4 min read

Recently it was reported that Maine ranked 46th in the “State Integrity Investigation” by three nonpartisan, national and international journalism and good government groups. Maine got an F in nine of the 14 categories. Three of the nine categories that Maine got an F on are categories that are relevant to cities like South Portland. The three are public access to information, accountability and ethics enforcement. I would give South Portland a C-minus on access to information and an F on both accountability and ethics enforcement.

The access to information grade of C-minus is a combined grade made up of an F for the school department and a B for the municipal side of the city. The school department has historically provided limited information and much of the information provided is factually dishonest. On several occasions in the past, I have questioned the actions of the City Council and the school board related to all financial matters and their lack of accountability, accordingly the F grade on accountability is justified.

My grade of an F for South Portland on ethics enforcement is based on over 20 years in senior management positions in the corporate world and recent actions related to the handling of the City Council health care issue. I worked for 10 years at Raytheon, which at the time of my retirement in 2006 was a $20 billion in sales company with over 80,000 employees. At Raytheon, every employee was required to have annual ethics training. Many managers including myself thought the annual training was excessive and that training on what was a “conflict of interest” seemed to be basic common sense. Every year our training would include a case study on hiring consultants or purchasing other goods and services. Based on my ethics training and common sense it is clear the South Portland City Council does not understand what a conflict of interest is and what it is not.

In the past year, the city has wasted tens of thousands of dollars of taxpayer money trying to enforce a policy that would deny Karen Callaghan, who is a part-time employee at the city library, from future service on the school board. It appears the city manager and the City Council believe that the policy that does not allow city employees to serve on the school board prevents a conflict of interest. I would agree that if Ms. Callaghan was a school employee, then that probably could be a conflict. In contrast, the City Council has never questioned the conflict of interest from several school board members voting to expand questionable programs and extracurricular activities that benefit their children directly. Ms. Callaghan, who has no children in the school system, has much less chance of a conflict than several other board members, who have several children in the school system.

The city manager and the City Council’s handling of the City Council health care dispute is a clear example of an ethical issue and a conflict of interest, especially when compared to the Callaghan case. The city had a full-time attorney as a city employee for many years until about three years ago. The City Council decided that they would outsource the position to Sally Daggett, a partner at a Portland law firm, on an hourly basis. It was thought at the time that there was no need for a full-time attorney and that payment on an hourly basis controlled by the city manager and the City Council would save the city money. Accordingly, the more the city utilizes Ms. Daggett the more it costs the city, and the more the revenues and profits increase for Ms. Daggett’s law firm.

In November of 2011, the city manager hired and paid for a legal opinion from an independent, outside attorney that concluded that the payments of health care premiums on the behalf of City Council members were in violation of the City Charter. This opinion was in contrast to the opinion given by Ms. Daggett in 2009, when she concluded that the City Council health care benefits could continue because the meaning of the word “compensation” was ambiguous. Upon receiving the 2011 legal opinion, the city manager should have stopped making payments of the health care benefits to the three impacted City Council members. When the city manager refused to stop the health care payments, I filed a lawsuit in Superior Court to force the city to stop the payments.

Advertisement

The full City Council, including three members who had a clear conflict of interest (because they were collecting the just determined illegal payments) and the Ms. Daggett (who also had a conflict of interest), decided to spend taxpayer money to fight the lawsuit that would have reduced the city’s costs. Last week, the full City Council refused to approve a draft compromise agreement between myself and the mayor that would have dismissed my lawsuit contingent on the City Council agreeing to just one public workshop or public forum on the health care issue by July 9, 2012.

Ms. Daggett’s conflict of interest is blatant. First, she has a conflict because she would for personal reasons want to defend her 2009 opinion that now appears to have been incorrect based on the 2011 opinion from an independent, outside attorney. But more importantly, she has already taken unnecessary actions that increased her billable hours, which enriches her personally at the expense of the taxpayers. The only way to avoid the conflict would have been for the city to hire an independent law firm to review the lawsuit and defend the city and only if it was determined the chances of success were good.

Hopefully the City Council, city manager and Ms. Daggett will find the time to enroll in a good ethics training course and change their unethical behaviors based on that training.

Al DiMillo is a retired CPA who lives in South Portland.

Comments are no longer available on this story