4 min read

PORTLAND – State Rep. Donald Pilon, D-Saco, is calling for an investigation of the shutdown of the Maine Department of Transportation’s longstanding vanpool program.

The program will be discontinued as of Sept. 1. In a letter addressed to program participants, MDOT Commissioner David Bernhardt explained that the cancellation resulted from a review that concluded, “although the vanpool provides a valuable service … sufficient funding is simply not available to meet the need for vanpool vehicle replacement and related ongoing expenses.”

I have ridden the vanpool from Portland to Lewiston pretty much every day for the last four years. But I’m also a fiscal conservative, so I have had a hard time reconciling my feelings about the cancellation of the vanpool program.

I generally feel that the government, although well-meaning, does a pretty poor job executing such programs.

For example, our vanpool uses a Ford F350 Econoline van that, according to the state, has a replacement cost of $43,000. But a basic model of that van, which is used by all of the commercial vanpool operations — without bucket seats, a high roof, bike rack and reading lights — costs only $35,000.

Advertisement

In my estimation, the state grossly overestimated the role those added features played in attracting people to the program, while underestimating the value of the service itself.

Each member of our van, excluding the driver, pays $120 per month — but each of us, including the driver, would readily pay $150 a month to keep the service going.

That may not seem like a significant increase, but over the estimated lifetime of the vehicle (say, six years at 17,500 miles per year), it would add up to a net increase in revenue to the state of $40,400 for our vehicle alone. And there are 27 vehicles in the program.

Amazingly, despite these missteps, the vanpool program actually made money. Pushed to explain its cancellation, the MDOT actually admitted that over the past four years, the vanpool program ran a surplus of more than $233,000!

Maybe the surplus is why the state decided to spend on van amenities — it must have seemed unlikely that the administration would cancel its one program that was running in the black.

Rep. Pilon is questioning MDOT’s reasoning for closing the vanpool, saying, “Things really don’t add up.”

Advertisement

He is right. In my own examination of the spreadsheets from the MDOT’s 2011 review, I found multiple errors. For example, the MDOT estimated that in the future, gasoline would cost the state $4 per gallon, but only $3.50 per gallon for commuters vanpooling with a private company.

Over the lifetime of our vehicle, that 50-cent per gallon difference turns into $4,000. Across the entire 27-van fleet, a 50-cent error adds up to more than $100,000, or three basic replacement vans. A more careful study of the program needs to be done.

Furthermore, Maine is hardly in any position to cut programs that lessen its dependence on fossil fuels. After all, Maine has no fossil fuel resources and never will. As a result, 78 cents of each dollar spent on fossil fuels leaves the state. (This figure combines numbers from the U.S. Energy Information Administration Home Heating Oil Report 2010 and Gasoline and Diesel Update, September 2009.)

This is a serious problem for Maine, not only for the $1 billion-plus annual trade deficit it creates, but also for the threat it poses to Maine’s economy. Continuing the vanpool program wouldn’t solve that problem, but would be part of a solution — especially if it were expanded to accommodate the hundreds of people who were on the waiting list for vanpool seats.

Like a social network, the GoMaine vanpool program has allowed Mainers who share commuting situations to connect and make that travel economical while lessening the state’s dependence on fossil fuels.

It may seem low-tech, but it may be our future. Canceling it because it requires more investment at a time when it’s actually making money — in effect, punishing it for its success — doesn’t seem like wise management.

Advertisement

As is hopefully clear, I have a prescription for Commissioner Bernhardt: Keep the vanpool program, increase fees 25 percent, keep the vehicles basic and keep the profits in the program.

Please consider contacting Rep. Pilon or your own state representative showing your support for his investigation. The vanpool program has its faults, but they are easily solvable and are overshadowed by its virtues. Giving up on it now probably just means rebuilding it, at much greater expense, a few years from now.

Joshua Henry of Portland is a visiting assistant professor of chemistry at Bates College.

 

Comments are no longer available on this story