ALFRED — A York County Superior Court judge has ruled that the York County Budget Committee must be free to work independently of York County Commissioners, also voiding their censure. The judge also ruled that commissioners cannot enforce a county ethics policy on the budget panel.
The ruling in the civil complaint filed by the budget committee last fall was handed up Tuesday by York County Superior Court Justice John O’Neil.
“The budget committee is eager to sit down and work with county commissioners and the county manager to do the best possible job for the citizens of the county of York,” said budget committee Chairman John Sylvester when asked for reaction to the judge’s ruling. “I hope we can sit down and have a conversation with them.”
“This puts the issue to rest,” said County Manager Greg Zinser, adding that he’ll discuss the matter with county commissioners, take a look at the ruling “and go from there.”
The fifth page of the five-page document made O’Neil’s ruling plain:
“The York County budget-making process relies upon public trust in the Budget Committee members,” O’Neil wrote. “… The censure of the (budget) committee impairs the ability of the committee members to perform their statutory duties by tainting the public image of the individual budget committee members and delegitimizing the budget-making process. For this statutory scheme to work as mandated, the budget committee must be free to work independently of the York County Commissioners.
“The statute compels the Court to declare the York County Code of Ethics invalid and unenforceable as applied to members of the York County Budget Committee and the censure of the members of the budget committee void.”
With the ruling handed up Tuesday, neither the budget panel nor county commissioners had much time to digest its contents when asked for comment by the Journal Tribune.
County Commissioners Vice Chairman Dan Cabral hadn’t seen the ruling on Tuesday afternoon, but said he expected commissioners will discuss it with Libby, the county attorney. He said he was surprised at the ruling, but seemed ready to put it behind him, and said he hoped the budget committee and commissioners can work together on the next budget.
“I’m of the mind, the court made a decision; that’s it,” he said Tuesday. “We let it go and go back to work on the budget, that’s it. I hope both sides can focus on the budget.”
Budget committee Vice Chairman Joe Hanslip said he is “elated” by the judge’s decision.
“I feel that Justice O’Neil correctly interpreted the statute and weighed the arguments, and recognized the budget committee has a function that is separate and autonomous from the commissioners,” Hanslip said. “Now that the Justice has ruled, my hope is that both respective bodies can get back to the people’s business, and I look forward to creating a budget that is spending county dollars wisely while being responsive to the needs of the citizens of York County.”
The ruling follows a lengthy dispute between the commissioners and budget committee.
In July, commissioners voted 4-1, with Sallie Chandler, Dan Cabral, Gary Sinden and Richard Dutremble in favor, and Michael Cote opposed, to censure the budget committee, after members refused to sign disclosure forms associated with the ethics policy commissioners had earlier adopted. In declining to sign the county policy, budget committee members cited a clause that they said would allow commissioners to overturn budget committee votes. The budget committee then adopted its own ethics policy and disclosures, which mirrored the county’s policy with the exception of the offending clause.
County attorney Gene Libby at the time said the clause meant commissioners could send a matter back to the budget board for a re-vote if it was determined a budget committee member had a conflict of interest and had voted on the matter.
Budget committee attorney Brad Morin said he didn’t believe commissioners had the authority to tell budget committee members who can and cannot vote on an issue.
Commissioners argued the budget panel is a committee of York County government; budget committee members pointed out that the committee was created by the Legislature.
Following their censure, the budget committee filed a civil complaint with the court.
The commissioners now have 21 days to appeal the ruling.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less