
Members of the group Protect South Portland, which supports the ban on tar sands, have been out in force throughout the draft ordinance process, but it wasn’t until last week that members of the South Portland Working Waterfront Coalition, which opposes the new rules, made their presence felt.
In fact, so many of them turned up at the regularly scheduled council meeting on July 7, that the council was forced to hold a special meeting on the tar sands ban to July 9 instead.
“The men and women of South Portland’s waterfront often put in 70 to 80 hours a week to ensure the businesses there remain a reliable source of jobs, innovation and the region’s link to American and world energy markets,” Burt Russell, vice president of operations at Sprague Energy, said in a press release.
He added, “These folks don’t have the luxury of attending months and months of public hearings and meetings. But they do know a bad ordinance when they see one. And they know this one puts their jobs at risk. That’s why they turned out in force to oppose it.”
And Jamie Py, president of the Maine Energy Marketers Association, said, “Like any business, if the terminals can’t evolve and grow, they’ll slowly die. And that means hundreds, if not thousands, of local waterfront jobs are in jeopardy.”
Py continued, “City councilors should be asking themselves why – in a time of political instability in international energy markets – they would voluntarily remove the Port of Portland from playing an essential role in America’s energy future?”
But, those who support the new rules banning tar sands argue keeping the product, which consists of a combination of clay, sand, water and bitumen – a heavy, black and viscous type of oil – out of South Portland is vital to protecting the health and welfare of both residents and the environment.
A moratorium is in place preventing any development proposal involving the flow of tar sands into the city. The moratorium, which was extended by the council once already, remains in place until Nov. 1.
This week, Pock told the Current he voted against the new rules that ban not only tar sands, but also the export of all crude oil products from South Portland, because of his concern about its potential impact on jobs.
“If you look at my voting record you will see I have been against the waterfront protection ordinance (defeated in a referendum last fall), the moratorium and the moratorium extension all along,” Pock said.
He’s not only concerned about present jobs, but also the ability of the oil companies in South Portland to evolve based on market demand.
“South Portland is certified as business friendly and throttling down businesses is not (being) business friendly,” Pock said.
When asked how he’s dealt with the lobbying efforts on both sides of the tar sands issue, Pock called it “challenging and requiring patience and understanding.”
He’s received more than 300 emails regarding the city’s approach to tar sands since last November and said it’s been his goal all along to be an “informed citizen” while also verifying the sources of various bits of information that have come his way during the debate on the tar sands ban.
The Current contacted every member of the City Council regarding the impact the lobbying effort on both sides of the tar sands issue has had on them, but councilors Tom Blake, Melissa Linscott and Patti Smith did not respond prior to the paper’s deadline.
Like Pock, Councilor Maxine Beecher said she’s received hundreds of emails and many phone calls during the tar sands debate.
She said when “both sides are pushing their positions, it can be difficult to compare the ideas.” That’s why she often asks people who are trying to influence her to put their arguments in writing.
“First, it cools them off and it helps me to see what they are trying to say,” Beecher said. “Then those ideas will give me (other) ideas for more research.”
She added, “I think being a councilor today is very difficult. The subjects before us are complex and when councilors don’t agree (people) get hurt.”
Councilor Linda Cohen said this week that she’s actually found it interesting to hear the arguments on both sides.
“They really haven’t changed since last fall, but I think that some people have come to understand the council is really serious about protecting the city and that our opposition to the (waterfront protection ordinance) really was because it was too broad.”
She’s also received more than 100 emails and phone calls from residents and others hoping to influence her vote on the tar sands ban.
“I truly believe that all the councilors (no matter their position) support a healthy and thriving South Portland,” she said.
Unlike his fellow councilors, Mayor Gerard Jalbert said he’s not feeling any stress regarding the proposed tar sands ban.
“I’m really not feeling any pressure because I truly feel that we have taken a really good strategy on this issue,” Jalbert said this week. “When I feel we got it right, I have no stress.”
In answer to those who say the council has overstepped in appointing the Draft Ordinance Committee, which created the proposed new rules, Jalbert said the council not only has legislative authority, but also the tar sands ban is “quite different” from the waterfront protection ordinance, which was narrowly defeated in a referendum last fall.
He also argued that the ban on tar-sands oil is actually a flexible rule that could be amended or changed as necessary.
“This is not written in stone,” Jalbert said. “This is a better methodology and if the (oil industry) business model changes, we could tweak this ordinance to allow for some export of fuel products.”
And, like Cohen, he believes the action the City Council has taken regarding tar sands is what’s best for the community overall.
“I think we have a well-crafted ordinance that could withstand any legal challenge,” he added.
His goal moving forward is to find a way for people on both sides of the issue to respect each other and ensure that any bitter feelings don’t persist.
Lobbyists out in full force
For groups like Protect South Portland and the South Portland Working Waterfront Coalition, lobbying the City Council is an important tool in getting their point of view aired.
Mary-Jane Ferrier, a spokeswoman for Protect South Portland, said this week that her grassroots group’s active participation in the process has been vital to getting their concerns addressed.
“We have spent the last months since the moratorium was put in place by the City Council in a widespread effort to make known to as wide an audience as possible the huge benefits that will accrue to South Portland if the city puts in place an ordinance to keep tar sands out of our city and harbor,” she said.
“It would be almost impossible to quantify the hours spent by Protect South Portland” in supporting the ban on tar sands, Ferrier added.
She said the group’s coordinating committee has met regularly throughout; volunteers have made phone calls; many members have attended council meetings to speak and others have written letters to the editor.
From Ferrier’s point of view, “The City Council has behaved in exemplary fashion throughout this time, studiously staying out of the Draft Ordinance Committee’s deliberations. At meetings they have been fair and evenhanded and have treated all with respect. Of course, they have been under a lot of pressure, but they appear to have handled it very well indeed.”
For his part, Py, who heads the Maine Energy Marketers Association, said it’s the goal of the waterfront coalition to “educate city councilors and local citizens about the negative impacts of this ordinance, while addressing the mistruths that ordinance proponents spread about the petroleum industry.”
He said the coalition is made up of a diverse group ranging from terminal operators to tugboat captains, community leaders and like-minded local citizens in and around South Portland.
Py said the Draft Ordinance Committee “engaged in a faulty and biased process from the start that was clearly slanted against the petroleum industry, and has proposed a ban on bulk-loading of all crude, including oil produced right here in America. That fundamentally changes what this effort is all about and enhances its dramatically negative impacts on our marine terminal operations.”
He added, “If enacted, this ordinance pre-emptively limits the ability of terminals in South Portland to progress and change along with the nation’s thriving energy marketplace, which means instead of the Port of Portland being a world-class marine working waterfront robustly employing many, it could face decades of withering.”
He also argued that there are other ways to deal with the concerns regarding air emissions, visual impact to South Portland’s waterfront and new development by the oil terminals without imposing an absolute ban on certain fuel products.
Dylan Voorhees, the clean energy director at the Natural Resources Council of Maine, which supports the ban on tar sands, said his group has been working on the issue since 2009, when the Portland Pipe Line Corp. was “actively pursuing reversal of the pipeline for tar sands.”
“Tar sands pose a wide variety of threats to communities across Maine, and the (Natural Resources Council of Maine) is concerned with all of them,” he said. “These range from pipeline risks in western Maine, to local air quality issues in South Portland, to climate change threats we all face.”
Voorhees said his group “has hundreds of members in South Portland, and the threat there is a good example of acute environmental risks from tar-sands and crude oil infrastructure. For many residents, it’s not an abstract, global issue, it’s a matter of whether a new, heavy industrial use with acute local impacts will be allowed in the community.”
He said the resources council has “put a significant amount of time and effort into working with Protect South Portland, providing technical information and other kinds of support and helping engage our members in the city.”
Voorhees added, “We’re impressed and pleased with the council’s management of this issue. They have responded to a loud call from citizens for better protections, and they did it in a deliberative and transparent way by invoking a volunteer, expert committee.”
What’s been the most amazing thing about the tar sands debate in South Portland, Voorhees said, is that the effort “hasn’t been lobbying by lawyers or paid advocates, it has been citizens engaging directly with each other and their elected officials. It’s been amazing to watch.”
Emily Figdor, the director of Environment Maine, which has also been working with Protect South Portland, said her group has spent so much time and effort in lobbying the City Council on the tar sands ban because, “South Portland is ground-zero when it comes to tar sands in Maine.”
Like Ferrier and Voorhees, Figdor had nothing but praise for the City Council saying it has “shown tremendous leadership, foresight, and courage in addressing the issue. It’s truly good local government at work.”
In addition to its effort with the City Council and the Draft Ordinance Committee, Environment Maine also recently put out a report entitled, “Inside the Big Oil Playbook: Strategies and Tactics Used in the Industry’s Battle to Ship Tar Sands Out of Casco Bay.”
Figdor said the goal of the report was to show “how one of the most powerful industries in the world exerted its influence locally in South Portland, spending $750,000 last fall. South Portland is just another page in Big Oil’s playbook, but for us it’s our air, our coast, our community and our future.”
She added that Protect South Portland “has shown the community and world the tremendous power in citizens coming together, against incredible odds.”
Sprague Energy is not a member of the Working Waterfront Coalition in South Portland, but this week Taylor Hudson, the managing director of marketing, said the company has come out against the tar sands ban, calling it bad policy and a bad precedent.
Hudson said there is no need for South Portland to ban tar sands because there are no plans to export the product from the city, and it’s also not an activity that is occurring now.
He also said that what the city is doing is “banning a hypothetical,” which is bad for relations between the municipality and the business community.
“I think if the ban passes, businesses in South Portland will start to ask what the City Council won’t like next?” Hudson added.
In addition, he argued that Sprague has been a good corporate citizen and the ban on tar sands could limit the company’s ability to change its business model in response to market forces.
“Sprague has been in business for 140 years. Before we sold refined petroleum products, we sold distillates, heavy oils and coal,” Hudson said. “The waterfront terminals change with the market all the time.”
Overall, he said, “there’s a lot at stake because of the precedent being set. That’s why we will attend all the (upcoming) meetings and speak our minds.”
Comments are no longer available on this story