SOUTH PORTLAND – Four men representing the gamut of political thought are running to fill the South Portland City Council seat vacated by Tom Coward, who resigned following his election as a Cumberland County commissioner.
The winner of the District 1 seat will represent the city’s east end, including the Willard Square and Ferry Village neighborhood, and will serve through December 2015. However, voting is open to all South Portland residents, with absentee ballots now available at city hall. Traditional polling will take place on March 12 at the Community Center on Nelson Road.
Whoever prevails will be thrust headlong into an annual budgeting process that is, in the words of Mayor Tom Blake, “as tough as any I’ve ever seen.” According to City Manager Jim Gailey, the biennial budget proposed by Gov. Paul LePage promises to siphon $2.8 million in expected revenue from South Portland, from a suspension of revenue sharing, a shift in excise taxes and changes to the state’s business equipment tax rebate program. Meanwhile, school Superintendent Suzanne Godin has predicted up to $3 million in additional costs from contracted pay hikes and changes to the state funding model, as well as a state shift of teacher retirement pay to the local level. On top of all that, elimination of the homestead reimbursement would hit all homeowners younger than age 65.
Two of the candidates, Rick Carter and Rob Schreiber, bring a wealth of public service to their candidacies, while the other two, Robert Foster and Michael Pock, are relative newcomers to municipal politics.
Carter has won three consecutive terms on the South Portland Board of Education, starting in 2004. He is the school board chairman and has served seven of his nine years on the board as either its chairman or vice chairman. Carter said he’d already resolved to step down after his term ends in December. The council run, he said, is a natural progression from his school board tenure, which he began just as his sons were entering high school.
“With my sons now almost out of college – one is a junior and one is graduated – my intent was this would be my last year on the school board,” said Carter. “But I coached something like 26 youth teams before I was on the board, and look to the council as a way to give back afterward. I think it’s important for people to serve the communities they live in and I think my experience gives me a total school and city perspective on what South Portland needs.
“I think it’s important to have somebody on the City Council who has a detailed understanding of the school budget,” said Carter.
Meanwhile, Schreiber has perhaps the widest expanse of public service of the four candidates. He’s logged nine years on the Planning Board, including two as chairman, along with four years on the comprehensive planning committee, four on the zoning improvement committee and two on the jetport master planning committee.
Like Carter, Schreiber says he plans to step down from his position regardless of the outcome of the March 12 special election.
“I think three terms is plenty. It’s time for some new blood on the Planning Board,” he said. “But in my time on the board, and on my other committees, I’ve learned how to work with others on a problem and build consensus.
“I know we’re not going to make everybody happy with the budget, but I understand that whatever we do we are going to have to work together on the next issue as well,” said Schreiber. “It never hurts to have a good listener on the council.”
Foster has attended every council meeting and every council workshop for more than a year. He retired two years ago, and he was appointed this past July to the energy and recycling committee and says he hopes to make the leap to City Council because he has “the time and energy to give back” to the community.
“I’ve been sitting in the council chambers for a while, listening to everything, because I’m not too happy with some of the past decisions,” he said. “I think it’s time to get some new blood in there. Not too many people have run in the past few years so I thought it was time to step up.
“I’m open minded and I check all the facts before I make a decision,” said Foster. “My long-range thing is to make decisions that are equitable for everybody.”
Pock notes that he is the most fiscally conservative of the candidates and, as such, describes himself as “the dark horse” in the race.
“I’m just concerned about the high tax rate,” said Pock. “We don’t need another tax increase. If anything, we need a tax decrease.
“Everyone tells me don’t bring up the school board if you want to win, that’s the killer,” said Pock. “Well, to me, that’s the elephant in the living room. Test scores in South Portland haven’t been that great compared to the amount of money they’re dumping into the schools.
“So, I can sum up my campaign in six words,” said Pock. “New face, new ideas, old standards.”
While all four candidates agree crafting a budget for the next fiscal year will be their highest priority, and their biggest challenge, they differ somewhat on secondary goals.
Schreiber, who is running the most professional campaign – the only one to issue regular press releases, set up a Facebook page, or distribute so-called “palm cards” – has touted a “triple bottom line” of “People. Planet. Profit.” In addition to strengthening environmental protection in the city, Schreiber wants to improve eastern Broadway, create design standards around the Maine Mall and reduce noise from “party boats” off Willard Beach and on the Fore River.
Foster says economic growth is his biggest priority but laments that “the governor’s budget is really going to put a damper on a lot of the projects we really need to look at.”
Carter said his priority is to maintain school and municipal services at current or better levels, in balance with “the needs of the taxpayers.”
Meanwhile, Pock takes a different tack, saying his primary urge is less to create something new than to hold in on the reins.
“The whole thing is expenditures,” he said. “I’m saying, hey, let’s get the new high school paid for before we move on to the next big thing.”
Budget opposition
Recently, South Portland became one of the first municipalities in the state to adopt a resolution opposing LePage’s proposed budget. While Carter, Foster and Schreiber all say they’d have happily joined in that unanimous decision, Pock says he’d have voted against it.
“That’s none of the town’s business,” said Pock. “They also recently voted on South Portland supporting gay marriage and that’s none of the town’s business, too. That’s a social issue.”
But the suggestions that the governor is cheating South Portland is absurd,” said Pock. “There is surplus in the budget, especially on the school side. They want to set money aside for a rainy day? Well, it’s raining.”
Still, if Pock is sure South Portland can weather the loss of $2.8 million in revenue, the other candidates are not so sure.
“The governor is doing some things that aren’t great to this city and the way the people in this city see things,” said Foster, suggesting the council will now have to justify every service against possible “belt tightening.”
“The city does a pretty good job of running things though, so I don’t know where we are going to come up with that kind of money,” he said.
Foster did not offer up any predictions on what might be cut, nor did Carter or Schreiber, both of whom predicted changes to South Portland’s benefit before the state budget falls under the final gavel later this spring.
“Right now this is about the biggest tax shift I’ve ever seen, so I think it’s critically important for the council to maintain a dialogue with our legislators,” said Carter.
“I have great faith in the people who are serving [in Augusta] right now,” said Schreiber. “It sounds to me like there is some reconfiguring that can happen with the budget. There’s got to be room to negotiate.”
Public works garage
Pock also is the lone dissenting voice among the candidates when it comes to a proposed transportation complex, to be built off Highland Avenue. In November, voters will likely face a bond vote to fund the project, which could dress out at $18 million. Preparation for that vote will consume more than a few council hours over the summer.
Schreiber says the city’s AAA bond rating means interest rates are in South Portland’s favor. The trick, he said, is to make sure residents understand the need, possibly by arranging tours of the public works garage on O’Neil Street.
“This really is an issue that needs to be taken care of,” he said. “It seems to me that every time we have a bond issues where the pubic hasn’t had an opportunity to really understand the issue, they vote no.”
“I’ve had to work in some of the conditions those guys work in now and it’s not pleasant,” said Foster, saying that he “definitely” supports the new facility, although he said he’d willing to look at the price tag.
“The important thing is that we get something that lasts, at least 50 years,” he said.
Carter said the important consideration is not the bottom line, but the annual bond payment and what impact that has on the property tax bills.
“It’s likely that, as other debt it retired, that can be absorbed with very little effect,” he said.
But Pock would have none of it.
“I’m in favor of them fixing the old facility, at least until they get the high school finished,” he said. “It’s better to put a few million into the existing situation than to build an entirely new one.”
School budget
Both Carter and Schreiber said they would fight to maintain current standards in the school department, meaning no cuts to programming or personnel if it can be helped. However, neither would say what increase, if any, they would support in the school’s $39.9 million operating budget.
“We don’t know what the final state numbers are going to be, so to suggest what I think ultimately the city’s responsibility is going to be for education – if somebody has that answer please have them call me,” said Carter. “I don’t have it and I’m as involved in the school budget as anybody. It’s just to premature to say where we are going to be.”
“I feel we always need to weigh the cost and benefits of any tax increase or decrease on the entire South Portland community, then move forward with a decision that will have the best positive impact on the livability of the city,” said Schreiber.
Foster called the school budget “a hard nut to crack,” and also offered no guidance on a percentage increase he might support on new spending. However, he did say the school department must do a better job working with area manufacturers to get students the vocational training they need to transition directly into the workforce.
“Not everybody is geared to go to college and sit in an office,” he said.
Pock, meanwhile, was firm on flat-funding the school department this year, sticking to his assertion that the schools have “plenty of surplus” to fall back on.
“No increase,” he said, adding that he favors administrative consolidation, including a single superintendent to oversee all of Cumberland County.
Other issues
All four candidates support the city’s farmers market, although there was no consensus on where it should be housed this year. Schreiber suggested the Shaw’s parking lot or making the Hamlin School, site of the winter market, a year-round location. Foster said it should be within walking distance of a low-income neighborhood. Pock suggested City Manager Gailey is wrong to keep the market out of Mill Creek Park for fear of ruining the grass. Carter offered no spot, saying that while he “absolutely” thinks the market is “positive for the city,” he does not have “a magic bullet.”
All four candidates favor selling the old Roosevelt School, vacated last fall by Spurwink services, over trying to hammer out a lease arrangement with a new tenant.
Election
Age:?50Born: Portland.Education: University of New Hampshire (1984, economics and history).Occupation: Operations manager, Marshall’s (since 1991).Elective experience: School board (2004-present; chairman 2006-2007, 2009, 2013).Other city posts: Comprehensive planning committee (2010-2012).Residency:?Thompson Street (since 1991).Personal:?Married (29 years), two adult sons.Contact: 767-7179, rchcart@aol.com
Born: Haverhill, Mass.Age:?64Education: “Some college,” University of Maine.Occupation: Retired (was an assistant deli manager for Hannaford’s stores in Scarborough, Gorham and South Portland for nine years).Elective experience: None.Other city posts: Energy and recycling committee (2012-present)Residency:?Front Street (since 1990).Personal:?Married (43 years), four adult children, 12 grandchildren.Contact: 671-3390, rfoster3@maine.rr.com
Age:?66Born: Stuart, Neb. (raised in Wyoming).Education: Westbrook College (1979, accounting).Occupation: Owner, Pock Carpentry (since 1983); Retired U.S. Naval petty officer (1966-1973, plus 14 years reserves).Elective experience: None.Other city posts: NoneResidency:?Grand Street (since 1973).Personal:?Married (44 years), two adult sons.Contact info: pockcarpentry@maine.rr.com
Age:?47Born: DeKalb, Ill.Education: Norwich University, Northfield, Vt. (2001, finance); City University of Seattle (2007, MBA).Occupation: Jazz drummer (36 years), bandleader of Standard Issue since 2011; life insurance and annuity specialist, AAA Northern New England (2012-present, 20 years in financial services).Elective experience: None.Other city posts: Planning Board (2004-present), comprehensive planning committee (2009-2012), zoning improvements committee (2006-2009), jetport master plan committee (2004-2005).Residency:?Stanford Street (since 2001).Personal:?Married (16 years).Contact: 799-2019, robschreiberplaysdrums@gmail.com, www.facebook.com/broadwaysmybeat
Comments are no longer available on this story