WINDHAM – A redistricting proposal for Windham-Raymond schools would unnecessarily uproot some students and inconvenience their families, parents and Windham day-care providers said this week.
But school officials say the plan, which would move elementary students in northern Windham to Raymond, is the best and least-expensive way to solve overcrowding issues in the district, and that the students would adjust quickly to any changes.
The issue was raised by many of the parents who attended a public hearing last week in Windham. For those parents who work, day cares are essential. The 27 child-care facilities in Windham offer before- and after-school care to children of all ages, from babies to 12-year-olds. Parents at last week’s meeting said the Regional School Unit 14 board’s proposal to shift northern Windham students – those living above Whites Bridge Road and Anglers Road – to Raymond schools would sever long-held ties to day-care providers in Windham.
The most notable parent to speak on the topic was Windham High School teacher Erica Brown, who lives in the affected area and said she would have to change day-care providers should the board choose to redraw the lines.
“He’s been there since he was 7 months old, and the thought of having to change child-care providers for him breaks my heart because I have entrusted my most precious gift to them nearly everyday of his young life,” Brown said.
Her son attends A Place to Grow on Danielle Drive in Windham. It’s conveniently located on the way to work for Brown but far from Raymond Elementary School, where he would attend kindergarten next year under the new proposal. Pam Aube, who has run A Place to Grow for 17 years, would be equally crushed. Of her 25 kids, 11 may be affected by the redistricting proposal, she said.
“You get bonded with them as they do with you,” Aube said. “I don’t think it’s fair to expect parents like Erica Brown to uproot Liam, who I have had since he was a baby. Same with most of the other children.”
Jen White, who owns A Joyful Noise Christian Daycare & Learning Center in North Windham, said she has similar worries if the proposal goes through.
“I know when I grew up I was a latchkey kid, but things have changed, not for the better. So safety is a big issue for the parents and they like having a structured environment for them to come to where the kids get help with their homework and they have healthy activities and snacks,” White said. “So it is a big deal, and parents tend to get very attached to their children’s child-care environment. So I think for a lot of parents that are looking at the possibility of having their kids go to the Raymond schools, and not only that, they may have to change their day-care situation as well. That’s a lot of transition.”
Since parents are working and can’t pick up their children from schools, they rely on school-provided bus transportation to drop off their kids at day care. Three buses from various elementary schools drop off at A Joyful Noise, for example. If redistricting occurs, bus routes would end at Whites Bridge Road, meaning kids who attended day care south of the line would no longer receive drop-offs.
Some day cares from Windham could bus students themselves, such as White does with students from Windham Christian Academy. Both she and Aube are considering such services, but doing so may not be financially feasible for all providers.
The other factor is where northern Windham parents work. Many who spoke last week travel south to jobs in Westbrook, Portland and South Portland and drop off and pick up their children during their commute.
Other parents lamented the lack of day-care centers available in Raymond, something White and Aube agree could be a problem.
“The ones that are in Raymond are mostly home-based,” Aube said. “I feel strongly for the kids that I have. I would not want them going anyplace else.”
“Raymond has a program located in the [Raymond Elementary] school, but they don’t have anywhere near the choices for day care that Windham has,” White added. “It’s a big issue.”
According to Teresa Sadak, a former member of the RSU 14 School Board and owner of Peek-A-Roo Day Care on Route 85 in Raymond, just south of the school campus, parents’ concerns regarding Raymond day care are overblown.
“They don’t know the day cares, and they’re condemning the day cares. They haven’t even gone in and interviewed any of them yet,” Sadak said of the half-dozen childcare facilities in the town.
Sadak also took issue with parents’ hesitation to shift child-care providers. Children, she argues, usually don’t have trouble adjusting to new situations.
“It’s not that big a deal, not if they’re young enough. It happens all the time,” she said. “Every year we send our [ninth-grade] kids from Raymond to Windham High School and there’s no problem. And I think younger kids are so much more open to meeting new people than high schoolers.”
Superintendent Sandy Prince says he understands the parents’ concerns regarding changing providers.
“I fully understand what the parents are saying about the day-care issue and the interruption that would be,” Prince said. “That is not to say they would not be able to transition to a new day care and probably over time things would be fine. But it is one of the disadvantages. That I would agree on.”
Mike Duffy, school board chairman, said he’s “not surprised they’re unhappy about it” but looks at the broader issues driving the proposal.
“It almost seems like some parents think they’re being banished from the community, which they’re really not, and I don’t know how to address that with them, except to say it’s still the same RSU, it’s still the same administration, they’re still the same teachers. It’s just a different location,” Duffy said.
Parents wanting to keep the same day-care providers had several proposals to prevent what they described as “uprooting.” Some suggested building a wing onto Windham Primary School, the most overcrowded school in the system. Others suggested the town build a new middle school, which is another overcrowded school.
However, Duffy said the alternatives to redistricting would be expensive and that taxpayers may object since Raymond’s two schools – Raymond Elementary School and Jordan-Small Middle School – are operating at half capacity.
“How do you ask the Windham taxpayers to come up with $18 million to $20 million for additions when you have two half-empty schools in the fleet?” Duffy said. “So to me, it’s better for everyone to move these kids up there. It doesn’t cost money. It’s perfectly safe. But people are saying they don’t want to cross this imaginary line.”
Mary Wassick, a former school board member and longtime child care provider in Windham, is conflicted with the issue but says the board should address long-term issues before taking short-term steps that could backfire against the children and their parents who are tied to day cares such as hers.
“We have a facility problem and we need to address the facility problem. I’m thinking that redistricting schools is a Band-Aid to a problem that we’ll just be facing again in a few years,” she said. “They need to start to look at – unfortunately for the taxpayers – bigger plans. We’re busting at the seams. We’re growing again, and it’s time to look at building.”
Prince, who said he doesn’t presume to speak for the school board, which has the final word and is expected to vote on the redistricting proposal by the end of October, said the district is already thinking ahead. He said options are limited since the state ranks the Windham Middle School 46th on the school replacement list. About six projects per year receive funding.
“I think the board thinks [redistricting] is a step in the right direction knowing that someday, hopefully, we’ll get a new middle school,” Prince said. “I guess the question would be, would the public support an addition to Windham Primary School knowing we have two schools in the district at 50 percent capacity.”
Teachers Joan Greenleaf, left, and Shannon Busque welcome kids to A Joyful Noise Christian Daycare & Learning Center in North Windham on Tuesday afternoon. Day-care centers around Windham would be affected if a proposed school redistricting proposal is approved. Staff photo by John Balentine
Comments are no longer available on this story