4 min read

It is annual budget season in South Portland and time for school and city officials to mislead voters about the need to increase property taxes. A few weeks ago at the first joint workshop of the City Council and the Board of Education on the 2014-15 budget, they repeated many of the annual excuses for tax increases. In addition, they predicted that this year’s increase could be large due to cuts in state funding.

As I stated in my last column, South Portland property taxes are about 15 percent too high due to financially irresponsible decisions made over the past 10 years by the city manager, school superintendent and City Council. The state of Maine property tax division calculates the full value property tax rate for every community in the state each year. In 2003, South Portland’s tax rate was 7 percent greater than the weighted state average rate. By 2006, South Portland’s tax rate was 14 percent greater, and by 2010 it was 20 percent greater than the state average rate. The state average tax rates for 2011-2013 have not yet been calculated, but it is clear based on the tax increases in the last three years, South Portland’s tax rate will continue to be 20 percent greater than the state average.

Below are five of the many reasons for the higher taxes in South Portland in 2014. All are due to poor financial decisions made by city and school officials, not because of cuts in state funding. These five total about $5 million a year in wasteful spending and excessive tax increases. There are many other poor decisions that add another $3 million a year and bring the total to about $8 million. This $8 million a year creates a property tax rate that is about 15 percent too high.

Excessive High School Expansion Costs

Once completed the expanded South Portland High School will be about 307,000 square feet (the largest in the state) and cost about $65 million including interest. Based on the Dec. 1, 2013, elementary and middle school enrollments, the SPHS (currently 851 students) will peak at about 950 students in 2017-18. By comparison, Noble High School, which was built in 2001 and designed for 1,500 students, is only 250,000 square feet. The financially responsible SPHS expansion would have resulted in at most a 240,000-square-foot facility and cost about $40 million or $25 million less. The excessive expansion will cost taxpayers more than $1 million a year in excessive costs over the next 25 years.

Excessive School Administrative Costs

Advertisement

The superintendent has admitted that South Portland spends millions more on education than the state standard. But she continues to claim that the number of school buildings was a major factor in why the costs are so high, like having two middle schools instead of one. She has made that claim several times over the past four years and I have illustrated several times that the claim is false, but she continues to make it. For example, the 2012-13 South Portland middle school’s guidance department budget had five staff positions and $331,276 in total costs or $456 per student (based on 725 students). The budget had 2.5 positions at each school (one staff position would split their time between the two schools). The total guidance costs are in excess of the state standards and other schools in the area, not because there are two schools, but because they have decided that they want to spend more than the state has determined is needed. At Scarborough’s middle school, the total guidance costs budgeted for 2012-13 was only $150,279 or $187 per student (based on 800 students). South Portland’s costs are 2.44 times that of Scarborough’s. Similar excessive non-teaching costs in other administration areas exist and have nothing to do with the number of school buildings. In total, excessive school administrative costs are at least $1 million a year.

Budgeting Errors

Every year for the past several years, city taxes have been at least $1.5 million more than needed to cover actual expenses. The city and school officials continue to collect excessive taxes and have created surpluses greater than is prudent and much greater than any other communities in the area.

New Community Services Facility

In the next 25 years, the new facility will cost taxpayers including interest about $27 million. The current public works facility could be replaced at its current location for $3-5 million. The excessive costs will be at least $1 million a year.

Co-Curricular And Extra-Curricular Activities

Advertisement

The school superintendent admitted that South Portland spends $1.5 million a year on co-curricular and extra-curricular activities and that the state standard is only $100,000. Despite spending 15 times the state standard, two years ago the school board rejected their own subcommittee work on a plan to charge fees for athletics and co-curricular activities. Last year in fact, the school established a new boy’s ice hockey team at a cost of $34,000 a year despite having not enough participants to field a full team. Every other community in the area requires fees (pay to play plans). Not charging activity fees for school activities is also inconsistent with the treatment of activities provided by the community center and the recreation department. All individuals both school-aged and adults are required to pay fees for numerous activities and a greater percentage of South Portland residents benefit from these activities than those that utilize the school activities. At least $500,000 a year in costs could be eliminated by a combination of charging fees and eliminating some of the excessive co-curricular and extra-curricular activities.

While it is too late to fix the SPHS expansion and some other issues, there are still about $5 million a year in cost savings that can be established in 2014, that will eliminate any need for a tax increase and actually would create a much needed tax reduction. It’s time for the City Council to stop blaming the state and others for property tax increases. Just look in the mirror and they will see who can fix their budget problems.

Al DiMillo lives in South Portland.

Comments are no longer available on this story