3 min read

In just three days, the Maine Energy Recovery Company waste incinerator will cease operations for good. No longer will trucks deposit garbage at the Lincoln Street site to fuel the flames that make that iconic plume of smoke over the city.

The closure means vastly different things to different people. For many of the plant’s employees, it means they’ll be out of a well-paying job to start the new year, and will have to look for another way to support themselves and their families.

Some residents see the closure as an imprudent way to eliminate a lot of tax revenue and jobs, especially now that the city has lost the Hostess Brands plant on top of it.

And the buyout of the property is going to cost taxpayers $6.65 million over the next several years, which has others concerned about their property tax bills as well.

While we recognize all of these concerns that come with such a major change, we agree with those who are hopeful about the Maine Energy closure, as we believe that its end marks a new beginning of bright possibilities for this entire area.

Advertisement

There’s no denying that the stench of burning trash emanating from the plant has impeded the concerted efforts of those who are working hard to reinvigorate the downtowns of Biddeford and Saco. The placement of this unpleasant, but necessary, facility was unwise and it’s contributed to giving Biddeford a black eye for more than two decades.

No longer.

Come Jan. 1, Biddeford’s trash ”“ and that of the other communities that contract with Maine Energy ”“ will be sorted at a Westbrook facility. From there, it will be sent to landfills or incinerators ”“ it’s unclear which at this time ”“ until Maine Energy owner Casella gets word on their request for final DEP clearance to use the Juniper Ridge landfill for that waste.

The state’s solid waste hierarchy policy has been a point of contention for some who oppose the closure of the Maine Energy incinerator. The hierarchy is to reduce, reuse, recycle, incinerate, landfill ”“ in that order. At first glance, yes, putting Biddeford waste in a landfill instead of an incinerator does go against the hierarchy, as the incineration option is listed as preferable. Such a first glance, however, ignores those first three parts of the hierarchy ”“ and those are important components of the closure.

The purchase and sale agreement between Biddeford and Casella requires the city to contract with them for a curbside recycling program, which will be the city’s first attempt at such an effort.

The Biddeford and Saco mayors have also pointed out that this new plan would actually reduce the volume of waste currently deposited at the Juniper Ridge landfill, by eliminating out-of-state waste that is currently accepted at Maine Energy before it is transported to the landfill as ash and residue byproduct.

Advertisement

Beyond the hierarchy issue, we agree with the mayors that the closure of Maine Energy must be viewed differently because of its unfortunate location. Economic development is also tops on the state’s list of “things to do” and having this plant, with its stench and arguably unhealthy emissions, is a hindrance to that goal.

Meanwhile, details are being worked out to begin Biddeford’s first-ever single-sort curbside recycling program July 1 ”“ an important step not only in light of the hierarchy, but one that will make it easy for everyone to reduce their waste.

It may seem hard to imagine Biddeford without Maine Energy after so many years, but there’s no doubt its exit and the new recycling program are going to have an effect on the way all residents see themselves and their city. It’s also going to change how others see the city ”“ particularly developers who have already taken note of Biddeford’s oceanside beauty, industry, educational and arts facilities, and transportation options.

Biddeford’s going to look a lot different once that smoke clears.

Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ

Today’s editorial was written by Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski on behalf of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Kristen by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.