WINDHAM – Windham will be open to the sale and use of fireworks following action Tuesday by the Town Council.
The vote, which in effect allowed the statewide law legalizing some kinds of fireworks to apply within Windham town limits, was 4-2, with Councilors Kevin Call and David Nadeau against the proposal.
The new state law, which bans fireworks use by anyone under the age of 21, including sparklers, says consumer fireworks may be shot off on private property any day of the year from 9 a.m. to 10 p.m., except on July 4 and Dec. 31, when use is permitted until 12:30 the following morning. What has been decriminalized in Maine are small explosives only, not to include “missile” products, such as bottle rockets, skyrockets and aerial spinners.
The law also puts restrictions on the sale. Sellers must obtain the correct state and federal permits, plus any applicable local permits, and fireworks can only be sold “in a permanent, fixed, stand-alone building dedicated solely to the sale of consumer fireworks,” meaning fireworks cannot be sold in a convenience or department store.
The law gave municipalities the right to ban the sale and/or use of fireworks. Despite the council’s vote, the 90-day fireworks moratorium that was put in place Dec. 27 just before fireworks became legal in Maine on Jan. 1, is still in effect until late March. The moratorium was designed to allow the council more time to consider the proposal.
Prior to the vote, state Rep. Gary Plummer, a Windham Republican who played a part in last year’s drafting of the law that allows fireworks in Maine, addressed councilors, making a plea in favor of following the state’s lead. Plummer argued that fireworks, though dangerous if used recklessly, can be enjoyed in a responsible way, similarly to other potentially dangerous entertainment such as playgrounds and snowmobiles.
“There are a lot of kids who suffer injuries on school playgrounds. But do we ban school playgrounds? We make a decision that the exercise and the other benefits of school playgrounds are worth taking that chance,” Plummer said. “And how many people are killed or injured using snowmobiles? Would you consider banning the sale or use of snowmobiles in the town of Windham if you had that power?”
Personal responsibility and government intrusion played a part in the majority’s decision.
“I guess after listening to everybody involved and the community, I didn’t hear overwhelmingly against, however I have heard overwhelmingly for us allowing the use of fireworks in the town,” Councilor Scott Hayman said. “When do we as a government stop legislating responsibility? I want to be responsible for myself. I want to be responsible for my kids. … So for me to sit here and legislate that stuff, where do we stop? Do we take away playgrounds? Do we take away beer and guns? When do we stop legislating responsibility for people who are supposed to be responsible for themselves?”
Councilors Matt Noel, Tommy Gleason and Dennis Welch commended Hayman’s for his comments with Welch adding, “I agree with you Scotty. You know I’ve spoken on this last time, you can’t legislate stupid.”
Call was against the proposal.
“It’s as tough one,” he said. “There have been some good arguments and Mr. Plummer has made my decision a lot tougher than it was earlier. I tend to think that it’s harder to reel a leash back in so I tend to say leave it as it is now. Let’s see how other towns deal with it and we can always change the ordinance later and allow it later. For a lot of different reasons, I just think it’s a bad idea to legalize fireworks in this town.”
Also opposed were Windham’s fire and police chiefs, who urged the council in December to continue the ban, which has been in place for years. Fire/Rescue Chief Charlie Hammond attended Tuesday’s meeting and cited lack of enforcement, public safety and increased costs as reasons why he opposes fireworks use by Windham residents.
“Who’s going to enforce it? Is the Windham Police Department going to be responsible at Summerfest for going around and taking sparklers and arresting parents (of children) that are using sparklers?” Hammond said. “Last year, we responded to over 2,694 calls for service with a pay-per-call department. Our people enjoy the Fourth of July just like everybody else, so if we’re going to ask for fireworks and sparklers to be used, are you prepared for the cost of having full-time people available to respond to emergencies when the call people aren’t available?”
Hammond predicted the new law allowing fireworks will result in “more calls, not less … so please take that into consideration when you start allowing people to play with fire.”
Public comment drew several residents mostly in favor of fireworks. Jim Hanscom urged councilors to reject a ban.
“Fireworks are here now,” Hanscom said. “You guys all sit down on Little Sebago Lake and watch fireworks on the Fourth of July and other times of the year. I mean, they’re out there. … At least the town of Windham could get a little bit of revenue from this, or the state could get a little bit of revenue.”
“I’m still against a blanket prohibition,” resident Patrick Corey said. “It would eliminate rights before they’ve been granted …with the most dangerous fireworks – sparklers – now regulated to adults, safety has been addressed to a point. If in a few years problems come up, you will see greater public support for prohibition.”
Comments are no longer available on this story