After rumors of underage drinking led to an uproar Wednesday on the handling of disciplinary action for Westbrook student-athletes, school officials are calling for an independent review of the school’s code of conduct policy.
At a Westbrook School Committee meeting Wednesday evening, Superintendent of Schools Marc Gousse announced that there would be an internal review of school policy and procedures used during “investigations of suspected code of conduct violations.”
While details of the events are hard to pin down, Westbrook High School Principal Jon Ross said Thursday that a number of Westbrook students were handed athletic suspensions following their alleged involvement in a party that included underage drinking. However, Ross said that after further details of the events were disclosed to both Ross and Athletic Director Marc Sawyer, they made a mutual decision to lift the suspensions.
It is still unclear when or where the party was held and how many and when the suspensions were issued.
“If I have any doubt, or get new information that makes me wonder if I can pull all of this together and be 100 percent sure, I have to un-suspend everybody,” Ross said. “Marc and I both said, ‘We have to take a step back.’”
Ross added that due to confidentiality, he couldn’t disclose the information that led to the suspensions being lifted.
Much of the controversy, possibly even overshadowing the issue of underage drinking, has come from speculation that members of the football team were reinstated solely so they could participate in last weekend’s playoff game against Kennebunk. Ross said that speculation is false.
“Given the new information, we un-suspended all of the athletes,” he said. “I think we had a representative sample of probably every fall sport, not just football.”
Both Ross and Gousse cited a problematic clause in Westbrook’s athletic policy known as “knowingly present.” According to Ross, the policy says that if students are “knowingly present” at a party with alcohol, they need to leave within a reasonable amount of time. He said events such as this, which occur off school property and not during school hours, only add to the speculative nature of such issues.
Cari Spardella, a teacher at Westbrook High School, expressed concern during the public comment session at Wednesday’s School Committee meeting. She said she thinks that the school’s code of conduct policy has been “thrown out the window.”
“They should be held to a higher standard, and currently they are not,” she said. “As a teacher and former graduate of Westbrook High, it sickens me morally and ethically.”
Spardella added that she would like to know how the department plans to deal with the upcoming winter sports season, and that morale in the school is currently “awful,” due to the controversy.
Robert Luce, a Westbrook resident, asked the committee for further information on the events, but School Committee Chairman Jim Violette said the committee’s hands were tied, both because of confidentiality issues, as well as its role as jurors if any disciplinary issue has to be handled by the committee.
The policy review, which will be conducted by Martha Sumner, Westbrook’s director of human resources, will ask Sumner to make recommendations to the school department on potential policy changes.
“This review may generate a referral to the Westbrook School Department policy committee for a consideration of any amendments and recommendations to existing policies,” Gousse said Wednesday.
Sumner could not be reached for comment Thursday afternoon.
Gousse also said Wednesday that the department plans on hosting a community forum sometime after Thanksgiving to process feedback on the code of conduct, disciplinary and athletic policies.
This is the second incident involving student-athletes, when members of the Westbrook High School baseball team were sentenced in July to community service after vandalizing the Wainwright Fields in South Portland in June.
Comments are no longer available on this story