6 min read

SCARBOROUGH – Following a series of nine whirlwind meetings since Dec. 27, Scarborough’s ad hoc Animal Control Advisory Committee completed its assigned task on Monday, agreeing on a list of recommendations designed to protect the endangered piping plover shorebird from dogs, while also getting the town out of hot water with the federal government.

The proposed ordinance changes place new limits on dog access to public beaches during the spring and summer, and introduces new fall and winter restrictions. However, the changes also include a mechanism for buying dogs some off-leash beach time during the summer, wherever plovers fail to appear.

The new rules stem from a $12,000 fine assessed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service following the July 15 killing of a plover chick by a dog on Pine Point Beach. That incident resulted in an agreement that knocked the fine down to $500 in exchange for a host of local concessions. Among those, the town agreed to Fish and Wildlife guidelines that call on dogs to be leashed at all times when on public beaches during the plover nesting season, from April 1 to Aug. 30.

However, on Oct. 2, when the Town Council formally acquiesced to that plan, it went one step further, on a surprise motion by Councilor Kate St. Clair, voting 5-2 to establish a town-wide leash law. That vote held open the possibility of creating dog parks in town, but until then required dogs to be leashed at all times when on any public property, including beaches, ballfields, parks and sidewalks.

A grassroots advocacy group called Dog Owners of Greater Scarborough, which already had sprung up to oppose the agreement with the feds, quickly transformed into a political action committee and successfully petitioned to overturn the Oct. 2 council vote. The town-wide leash law was struck down overwhelmingly by voters, 2,880 to 1,059, at a special election on Dec. 3.

That led to the creation of the ad hoc committee in hopes it could somehow reach a compromise. Its recommendations for dogs and plovers will be heard at the next Town Council meeting on Feb. 19. According to Town Manager Tom Hall, the council will hold a special workshop session at 6 p.m., an hour before the regular meeting, to consider the committee’s final report.

Advertisement

But what will happen to that work product, Hall ventured, is anybody’s guess.

“There’s a dramatic difference of opinion around this table,” he told the committee. “Just imagine what the council will do.”

Following the Dec. 3 vote, Scarborough’s leash law was reset to what has been on the books since 2004. Those rules allow dogs to run free on municipal beaches from sunrise to 9 a.m. between June 15 and Sept. 15, if under “voice control.” Dogs are banned from public beaches during those months between the hours of 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., and can be walked only on a leash between 5 p.m. and sunset. There are no restrictions from Sept. 16 to June 14.

Recommendations

The committee recommends splitting the plover season into two parts. During the most critical nesting period, from April 1 to May 14, dogs must be leashed at all times on beaches, from dawn to dusk, on leads no longer than 8-feet in length.

In the next timeframe, from May 15 until the Tuesday after Labor Day – in rules DOGS members say are more about people than about plovers – dogs are banned from the beaches between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., and must be leashed from sunrise to 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. to sunset.

Advertisement

However, individual beaches could be “released” on or after July 15 if no plover nests have been detected, or once 40 days have passed since the last plover hatched. Beach release applies only to public shores, such as Higgins, Pine Point and Ferry beaches. Scarborough Beach State Park and the private Western Beach, from which dogs are banned year-round, retain their own rules.

The committee advisement also includes the first “off-season” limits on dogs in Scarborough. If adopted by the council as recommended, dogs will still be able to run free from the Tuesday after Labor Day until March 31, except for the hours between 11 a.m. and 2 p.m., when they must be leashed.

The committee, which technically ceased to exist with its last meeting, also calls on the Town Council to establish a standing animal control advisory committee. The primary purpose of that group, said Hall, would be to work for implementation of the ad hoc group’s remaining recommendations.

“Some of which might take years, frankly,” he said.

Chief among the committee’s other opinions is that the town should consider the co-op beach, from the town pier at Pine Point to the sea wall near the Rising Tide restaurant, as a year-round “dog beach.” That recommendation has been dismissed by some DOGS members, who note that the co-op beach is no beach at all during high tide.

A motion in committee to try and get Ferry Beach delisted as a plover habitat was killed 4-3, the same divide DOGS members predicted based on the committee membership.

Advertisement

The committee has, however, called for establishment of a dog tag program based on a similar set-up in Boulder, Colo., which notes that being able to walk a dog off leash is “a privilege,” not a right.

The tags, which would include separate fees for residents and non-residents, would require tag holders to acknowledge receipt of educational materials regarding plovers and voice control. However, Hall said, a call for tag holders to read that material in the presence of the town clerk will not likely happen.

“It will be up to people to take the material and educate themselves,” he said.

Hall, who said he expected to have the committee’s final report drafted and ready for council review by Friday, noted that some conflicting details of the proposed tag program did emerge from committee and will likely survive through to the completed list of recommendations.

“I don’t see how the council can adopt both of these recommendations,” he said. “But they may choose to meld them somehow.”

The committee report also includes a call to beef up the “plover coordinator” position named in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife agreement, a post that nominally exists already within the town’s department of community services.

Advertisement

“We have to monitor all of this stuff long term,” said Councilor Bill Donovan, who served on the ad hoc committee.

In addition to establishing a 200-foot setback from any plover enclosures set up by Maine Audubon or state wildlife officials, the committee report also will recommend an “enhanced focus” on enforcement of the leash law, as well as new education initiatives and improved signage at all beach access points.

Education and enforcement have been the clarion call of the DOGS group, which has repeatedly said that this, and not new ordinance rules, are what is most needed to protect the plover.

“I walk the beach every day, and there still are people who don’t know any of this is going on,” said DOGS President Katy Foley, who served on the ad hoc committee.

“Maybe they’ve been living under a rock,” said Hall.

“Well, there always will be a percentage of people who are unaware, or who feel it doesn’t apply to them if they are aware,” said Donovan.

Advertisement

Long-term measures called for by the committee include distributing materials advising homeowners and summer residents to keep cats, a strongly suspected if unproven plover nemesis, indoors. Also, the town’s Pest Management Advisory Committee has been called on to “engage the golf courses” in town on their use of weed and pest control products, suspected by some in the decades-long decline of plover populations.

Other recommendations include petitioning to add areas north and east of Scarborough Beach as essential plover habitats, increasing enforcement of fireworks regulations, and evaluating trash collection measures, with an eye toward reducing the overall number of trash cans on the beach, while placing them as far from plover nests as practicable. Concern that beach raking may deprive plover chicks of both food sources and hiding places has prompted a call to solicit state and federal agencies on “best management practices” related to beach maintenance.

Finally, while the committee says the town should move forward on the creation of dog parks on public property, and encourage both the Scarborough Conservation Land Trust and the Eastern Trail Management District to maintain their current access rules for dogs, one other animal has been drawn into the discussion.

A final change recommended by the committee would amend the town’s Horse Beach Permit Ordinance to allow horses on public beaches from Oct. 1 to April 1.

Comments are no longer available on this story