4 min read

SANFORD — A federally licensed gun dealer here is facing possible revocation of his license to sell firearms as part of a pending investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.

Philip Chabot, owner of Pac N Arms LLC in Sanford, has not been charged with any crime, but is awaiting a hearing on his license. In a telephone interview Tuesday, his attorney, Penny Dean, said she sees “a lot of smoke and mirrors, but no substance,” emanating from the bureau in relation to her client and his business.

Dean said that if the bureau authorized their agent to copy Chabot’s records, “(the bureau is) breaking the law, and if they didn’t, he is. One of these two things is true.”

In a February affidavit for a federal search warrant, ATF Industry Operations Investigator Wayne Bettencourt said he had begun a compliance inspection at Chabot’s business in August. Pac N Arms LLC had been the subject of inspections in prior years: 2003, 2006 and 2009, according to the affidavit on file at the federal court in Portland.

Bettencourt wrote that during his August inspections, Chabot “constantly hovered over my shoulder so he could see which records I was reviewing. In some cases, when I attempted to copy or photograph records, Chabot forbade me from doing so.”

Advertisement

Chabot, whose business has two locations, 125 Milton Ave. and 72 Emery St., which is in an unmarked storefront at the rear of a largely vacant mill building, was issued a notice of revocation earlier this year. A hearing on the bid by the ATF to revoke his federal firearms license has not been set, according to Debora Seifert, spokesman for the federal agency, who also said such hearings are not open to the public or the media.

Seifert, in a telephone message, said the bureau is “not able to speak on the status of investigations,” but added Chabot has not been charged with a crime.

Dean said she has yet to receive any information from the federal government in connection with the revocation hearing.

“We’ve asked for the evidence, but haven’t received any,” she said. Such evidence must be provided prior to any hearing, Dean added.

In the affidavit, Bettencourt wrote that he explained to Chabot that he needed to copy some of the records to document “Chabot’s own violations, and to follow up on individuals whose purchase patterns appeared suspicious to me, based on my training.” Bettencourt said the August inspection continued over a multi-day period, and he returned in October to copy pages from Chabot’s acquisitions and dispositions book, but received permission from Chabot to copy only some of them.

Bettencourt wrote that in one instance, he reviewed records of one individual who had purchased 100 firearms from Pac N Arms over a two-year period ”“ in some instances, multiples of the same model ”“ which he wrote indicated to him that the buyer was not a collector, but might be engaged in selling firearms without a license.

Advertisement

The application for the search warrant asked permission of the federal court to authorize the ATF to examine, inspect and copy the business records of Pac N Arms, reflecting business activity from Jan. 1, 2012 through Aug. 12, 2013. It was signed by a judge in February.

Dean suggested the timeframe associated with the records sought to be copied was different, and pointed out problems associated with record-copying.

“It’s against federal law to compile a database of gun owners,” she said.

Bettencourt, in the affidavit, wrote that he couldn’t know for sure why Chabot refused to allow copying of his records during the inspection as he had in prior years, but wrote that one possible reason is that Chabot “has something to hide,” and noted an investigation carried out by a different ATF agent in 2012, who suspected “straw purchases,” were made there by Anthony Foglio, a felon who was barred from possessing firearms.

Foglio was sentenced to 70 months in prison in September on federal gun charges, including that he bought guns through a third party. According to the affidavit, Foglio shopped with his wife or a friend at Pac N Arms, and they completed the paperwork to purchase guns.

Bettencourt, in the affidavit, wrote that he believes there is reasonable cause to believe Chabot violated the gun control act by failing to make appropriate entries and to maintain federal firearms records; made false statements; failed to report multiple sales of firearms to the same individual; and transferred firearms to a person who is prohibited from possessing them.

Advertisement

Dean said her client is anxious to clear his name. She said Chabot’s clients have been visited by ATF agents, and alleged that agents, by innuendo, have suggested Chabot wasn’t someone with whom they should be conducting business.

Chabot, at his gun shop at the mill on Wednesday, declined comment, citing the advice of his attorney. The gun shop was busy, with half a dozen or more folks perusing the merchandise.

“I’d love to talk, but I can’t,” said Chabot, who said he’s been in business since 1991.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.