3 min read

PORTLAND — Supreme Court justices in Portland will consider whether they erred in overturning a lower court’s decision, which had determined that the public enjoys access to Goose Rocks Beach in Kennebunkport due to a prescriptive easement.

The Supreme Judicial Court ruled earlier this year that the public does not have the right to access Goose Rocks Beach, arguing that private property owners control use of the beach down to the low water mark.

Kennebunkport’s attorney, Amy Tchao, said she hopes that, after hearing arguments on Wednesday, the court will remand the case back to York Court Superior Court in Alfred, which previously had ruled in favor of the town. If that happens, she said, then the town will effectively have to make its case once more, only on a parcel-by-parcel basis.

“The court should have decided there was a prescriptive easement on Goose Rocks Beach, and we’re hopeful they will do that,” said Tchao.

Of concern to Tchao is that the Supreme Court’s initial decision overturning prescriptive easement rights on the beach will have ramifications beyond Kennebunkport. That decision, authored by Justice Ellen Gorman, seems to reverse a precedent set in 1989, in a similar case involving Moody Beach in Wells, which established the tradition of prescriptive easements in the state, according to Tchao.

Advertisement

Brian Willing, another of the town’s attorneys, said in March that the Supreme Court’s initial ruling makes it unclear whether the Moody Beach case is now no longer considered the precedent by which similar cases are judged.

Sydney Thaxter, attorney for the plaintiffs, comprised of property owners along the beach, said he hopes the court decides to uphold its initial ruling.

“I was happy with the decision they made the first time,” said Thaxter. “The reason for that (decision) is for land owners not to feel threatened.”

Justice Gorman on Wednesday said that the court’s first ruling on the matter did not overturn precedent, due to the facts of the case being substantially different from those that had come before it.

“Public lands made available for the public use are ”¦ not going to be subject to prescriptive easement, because all public beaches would have to be shut down, which would make this a very different state,” she said.

Tchao countered that generations of public use has effectively rendered Goose Rocks a public beach, reflected in an ordinance passed by the town last year that regulates public use. The ordinance established that the public may access the beach, but that property owners have the right to ask beach-goers to vacate the premises of they happen to fall within a select “zone” in front of each home.

Advertisement

“If the landowners bought property,” said Tchao, “they bought it with the understanding that it was historically a public beach.”

Thaxter said the town already had its chance to make a case.

“The town waived its right to try the case on a lot-by-lot basis,” he said. “The issue of lot-by-lot was front and center.

“You don’t get a do-over,” he said. “It’s been tried, and the courts have made their decision. There are no prescriptive easements in the inter-tidal zone. There was presumptive permission. The court did not err in its decision.”

Tchao said it’s anybody’s guess as to when the court will make a decision on whether to remand the case back to Superior Court.

“I don’t know how long it’ll take,” she said. “But I’m sure the court is looking at it closely.”

— Staff Writer Jeff Lagasse can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 319 or jlagasse@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.