5 min read

At the Feb. 4 City Council meeting, the council approved a resolution expressing opposition to several of the governor’s 2013-2015 biannual budget proposals. The resolve stated in part: “These proposals will dramatically increase property taxes in South Portland, taxes which often are unrelated to the ability of property owners to pay, and will require spending reductions which will call into question our ability to protect the health and welfare of our community and provide our residents with government services.”

I agree with some of the points made in the resolve, like opposing the elimination of the homestead exemption in fiscal year 2015 for residents under age 65, and I oppose the elimination of the property tax circuit breaker refund program for low- and moderate-income residents in both 2013 and 2014. However, what is hypocritical in the resolve is the implication that this City Council and city manager have properly considered “the ability of property owners to pay” over the past several years. In the last six years, South Portland’s property tax rate has increased by 26 percent (from $13.10 to $16.50 per thousand valuation). Not many low- and moderate-income residents have seen their incomes increase by that amount and their ability to pay has decreased. Where was the city manger and council’s concern for taxpayer’s ability to pay taxes the past six years? Over that period, the council approved millions in unnecessary spending and has accumulated excessive surpluses that created excessive tax increases.

South Portland’s 2012 property tax rate is already 20 percent higher than Scarborough, which is South Portland’s biggest competitor for any potential economic expansion. Scarborough also has much more developable land available; accordingly any more increases in South Portland’s tax rate will make economic development almost impossible. Rather than dealing with the high tax rate by finding ways to reduce wasteful spending, the city manager is hiring, at an annual cost of about $100,000, an assistant city manager, whose primary job will be to increase economic development in the city. The city manager is also hiring an information services manager at an annual cost of at least another $80,000. Both of these positions should not have been filled. The information services position should have been combined with the similar position in the school department. There are several other duplicate administrative positions that the city and school departments could consolidate to save money.

Albert Einstein said, “We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.” South Portland’s city and school officials as well as the City Council need to see the potential state cuts to revenue sharing as a wake-up call to consolidate city and school administrative positions, eliminate excessive costs and to properly analyze every major expenditure using a cost benefit analysis. Raising taxes should be the last option, not the first.

Next week the City Council will have a workshop meeting on the proposed $23 million (includes $5 million in interest on the bond) public works project. Using the proper new thinking would result in stopping the financially irresponsible project immediately.

Although the city manager stated last June that his staff would prepare an analysis of the benefits of the project, no detail cost savings have been provided to the public. Last year, the city manager made the unsubstantiated claim that heated undercover vehicle storage would reduce wear and tear from environmental exposure like rust. However, experts say heated garages are more likely to cause rust than leaving the vehicles out during the winter. Highway salt can’t do much damage to vehicles in the winter, unless you warm the vehicles up in heated spaces, which will accelerate the corrosive power of the salt.

Advertisement

Even if storing vehicles in the proposed heated garage did reduce rust and wear and tear, there is no evidence that over the past five years that the various public works vehicles and equipment that have been replaced were replaced because of rust or other damage due to exposure.

As I noted last July, even if you incorrectly assumed that storing equipment and vehicles in heated covered garages increased their life by 15 percent, based on the public works department’s $400,000 a year planned equipment purchases in the future, the saving from the 15 percent increase in life would only save about $60,000 a year.

The other major unsubstantiated claim made by the city manager was that the new facility will improve productivity and efficiency. If this is true, how many administrative and hourly workers will be cut in future budgets? Even if 10 percent of the 25 public works positions can be eliminated, the total savings would only be about $125,000 a year based on an average cost of $50,000 per employee.

The combined assumed equipment and wage savings total only $185,000, before reducing the savings by the increased operating costs for utilities and maintenance on the new public works facility of at least $50,000 a year. The net questionable yearly savings of $135,000 would not justify spending more than $3 million on the project, or $20 million less than the proposed amount of $23 million.

The City Council also has not talked about the potential costs of removal of the old public works facility at O’Neil Street, which will likely have significant hazardous waste cleanup issues and an inability to sell the property for years because of the hazardous waste.

The city manager and City Council should immediately stop wasting time and money on the proposed plan. Instead of looking at a $23 million project, they should be looking at a $2 million to $3 million alternative. There are many other alternatives that should be looked at that will cost the city very little, including a combination of making some needed repairs at the present O’Neil location and or reducing the planned equipment purchases over the next five years and gradually reducing public works projects by outsourcing more work similar to the current outsourced trash and recycling program.

On Monday Feb. 25, taxpayers should attend the city council workshop and let the council know where you stand.

Al DiMillo is a retired CPA who lives in South Portland.

Comments are no longer available on this story