When you walk into the voting booth on Nov. 6, be prepared for some high stakes gambling.
On the national level, will you bet on the status quo in hopes that the economy recovers under current fiscal policies, or do you take a chance on the new guy who would institute a whole new set of policies?
On the local level, will you bet $37.8 million plus an estimated $24 million in interest on design and construction of a new sanitary sewer system that would collect sewage from up to 467 properties in North Windham and Windham Center and convey it along Route 302 to a treatment plant in Westbrook? Or do you decline that bet and take a chance on continuing with the septic systems and the school sewage treatment plant that currently service those areas? Either way, it is a high stakes gamble.
Unfortunately, the stakes are not equal for all Windham residents. Those of us who live outside of the area that would be served by the proposed sewer would have our property tax rate increased by approximately $1 for every $1,000 of assessed property valuation. Property owners within the service area that connect to the sewer would have to pay an additional one-time “betterment” fee of $12.30 per foot of road frontage plus a minimum annual fee of $696 (charged according to volume of water used or wastewater discharged). Those that decline service would still have to pay the betterment fee plus an annual ready-to-use fee of $285. Annual fees would go toward operation and maintenance costs and capital expenses. Commercial, government and institutional properties would be required to connect to the sewer, while residential users would have a choice. Those that do connect would also be required to pay for the pipe and associated equipment installed between the sewer and the buildings being served. Farms along the sewer route would not be subject to the betterment fee.
With those stakes, Windham should be a big winner if the sewer pays off. How might we win? For starters, it is expected that there would be a significant improvement in groundwater quality in the aquifer beneath North Windham, as well as a more certain future for sewage disposal at the school campus in Windham Center. If the sewage discharged from homes and businesses in North Windham is redirected from septic systems to a sanitary sewer, the cause of the nitrate contamination in the underlying aquifer would be largely eliminated.
Inadequate and failing septic systems are suspected of being the primary contributor of nitrate contamination in the aquifer. Although the levels of nitrate contamination do not yet exceed federal and/or state standards for the protection of human health, an evaluation of the trend of nitrate contamination that was performed by an environmental consultant working for the town indicates that nitrate levels could eventually exceed acceptable standards if corrective action isn’t taken. If and when that might occur is anybody’s guess. However, a sanitary sewer should alleviate those concerns, thus offering some assurance that the environment and human health will be protected.
The bigger question is whether there would be an economic benefit associated with a sanitary sewer. One measure of economic success is the number of jobs that could either be saved or created because of a sewer. There have been innumerable cases across the country where construction of a sewer has allowed existing businesses to expand their operations, in addition to attracting new businesses. It can be a critical factor in where a business decides to build. When more jobs are saved or created, all businesses in the area can benefit from increased consumer spending.
Obviously, construction of a sewer is not a guarantee that businesses would expand or relocate in North Windham. Other factors come into play when a business makes a decision, such as transportation infrastructure, zoning, schools, housing, and tax burden. Are there currently businesses in North Windham that would expand if they could connect to a sewer? There doesn’t appear to be an answer for that yet. What new businesses would come to North Windham because of a sewer? No answer for that either. How many jobs added to payrolls in North Windham would it take to offset the burden on businesses and residents who are paying for the construction and operation of the sewer? Don’t know if we’ll ever have an answer for that one. However you decide to vote, are you feeling lucky?
John Mackinnon is a Windham resident and former Windham Town Councilor.
Comments are no longer available on this story