SCARBOROUGH – Although telemarketing calls made this week on behalf of the Scarborough Athletic Council are legitimate, questions persist regarding fundraising attempts allegedly conducted last week, before the campaign began.
According to Scarborough Athletic Council Treasurer Greg L’Heureux, his group has hired Brent Wyatt East Inc. of Falmouth, Mass., to help sell program advertising and tickets for its annual comedy night fundraiser.
That event, to be held on March 14 in the Winslow Homer Auditorium of Scarborough High School, will this year feature Randy Judkins and the Maine Hysterical Society.
The Scarborough Athletic Council was formed about a decade ago to support athletes and team managers of Scarborough High School and to assist the athletics director with program promotion. However, unlike most booster groups, the primary activity of the council, L’Heureux says, has been to provide scholarships to graduating seniors. Those awards are based on good sportsmanship and other qualities, he said.
According to L’Heureux, the Scarborough Athletic Council has handed out $100,000 in scholarships in the past eight years, with $14,000 given last year alone.
“We are the single largest source of scholarships at Scarborough High School,” said L’Heureux.
However, that level of support does not come easy, and council members have relied on a marketing firm to produce the annual comedy show, even though that means it only gets about one-third of the ticket price, the remainder being split between the marketing firm and the performers.
“It’s just a matter of the volunteers being a very small group of parents. We just don’t have the hours during the day to do this,” L’Heureux said.
What’s odd about this year’s marketing campaign, however, is that six days before it began, someone allegedly made “aggressive” calls to collect donations for the show.
“We received the call just yesterday,” read a Jan. 3 email from a Scarborough resident reporting the incident to the Current. That person asked that his name not be used because, “I don’t want to be involved. I like the school.”
However, the person did say, “The calls have been pushing people like myself, on a fixed income, to make a donation, of which I was led to believe all of the proceeds were benefiting the school. I was also told the call was from a member of the [Athletic] Council.”
L’Heureux said Tuesday that he has spoken to the person who contacted the Current, and that it is the only complaint he or anyone else on the Athletic Council has received thus far. However, L’Heureux and Athletic Council President Lisa Huber, also contacted by the Scarborough resident, took the complaint seriously, he says, and immediately contacted Brent Wyatt East.
That’s when things began to get strange.
“He called me last week to say, ‘We’ve already got a complaint,” and I was like, “I haven’t even begun making calls yet,” said Joanne Matheson, who is handling the Scarborough Athletic Council account for Brent Wyatt East.
If whoever made the call did claim to be a council member, it was clearly part of a scam of some type, said Matheson.
“It’s against the law to do that,” she said. “You can only say you are calling on their behalf. You can say the call is ‘for’ someone, but not ‘from’ them.”
Matheson said she identifies herself on every contact as calling from Brent Wyatt East.
So, who made the call?
“I have some suspicions that I might know who it is, but I’m not positive,” she said. “We have no proof yet. Whoever it is, it would have to be someone who is familiar with the campaign and who knows when the calls usually begin.”
Matheson recently retired from another marketing firm, East Coast Marketing Group, based in Westbrook. That company had a three-year contract to handle the comedy night campaign for the athletic council, which L’Heureux chose not to renew this year.
“Greg [L’Heureux] did come to me and ask me if I thought I could handle it on my own,” said Matheson. “I said no and referred him to Brent Wyatt East.”
It was only afterward, said Matheson, that she accepted a Brent Wyatt East offer to work the contract for them. Still, Matheson said, that does not mean East Coast Marketing made the mystery calls.
“Whoever it is, what we are concerned about is that it could be somebody, for whatever reason, who is trying to get us in trouble with the Maine Attorney General’s Office,” said L’Heuruex.
Martha Demeritt, a complaint examiner with the consumer protection division of the Maine Attorney General’s Office, said on Tuesday that no complaints have been filed recently from Scarborough, or concerning either Brent Wyatt East or East Coast Marketing.
A call placed Tuesday afternoon to East Coast Marketing was transferred to a man who refused to give his name or title, but did say, “I have no idea what you’re talking about; it sounds a little bizarre to me.”
After confirming that East Coast Marketing did work for the Scarborough Athletic Council last year, the man said, “I find it highly insulting that anyone would suggest that,” when asked if the company might have, even mistakenly, made any calls this year.
“It seems to me this is an iceberg with a whole lot below the surface,” he added, tagging out-of-state marketing firms as “unscrupulous” telemarketers who “will do whatever they have to do.”
“I would say they are trying to shift the blame onto someone else for something they did wrong,” he said.
Both companies are registered with Maine’s Office of Professional and Occupational Regulation as professional solicitors. A genuine caller from either organization should be able to provide its license number upon request.
What is important for Scarborough residents and business owners to know, said L’Heureux, is that any solicitations made for the Scarborough Athletic Council by Brent Wyatt East are legitimate, and began this week.
“Scarborough Athletic Council’s annual comedy show and high school basketball game concessions are the primary sources for funding scholarships for graduating seniors,” he said. “Local businesses and residents are being contacted in an effort to raise enthusiasm and support for this important cause.”
Comments are no longer available on this story