KENNEBUNKPORT — On Tuesday, the Maine Supreme Judicial Court in Portland reversed a lower court’s determination that the public has the right to use Goose Rocks Beach in Kennebunkport ”“ meaning property owners would technically have the ability to ask beach-goers to remove themselves from the premises.
That ruling overturns the findings of York County Superior Court in Alfred, which in 2012 ruled that the town and the public enjoy a “prescriptive easement,” which draws on custom and precedent to make any portion of the beach, whether on wet or dry sand, open to public use.
In all, 29 beachfront property owners were named in the ruling. Those property owners initiated proceedings in Superior Court in 2009, seeking a judgment declaring his or her ownership and exclusive right to use the portion of the beach abutting their respective properties, extending down to the low-water mark.
“The town is very disappointed,” said attorney Amy Tchao, who represented Kennebunkport during Superior Court proceedings. “The state as a whole should be disappointed.”
The reason for that, she said, is that the implications of the ruling extend far beyond the bounds of Goose Rocks Beach, affecting a large portion of beaches throughout the state.
“The larger effect is that it’s impossible to have a prescriptive easement on any beach in Maine, which is a radical departure,” said Tchao. “It means almost all of these beaches could be considered private property.”
Effectively, she said, the public will continue to be able to use these beaches, but would have to vacate the area upon request from an abutting property owner. Owners will now have the ability to rescind what is considered an implied permission to be on the sand.
“We have long recognized that public recreational uses are presumed to be undertaken with the permission of the landowner,” wrote Justice Ellen Gorman in the Supreme Court’s decision. “The presumption of permission derives from the ”˜open lands tradition’ that Maine shares with a minority of other states. … This tradition recognizes the State’s desire to encourage the hunting, hiking and other outdoor activities for which Maine is celebrated and on which Maine’s economy is based. … The presumption recognizes that public recreational use is consistent with, and in no way diminishes, the rights of the owner in his land.”
The impact on Goose Rocks Beach will be mitigated by a beach use ordinance that was crafted by Kennebunkport in 2012 in conjunction with a contingent of litigant landowners. The ordinance established a 25-foot wide private “zone” in front of each property, extending down to the water line, in which a landowner could determine who was allowed.
The ordinance will remain in effect, and Tchao said that, despite the Supreme Court’s decision, over half of Goose Rocks Beach will remain open to the public, in areas owned by the town or Kennebunkport Conservation Trust.
Attorney Sydney Thaxter, who represented the beachfront owners in their suit, agreed wholeheartedly with Tuesday’s ruling.
“It makes it very clear that there were no facts to make the (town’s) case,” said Thaxter. “These residents are not going to be deprived of their ownership of the property.”
Thaxter said the decision will have an impact on more than just beaches. The landowners were joined in their initial suit by the Maine Snowmobiler’s Association, he said, because they were concerned about rights as they pertained to their inland properties. The ruling, he said, gives a clear definition to the bounds of permissive use.
“We have a history of permissive use,” he said. “Just because you live on a beach does not mean that people can claim a right to your beach. You’re there with their permission.”
Acknowledging Kennebunkport’s beach use ordinance, and citing the general tolerance of his clients, Thaxter said he doesn’t expect the ruling to infringe greatly on the public’s enjoyment of the beach.
“The town made it seem as though the owners were trying to shut down access to the beach, and that was never the case,” he said. “An owner may ask someone to move, but that’s rare. I don’t anticipate that’ll happen very often.”
— Staff Writer Jeff Lagasse can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 319 or jlagasse@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less