3 min read

Sir Winston Churchill once said, “Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.” That bit of wisdom seems especially appropriate when viewing the current state of Regional School Unit 5. The formation of the RSU was done in the best democratic tradition, with the popular support of the voters of Durham, Freeport and Pownal. Today, despite the fact that our schools are measuring up to be good, if not very good, the citizens of our three towns are at odds with one another.

I’ve been unhappy with the RSU, as well. As a Pownal resident, I voted in favor of joining the RSU, only to find that my taxes would be increasing by a big number. I saw the education commissioner offer several thousand dollars to the town of Pownal to “study” the impact of consolidation, only to have the offer rescinded on the very same day. And I protested as loudly as the others when the RSU school board voted to remove grades 6 through 8 from Pownal Elementary School.

And while I have come to accept that I have been wrong on some of the issues, and while I do maintain my right to dissent, I have come to believe that we are all misdirected in protesting the RSU. We were forced into this union by the state. The legislation that forced the Regional School Units on the people of Maine was done to save money, and not to improve our children’s education. It was an ill-conceived and hurried law that provided poor direction and no incentive. It was democracy at the very worst.

And while being terribly planned, the law also gave little recourse for correction. Many residents of Durham, Freeport and Pownal would like to go back to those days before consolidation. Folks, that just isn’t possible; at least not without spending a lot more money than what we are spending now.

The state of Maine forced us into this shotgun wedding, and they kept the dowry. The money that provided for Durham and Pownal to tuition their kids to high schools in other towns is gone, as is the money that Freeport received from the state for accepting high school students from Durham and Pownal. We are in this whether we like it or not. It’s time to stop arguing within the RSU.

The residents of Durham and Pownal can vote time and again against the school budget. It’s not going to change anything. The educational funding that had kept our taxes low is gone. Before the ink in his signature had even dried, John Baldacci was claiming the perceived savings through school consolidation, and cuts in state spending that have been enacted since will only act to ensure that the money will not be coming back any time soon.

Advertisement

And Freeport residents who are frustrated with the current state of withdrawal negotiations have to understand our position – that we have no other place to go. In the time just before consolidation, high school students from Pownal had no other choice than Freeport High School. As I understand, other high schools in the area, including Brunswick, Lisbon, Greely and Yarmouth, are all telling the RSU Working Group that they will take some of our high school students, but not all. What are we to do?

I understand the frustrations of the folks in Freeport who support withdrawal. But think of what we are doing. We are turning to state government to help us resolve the impasse in negotiations when they are the ones who forced us into this situation. The requirement for designation of a school of choice was the poison pill that they inserted into the statute all so that we can’t force it back on them. They aren’t going to help us.

Tom Hall

Pownal

Comments are no longer available on this story