5 min read

MONTPELIER, Vt. — Mentally ill Vermonters who are involuntarily put in state care are still mostly being moved from place to place in shackles, seven years after the state decreed that they should be transported with “the least restrictive means necessary,” according to documents and interviews.

A very small percentage of patients are combative or are deemed to present a threat of violence, psychologists, sheriffs and others said. But about two-thirds of patients being moved by sheriffs or police are in handcuffs and ankle chains, data compiled by the state Department of Mental Health show.

Some patients end up being shackled for nearly three hours as they are moved from hospital emergency rooms in St. Albans or Newport to the Brattleboro Retreat in southeastern Vermont, a private psychiatric hospital the state has been relying on more since flooding from Tropical Storm Irene forced the closing of the Vermont State Hospital in Waterbury in August.

“It would seem as though we’ve made virtually no progress on this issue … or, worse yet, that we’ve regressed substantially,” Jeff McKee, director of psychiatric services at the Rutland Regional Medical Center, wrote in an email.

A retired doctor told of her 26-year-old son, who suffers from schizophrenia and has been shackled on several occasions when being taken to psychiatric treatment even though he was not threatening violence, she said.

“I just can’t even describe the horror of it, the cruelty,” said Dr. Ruth Grant of Waltham.

Advertisement

“They’ve never come close to using the least restrictive means available on my son,” Grant said.

Deputy Mental Health Commissioner Mary Moulton acknowledged the mental health system was not living up to the terms of the law, passed in 2003 and updated in 2005.

“We’re late, but we’re here and we’re going to do something about it,” she said.

Since Irene, a task force has been studying issues connected with transporting the mentally ill, and Moulton said her goal is to see, within a year, at least 60 percent of Vermont’s transports of mental health patients done without law enforcement involvement or the use of restraints.

The issue is yet another setback for Vermont’s mental health system, which is in the midst of a top-to-bottom shake-up. Built in the 1890s and widely seen as antiquated, the state hospital was closed for good after the flood. It lost its federal certification a decade ago, costing the state $8 million to $12 million a year in federal money used to care for patients.

In the past five years, about three-quarters of involuntarily committed patients were transported around by sheriffs or police. Others were taken by ambulance or in vehicles driven by hospital or mental health workers. From 2007 through 2009, an average of 65 percent of the patients were transported in restraints. In 2010 it crept up to 69 percent and last year to 72 percent.

Advertisement

One patient, Marla Simpson, said in an interview that she was suffering from insomnia last year and hadn’t slept in four days when she asked a mental health crisis worker to be taken from her home in Randolph to the Central Vermont Medical Center, which has a psychiatric unit. Instead, she was taken to the Gifford Medical Center in Randolph, which does not have a psychiatric unit.

She was held overnight and asked to return home in the morning to find a ride to central Vermont. She said in an email that a police officer threw her against a wall and handcuffed her.

“I don’t think it should be allowed,” Simpson, 39, said in an interview.

Both Windham County Sheriff Keith Clark and Orleans County Sheriff Kirk Martin said that getting a ride with their deputies means being in shackles.

Patients are being transported by sheriffs in most cases mainly because that’s how it’s been done historically, several people involved in the mental health system said. Some said there’s reluctance among ambulance crews to move the patients because crews worry about the safety of moving people who are being committed involuntarily.

“If you call us, it means you’re asking for the most secure kind of transport,” Clark said. He said he would prefer that the Department of Mental Health have its own personnel do the transports. “When it comes right down to it, we should not be in the mental health transport business.”

Advertisement

There are also financial issues: A ride with a sheriff is cheaper than one in an ambulance. And Jim Finger, president of the Vermont Ambulance Association, said some ambulance services balk at long-distance transports of patients covered by Medicaid because reimbursements from that government health insurance program are too low to cover the ambulance crew’s costs.

But traveling by ambulance is better for the patient’s mental health, McKee said.

“If it’s not treated like a criminal thing, they respond differently,” he said. “If the police are walking in and jangling shackles it’s just a whole different level of conversation. It just escalates the situation.”

Such transportation is not without its own challenges.

Patients often are brought first by family members, police or community mental health workers to emergency rooms, where, if they are deemed in need of inpatient care, they often wait until a bed opens up in a psychiatric unit somewhere in the state. Those beds have been harder to come by since the 54-bed Waterbury hospital closed.

Often it’s hospital emergency room managers who decide how a patient is to be moved, and they operate under a federal law that sets strict safety standards.

Advertisement

“Some hospitals say they can’t put someone in a car,” Moulton said.

Ambulance crews, meanwhile, want to make sure they have enough staff and vehicles available to respond to emergencies in their own areas before they’re called upon to move a psychiatric patient from a local hospital to another one hours away, Finger said.

“It’s something you can’t just mandate,” said Finger. “You’d have to work it through and make sure the resources are there before you did that.”

He added, “I’m not giving you a lot of answers because I don’t think the answer is out there yet.”

 

Comments are no longer available on this story