Unless your friends are the open-minded, cool-headed sort, it’s probably a good idea to avoid any kind of discussion about politics if you still want invites to their backyard barbecues and all-night keggers. Political divisiveness being what it is, voicing support for a candidate or policy is a good way to get paperweights chucked at your head. Civil discourse has become the jousting event on American Gladiators.
Fortunately, a guy like me has friends who can discuss opposing viewpoints without bare-knuckle fisticuffs. That’s a nice luxury for a man to enjoy.
Less enjoyable is that, if talking to a conservative or libertarian, I can never gain traction in these discussions ”“ because I belong to the “liberal media.” The ultimate trump card, “liberal media” is a phrase that effectively ends all conversation, because it re-casts everything I’ve said as biased and invalid. Never mind that it’s a myth as fanciful as the gods of Olympus, or a thought-provoking Pauly Shore movie. It’s a cheat code, an end-run around any serious examination of a person’s own logic.
When relating stories involving personal acquaintances, I like to change their names for two reasons: To protect their identities, and because naming things is fun. So allow me to share an anecdote about my good buddy “Skeletor.”
One thing I should make clear is that Skeletor’s an awesome dude in just about every way. He’s gregarious, generous, thoughtful and has that rare ability to grow a lumberjack beard overnight, indicating testosterone levels that could mutate a small animal. But he’s a believer in an inherently liberal media, a vast machine that is somehow controlled by a sinister puppeteer with a donkey emblem on his chest and a cape made of food stamps.
About a year ago, I sat with him in his computer room while we discussed the state of the media, and while the conversation was civil and free of acrimony, at some point in the evening he did something telling: He turned to his computer screen and opened up the Drudge Report, an unabashedly right-leaning news site with blatantly leading headlines such as “Bill allows criminal illegals safe harbor,” and “Obama: Anti-Christ, or just a big, fat doodie-head?”
Oh, Skeletor.
While he doesn’t share many of their more distasteful characteristics, he does unfortunately belong to that group of people who blast the mainstream media for liberal bias ”“ and then in the next breath, praise conservatively biased news outlets for telling the “truth.” That there exists a choice of legitimately neutral news organizations is a thought that never occurs to this group. It’s not controversial enough. It’s more exciting ”“ and more gratifying to one’s ego ”“ to believe that there’s a small, savvy elite who have figured out how to get their news from “real” news sources that “tell it like it is.” (As an aside, putting words in quote marks is “fun.”)
Do some news outlets have an indisputably liberal bent? Of course. When reports surfaced that the IRS had targeted conservative political groups for special scrutiny, and that the Obama administration may have known about it, anchors at MSNBC set land speed records racing to their desks to defend the president ”“ with pundits like Lawrence O’Donnell stopping just short of painting a watercolor of the chief executive wearing fig leaves and a Roman toga.
And, as any yin must have its yang, MSNBC has Fox News, that paean to tunnel-vision Republicanism. Windbags like Sean Hannity were perplexed when the George W. Bush administration wasn’t immediately followed by the rapture, so convinced were they that he was the second coming of the messiah.
So yes, biases of every political stripe exist in media. That’s been the case since the 18th century, when state’s rights newspapers accused President Washington of promoting a strong federal government so he could subvert the burgeoning republic with a monarchy.
But it’s been the nonpartisan faction of the mainstream media ”“ led by honest, objective journalists ”“ that has broken some of history’s most important stories, and held governments and politicians accountable. Watergate, the atrocities of Vietnam, abuses at Guantanamo Bay; these were all stories broken by the media, not by some guy in a basement blogging his conspiracy theories about Martians brainwashing Americans through subliminal messages in Clorox commercials. These are the people who break their backs, and in some cases risk their lives, to deliver impartial information.
Look, it’s a way more complex media landscape than it was 40, 50 years ago. That’s obvious. We’ve come a long way from the days of good ol’ reliable Walter Cronkite. It’s harder to know which media outlets are objective, and which are trying to advance a partisan agenda. But it’s not impossible. The further one gets from the broad center of media, the more likely one is to encounter bias, not less. That’s what’s sad about the post-millennial electorate: Because shunning something mainstream is attractive to people, everyone retreats to their respective corners, fomenting dissent from the fringes, where true bias is born. In seeking the truth, they actively avoid it.
Restoring the public’s trust in real journalism is key to ensuring that the fringe outlets don’t become mainstream themselves. How do we do this? By convincing Skeletor to delete the Drudge Report from his Internet bookmarks.
I hope he doesn’t bristle at the suggestion. ‘Cause honestly, I don’t want to stop being invited to his cookouts. His potato salad is to die for.
— Jeff Lagasse is a staff writer and columnist for the Journal Tribune, and thinks all pundit shows should be replaced by reruns of “Garfield & Friends.” He can be contacted at 282-1535, Ext. 319 or jlagasse@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less