3 min read

Last week’s report of Gorham Town Councilor Ben Hartwell’s drunk-driving charge, the latest in a string of arrests or summonses involving public officials in Greater Portland in recent years, begs the question: Should town officials be forced from office if they break the law? And, if so, does that apply to any law, however minor?

Hartwell’s summons for intoxicated driving, which took place after he drove off the road and struck a tree, isn’t the first and won’t be the last instance of public officials being accused of breaking the law. It’s also not the first or last instance of a leader choosing not to give up his or her seat after being charged or convicted of a crime. Suzanne Phillips, another Gorham councilor whose term is up this year, was charged and later pleaded guilty to drunk driving in 2012. She did not step down from the council. Judith Roy, a former Scarborough town councilor, was caught drunk driving in 2012. Roy told reporters at the time that she agonized about whether to resign her seat but decided to stay. She was defeated in her re-election bid in November 2013. Former Scarborough state Rep. Sean Flaherty was arrested for drunk driving in 2010. Later that year he ran for re-election but lost.

In Westbrook, Suzanne Joyce, a school board member accused of tampering with the investigation of a high school teacher having sex with a student, was indicted by a Cumberland County grand jury last year on the charge, but declined to resign from her seat, which she still holds. The case was later dropped and Joyce has notified city officials that she will file a suit, claiming she was wrongfully charged.

When officials don’t voluntarily and immediately resign, many towns, but not all, have a code of conduct within the town charter that can provide guidance. The code is usually a boilerplate policy from the Maine Municipal Association that includes the phrase “moral turpitude,” a legal term defined in West’s Encyclopedia of American Law as “conduct that is considered contrary to community standards of justice, honesty or good morals.” Having such a clause is wise and necessary. Each time an elected representative of the people is arrested or summonsed, the incident reverberates in the wider community.

Hartwell’s case in Gorham is prompting a similar strong response. Longtime Councilor Matthew Robinson wanted to review the council’s code of conduct after Phillips’ arrest in 2012, but got sidetracked before that discussion could take place. Now that a similar incident has occurred, he specifically wants to add a clause qualifying drunk driving as an act of moral turpitude worthy of dismissal from the council. The discussion is one every town, not just Gorham, should be having. And the discussion should expand to include other crimes, not just drunk driving.

We consider it a given that people want their town officials to be held to a higher standard since they represent the town. The assumption requires that some sort of consequence should occur – in addition to whatever court-imposed penalty takes place – when officials break the law. Determining the level of that punishment is the tricky part. Gorham, if Robinson gets his wish, will set about trying to define what that punishment should look like. Most likely, the discussion will be lengthy with many considerations since the crime of drunk driving has a spectrum of qualifying considerations: How drunk was the driver? Was someone killed in an accident? Is it a first-time offense? And drunk driving is only one possible crime to be considered.

Advertisement

Because of the potential pitfalls with trying to clarify the moral turpitude clause, the whole community should take part in the discussion so as many angles can be raised and explored. And any decision to change the clause should be done by a vote of the people, not just the councilors.

Robinson’s desire to define and clarify the rules is a good one and should be explored by all communities. But even if nothing comes of it, one thing’s always the case. The people have the ultimate say on who represents them come Election Day.

–John Balentine, managing editor

Comments are no longer available on this story