3 min read

Certain rights are fundamental and should not be subject to removal when the political wind shifts.

That is why I am concerned about a bill that we soon will be voting on in the Senate, L.D. 1207, “An Act To Amend the Labor Laws Relating to Certain Agricultural Employees.”

This bill is aimed squarely at reducing the rights of a specific group of low-wage agricultural workers, the employees of the former DeCoster Egg Farm in Turner.

In Maine and across the country, factory farming like that at DeCoster is low wage and dangerous.

There is an unfortunate history to the DeCoster farm.

In the late 1990s there was a considerable scandal around the living and working conditions there.

Advertisement

Things were so bad that it made the national news, and ultimately Jack DeCoster was fined more than $2 million by the federal government.

To help prevent such a situation from happening again, the Legislature granted the DeCoster workers some elemental labor rights.

Protecting the rights of workers is paramount to our American history.

You may remember that more than a hundred years ago, Upton Sinclair wrote a book about the horrific living and working conditions of American factories.

Sinclair’s depiction of the harsh working conditions and hopelessness among the working class is not that dissimilar from what we saw during the peak of the DeCoster worker abuse.

While conditions have improved somewhat for the DeCoster workers in Maine, the DeCoster farms across the nation have not been free from scandal.

Advertisement

They have faced charges of animal cruelty and unsanitary conditions leading to a national outbreak of salmonella in 2010.

Now, Jack DeCoster has gone out of the egg business, at least in Maine, and he has leased his farm to another company named Moark.

I think this is good news, and I welcome Moark to Maine.

Unfortunately, that company is seeking, through L.D. 1207, to undo those rights that were granted to the DeCoster workers 15 years ago.

In its original form, the bill sought to take away any collective bargaining rights for the workers, even removing their right to be paid overtime.

The bill was softened slightly in committee and under the amended version now before the Legislature, the workers would still qualify for overtime, but would lose their collective bargaining rights.

Advertisement

To me, this is just wrong.

The rationale is that Moark doesn’t have the record that DeCoster had, and that these rights won’t be needed.

Well, virtually no one has a history quite like DeCoster so that isn’t much of a comfort.

I am sure that Moark has the very best of intentions, and I sincerely hope that they will treat their workers fairly.

I want them to be a business that Maine can be proud of.

We can’t entrust these workers to “hope and good intentions,” however.

Advertisement

They need rights and protections as well.

For even if Moark turns out to be the best of employers, what happens if someone else takes over that isn’t as scrupulous?

If this law passes, then the workers are just out of luck.

Taking away their rights will not improve the economy or create jobs, it will just make the workers vulnerable.

I am also concerned that this is part of a larger, national campaign against workers’ rights in general.

The DeCoster workers may be seen as a way of getting a foot in the door concerning workers’ rights.

Advertisement

We have to identify this for what it is, an assault against all workers.

L.D. 1207 recently passed the House, and we soon will be voting on it in the Senate, most likely this week.

Maine lawmakers need to be standing up for Maine workers and focusing on creating jobs, not gutting workers’ rights. The workers of Maine need to feel like Augusta has their back.

I will be voting to oppose this bill, as I would any measure to reduce workers’ rights.

 

Comments are no longer available on this story