4 min read

BIDDEFORD — On Tuesday, amidst opposition, the city council gave initial approval to a contract zone that will allow a new cellular tower to be built at 384 Hill St.

The 140-foot tower being proposed by VC Properties, LLC, doing business as Mariner Tower LP of Kennebunkport, would be located in an I-2 zone. The contract zone is necessary because telecommunication facilities are not allowed in that zone.

City Planner Greg Tansley noted that there are only two zones where telecommunications facilities can currently be located in Biddeford. Because of the greater use of wireless technology today, he said, the city should look into adding more areas. Tansley said he intends to address this when the city starts updating its comprehensive plan, a process that will begin soon.

The proposed tower is needed, said Chris Ciolfi with Mariner Tower, to allow better coverage for AT&T wireless services, which for now is the only company seeking placement on the proposed facility.

The tower would also have room for four other companies to collocate and would allow the city to install whip antennae on top of the tower for use by public safety and the public works departments.

Advertisement

Other public benefits would include that the 14-acre lot to be purchased by the applicant would be sold to the city for $1. The applicant would also build a road, compliant with city standards, and install underground utilities, except water and sewer, to the site.

The applicant would be granted an easement to a 100,000-square-foot area on the site for the placement of the tower and the remainder of the property could be used by the city for yet-to-be-determined projects.

Since learning about the proposed facility, several residents living near the area it would be located in and others have raised objections to it mainly based on health concerns and the effect on property values.

Rev. Derek White said he isn’t against cellular towers in general but as a neighbor of the one being proposed, he is concerned it will negatively affect property values in the area.

Noise produced by generators that would be installed by each of the companies locating on the tower would be bothersome to those living nearby, he said, adding that there have already been concerns raised by real estate agents.

White suggested placing a tower next to the nearby public works department where a tower is already located that is used by city departments.

Advertisement

Frank Novotny said he also lives near the site of the proposed tower and is also opposed to it.

He said that residents in areas where cellular towers have been built and have had a negative affect on property values have won class action lawsuits.

If the tower is approved, said Novotny, “I will do my level best to organize a class action suit.”

He also said he was concerned about the health effects of radio frequency, or RF, energy that would be released by wireless carriers that would locate on the tower.

“This radiation is deadly to humans, animals and plants,” said Novotny.

Teacher Nancy Nadeau raised a concern that the proposed tower site would be located about 2,500 feet from public schools, which is too close, she said.

Advertisement

“I’m very concerned about the children,” she said. “A tower that close is really detrimental to health.”

In responding to some of the remarks, Ciolfi said, “The need for this facility is driven by consumer demand.”

He also referred to reports refuting some of the residents concerns.

A report conducted by an independent third party, but paid for by the applicant, concluded that the RF energy that will be emitted by proposed placement on the tower would be below the maximum permissible exposure level, as set by the Federal Communications Commission.

According to the federal telecommunications act, wireless facilities cannot by denied based on RF emissions if they comply with FCC regulations.

Also, to ensure compliance with FCC RF emissions regulations, if another wireless providers seeks to collocate on the proposed tower, it would be required to show proof that the cumulative effect of RF emissions would be below the permissible exposure levels before the city would issue permits.

Advertisement

Another expert report by Deborah Haskell of Winthrop Real Estate Advisors disputed concerns about the tower’s effect or property values.

She stated that based on her analysis, “it is my opinion that the proposed telecommunications facility at 384 Hill St. will not adversely affect surrounding properties’ values.”

In addition, Haskell said lack of adequate connectivity and high-speed Internet service can have a negative effect on property values and the proposed facility would resolve that issue for the area.

According to a memo from Tansley, City Assessor Frank Yattaw reviewed and agreed with Haskell’s conclusions.

Regarding the use of generators, Ciolfi noted that they would only be used during power outages when the need for wireless services would be most needed and for short testing periods. The times of the testing could be conducted when they would be least disruptive to residents, he said, and added that a residential-style muffler would also be placed on the generators.

The council must vote on the contract zone a second time, which will take place July 1. If it receives final approval, the applicant must go back to the planning board for final approvals before the proposed tower can be built.

— Staff Writer Dina Mendros can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 324 or dmendros@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.