4 min read

SANFORD — This city has reduced the amount of trash it throws away ”“ from 7,400 tons in 2009 to 4,750 in 2013 ”“ and projects to dispose of even less, about 3,400 tons, in 2014. Sanford has nearly doubled its recycling rate and, along with some other York County communities, negotiated a lower tipping fee to dispose of trash.

But some of Sanford’s savings ”“ about $50,000 annually ”“ could be eaten away by fees through a new law, L.D. 1483, proposed by Penobscot County state Sen. Emily Cain and co-sponsored by House Speaker Mark Eves of North Berwick, among others.

The bill would assess a fee on licensed landfills, which in turn are expected to pass the fee along to municipalities. Fees would go into a fund to be disbursed to municipalities, recycling or compost programs, based on the tipping fee they pay to an incinerator. The fee to be disbursed would be at least $30 per ton, according to the bill’s text.

A public hearing on the new law, before the Committee on Environment and Natural Resources, was scheduled to begin at 1 p.m. today in Augusta. The committee is scheduled to hold a work session on the bill on Wednesday, Jan. 15.

Cain on Wednesday did not respond to an email seeking comment, but told the Journal Tribune last week the impetus for the legislation is to preserve the current “level playing field” between landfills and incinerators, because the incinerators’ contracts for selling energy will eventually run out.

Advertisement

At that point, she said, Penobscot Energy Recovery Company, in her district, along with Ecomaine in Portland and Mid-Maine Waste Action Corp. in Auburn, will be at a competitive disadvantage with landfills. She said she hopes the bill she proposes will be “a vehicle for a larger conversation” on Maine’s “solid waste policy.”

Sanford is among a host of communities crying foul. Public Works Director Charles Andreson, who updated the city council on the proposed bill Tuesday, called the proposed new law “offensive and outrageous.”

He pointed out that the state worked with Biddeford to close the Maine Energy Recovery Company incinerator ”“ where Sanford and more than a dozen other York County communities had disposed of their trash ”“ and now, L.D. 1483 proposes a fee of $14 to $19 per ton on waste that goes to landfills.

Old Orchard Beach is among other communities questioning the proposal. Town Manager Larry Mead spoke up about it earlier this week. Mead estimated the seaside town would end up paying $45,000 annually in fees.

“I certainly believe it’s an unfair proposal that really ends up dividing towns,” Mead said, by taking money from some communities and giving it to others.

“I also think it’s bad public policy,” he continued.

Advertisement

The three incinerators in Maine have limited capacity, and are aging and inefficient, he said.

“They couldn’t handle all the trash in Maine by a long shot,” he said.

Mead said the state won’t license any more incinerators.

Sanford was paying upwards of $88 per ton when its trash was sent to MERC. Now, Sanford sends its waste to MERC’s parent company, Casella, which disposes of it in a landfill. The city now pays about $71.50 a ton for disposal, a fee negotiated by the Tri-County Group of about 13 municipalities.

Kennebunk Town Manager Barry Tibbetts, a leader of the Tri-County Group, said if the legislation passes, it would cost 14 York County communities a combined $360,000 in future costs. Tibbetts instead proposes a surcharge on waste coming into the state from elsewhere.

Biddeford and Wells municipal managers have also voiced opposition to the proposed law.

Advertisement

Waterboro is one of the municipalities in Maine that is a part owner of Ecomaine. In an email to municipal managers, legislators and others, Town Administrator Gary Lamb said he personally believes the state should burn more trash and reduce or eliminate landfills altogether, but he added that he believes upcoming legislation should be constructed to minimize or eliminate short-term penalties to landfill towns that have no ready access to incinerator facilities.

“Let’s face it, former MERC towns should not be fined just because the MERC incinerator went out of business, and now all that trash is landfilled,” Lamb wrote, in part. “Landfill towns in the county should also not be fined just because they have no reasonable access to present incineration facilities.”

Sanford’s resolve, approved unanimously by the city council Tuesday, asks that the state focus on development of technology for waste processing that reduces the volume of waste for disposal, rather than levying a fee upon some, but not all, to support what they described as “limited and antiquated” technologies like the waste-to-energy facilities.

— Staff Writer Dina Mendros contributed to this report. Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com. Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.