4 min read

A widespread uproar has greeted Gov. Paul LePage’s biennial budget plan, with school districts and municipalities crying foul over the shift of revenues to the state, and the shift of some costs to local property taxpayers.

The $6.3 billion LePage budget is not good news for most Mainers, particularly with its elimination of the Homestead Exemption tax credit for all but those over 65 years of age. For example, if you own a $200,000 home in Biddeford and you’re under age 65, you can expect to pay $500 more in property taxes, according to figures provided by the Maine Municipal Association. And that’s not counting the increase in sales taxes everyone will see when they purchase goods and services. Newspapers, in particular, have been singled out for a new tax ”“ raising concerns that reach far beyond the wallet (see op-ed at right).

In response to some criticism of his budget, LePage, in April, invited other groups to come up with a better plan, and some have answered that call.

The “Gang of 11” is a bipartisan group of legislators that have put forth a bill, LD 1496, to overhaul Maine’s tax code.

Other groups, including the Fair Share Now coalition and the Mayor’s Coalition, have also suggested that we can do better than LePage’s budget, and have, in turn, started an interesting discussion about the state’s tax structure.

Advertisement

All of the groups suggest a review of how the state collects taxes, from special exemptions for businesses and residents, to sales taxes on goods and services enjoyed by visitors and residents.

While the governor is squarely focused on “out-of-control government spending,” which is certainly important, it’s clear that the revenue side of the equation could use some work, too.

LD 1496, sponsored by the so-called Gang of 11, is currently in the hands of the Tax Committee, which is expected to make recommendations to the Appropriations Committee. The bill’s sponsors are hoping some of its proposals to overhaul the tax code can be incorporated into the upcoming biennial budget.

In short, the bill would send $160 million back to property taxpayers, while LePage’s budget would send none.

The bill would reduce income tax from 8 to 4 percent, and raise about $700 million with a sales tax on just about everything other than health care and education. Co-sponsor Sen. Seth Goodall, D-Sagadahoc County, noted that in 2009, the proposal to expand the tax base failed, in large part because it included some industries, but not others, which is why this bill is more comprehensive. It would also increase taxes on cigarettes, dining out, liquor and wine, and lodging, among other items.

To offset the burden on low- and middle-income people, the bill includes a sales and property tax refund for those who are not high income; with rebates for a single person, for example, available if they earn up to $60,000.

Advertisement

Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, said the state’s tax structure has not been reformed in 40 years and is based on the manufacturing economy of that time ”“ and we agree that it’s time for an overhaul.

Currently, the state’s revenue sharing program sends 5 percent back to municipalities, which goes into the municipal general fund, said Goodall. This proposal would instead direct it to the Homestead Exemption, raising it to $50,000, and give 1.5 percent to the municipalities, thereby ensuring that more of it goes into property taxpayer’s pockets.

Another intriguing part of this bill is its provision to allow municipalities to tax large nonprofits. With the exception of religious properties, all private nonprofits with $250,000 or more of property would be taxed at 25 percent of the value of that property. This will reduce the level at which all other property taxpayers subsidize these large-scale operations. Goodall noted that in Biddeford, for example, the University of New England has a large swath of untaxed waterfront that would bring in a hefty sum, even at 25 percent.

The other groups proposing tax reform have similar ideas, though Fair Share Now ”“ the coalition that includes groups such as the Maine State Employees Association, Maine Education Association and Maine Center for Economic Policy ”“ suggests that the sales tax increases should focus on items that are mainly purchased by out-of-staters, such as for rental cars, as they raise the concern that too much of the taxes proposed by LD 1496 will fall on residents, and people may not know to apply for the rebate.

We agree with the bill sponsors, however, that Maine needs to widen its tax base, as it is one of the narrowest among those states with a sales tax, and the rebate provision will be enough to offset the burden for residents. The tourism industry should certainly be targeted most, however, as it has the least impact to residents. Increasing the tax on rental cars, for example, could save enough money to restore Head Start ”“ and more ”“ according to the Maine Center for Economic Policy.

Many of these proposals have merit, but the focus must be on reducing ”“ or at least not increasing ”“ taxes on average Mainers while maintaining the highest level of service possible. We agree that most businesses would locate here with or without significant tax breaks ”“ and legislators are waking up to the fact that many of these incentive programs seem to have little or no return. LD 1496 would end these tax break programs, such as BETR and Pine Tree Zones, allowing those already enrolled to continue their benefits through the term of the program.

We hope the Appropriations Committee takes this bill seriously as they mull over LePage’s budget proposal. By combining common sense and streamlining reductions in government with taking a new look at the way we tax and the tax breaks we give, surely the state can find a way to balance the books with the least possible impact on the average Mainer.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.