I am a fourth-generation South Portland native who had the good fortune of helping the Working Waterfront Coalition win its campaign last fall. Though I live across the bridge now, my connections to and love for South Portland are deep. All of my family lives in South Portland and I’m a proud member of First Congregational Church at the top of Meetinghouse Hill.
I received an outstanding education at South Portland High School. I learned that societies must make decisions based on facts, not fear. I also learned that no matter how frustrating or slow the process might be, fair and effective policy making requires collaboration of all stakeholders who allow evidence and conversation to lead them to a fair outcome.
The ad hoc ordinance committee working to ban oil sands shipments in South Portland does not honor that process. While they have solicited input from all stakeholders, they are working toward a pre-ordained goal rather than seeking to reach consensus and see where the evidence takes them.
As a progressive, there have been many times when I have been frustrated by anti-science positions taken by the extreme right.
It seems that those targeting Portland Pipe Line are engaging in some science denial of their own. The National Academy of Sciences, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization chartered by the government to advise lawmakers on important policy matters, has dismissed many of the pipeline safety claims made by those who oppose oil sands development.
Furthermore, President Obama’s State Department has concluded that the construction of pipelines in the United States will not have a material impact on climate change, because oil sands petroleum will make its way to market one way or another.
While I understand and agree with the science of climate change, I also recognize that we aren’t going to end our use of fossil fuels overnight. Fossil fuels will remain an important part of our energy portfolio for the foreseeable future, and it’s our job to ensure they are transported and managed in the safest way possible.
Pipelines and ships are the safest and most efficient methods of transporting petroleum, so as long as our world needs oil, we should adopt policies that favor these transportation methods over others such as trains and trucks.
I hope my friends in South Portland will hit the reset button on this oil sands conversation. It’s time to try again with a blank slate and an open mind that uses a pragmatic, data-driven approach to weigh all of the factors that influence this issue, including the environment, safety, energy policy, market forces, foreign policy, and national security. Our community deserves nothing less.
Justin LaBerge
Portland
Comments are no longer available on this story