3 min read

LONDON – In some European capitals, they mutter about a Fourth Reich and compare the German chancellor to Adolf Hitler. The French complain about British obstructionism; Brits complain about everyone else. In Spain, a separatist movement is gaining traction.

But the Nobel Committee chose to take the long view Friday, awarding the 2012 Peace Prize to the European Union. The panel reasoned that even if economic divisions are tearing at the harmony Europeans have spent decades building, it no longer seems possible that they would start killing each other again.

From a handful of countries whose leaders shook hands amid the rubble of World War II, the EU has become a 27-nation club of free trade and travel.

“The union and its forerunners have, over six decades, contributed to the advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe,” said Thorbjorn Jagland, the chairman of the Norwegian Nobel Committee. “Reconciliation has become a reality.”

So has name calling and finger pointing. Parties contemptuous of the EU have risen in the polls across the continent as national economies sink into recession. Street protests occur almost daily in hard-hit countries such as Greece and Italy, where angry residents have singled out German Chancellor Angela Merkel for her insistence on fiscal austerity.

Advertisement

Secessionist groups are pressing their cause from Belgium to Italy. And in eternally “Euroskeptic” Britain, some want a referendum on whether to get out of the European Union altogether.

Regeno Para, a factory worker in Madrid, said many Spaniards now associate the European Union with brutal budget cuts. In Spain, one in four workers is out of a job, as is one out of every two young people.

“The most important thing for most people these days is the crisis — paying their mortgages and not losing their homes,” Para said. “Sure, the EU might be a tool for peace. . But it’s not the foremost thing on people’s minds here right now.”

For believers in the European dream, however, announcement of the prize came as a welcome morale boost in difficult times, which Jagland made clear was exactly what the Nobel Committee intended.

“The Nobel Peace Prize committee and in fact the international community are now sending a very important message to Europe: that the European Union is something very precious, that we should cherish it for the good of Europeans and indeed for the good of all the world,” said Jose Manuel Barroso, head of the European Commission, the EU’s executive arm.

This is not the first time that the choice of recipient of the world’s most prestigious prize has generated controversy. When President Obama won it in 2009, many critics said it was an award simply for not being George W. Bush.

Advertisement

There was some criticism Friday over the decision to recognize an institution rather than an individual. In Russia, veteran activist Svetlana Gannushkina, a perennial nominee, called the Nobel Committee’s choice “absurd.”

“It is a prize that in my opinion goes nowhere,” said Gannushkina, a board member of the human-rights group Memorial. “Who gets the prize, the nations of the European Union or the bureaucratic structure that manages it?

“And after all, European states haven’t been all that peaceful in recent years,” she said. “They fought in Yugoslavia, Iraq, and they are still fighting in Afghanistan.”

But precedent exists for picking an organization: The United Nations’ International Atomic Energy Agency won in 2005, and the charity Medecins sans Frontieres (Doctors without Borders) was honored in 1999.

 

Comments are no longer available on this story