FRYEBURG – A Jan. 14 letter titled “Sebago Lake users left high and dry,” criticizing Sappi’s role in the new proposed management plan for Sebago Lake’s Eel Weir Dam, underscores the need for the media to help accurately explain to Maine residents how this vital water resource will potentially be managed far into the distant future.
The proposed new management plan for inclusion in a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission license has received input and approval from state agencies, various citizens and Sappi. The plan will benefit the lake environment as well as more efficiently use the water released from the Eel Weir Dam, while maintaining prescribed state lake level targets.
Sappi’s 2011 proposal, which would more simulate natural outflows from the dam and historic ranges in water levels, was modified by the Maine Department of Environmental Protection to appease high-water interests. Some marina and property owners in shallow coves and tributary rivers still oppose any change to the present harmful lake level plan.
Residents need to be aware of how the FERC relicensing process for Sappi’s Eel Weir Hydroelectric facility has evolved. It was due for relicensing in 2005, but the DEP delayed the issuance of state water quality certification for Sebago Lake’s relicensing until 2012.
Since 2005, information has been presented to FERC by the Friends of Sebago Lake claiming that the DEP’s 1997 water-level management plan is:
• Harming water quality.
• Accelerating the erosion of beaches and shorelines.
• Promoting the proliferation of invasive species like milfoil.
• Reducing the effectiveness of lake wetlands to assimilate and safely sequester nutrients.
• Harming the natural fishery.
• Negatively altering the seasonal freshwater flow volumes into the Casco Bay estuary.
The Friends of Sebago Lake, in recent years, has contracted with national and state experts to analyze studies on Sebago’s wetlands, water quality and beach geology, as well as to provide opinions on the lake level management plan’s impact. The reports and findings are part of the FERC relicensing record for the Eel Weir Dam.
It is likely the group’s information was somewhat responsible for the state’s reversal of its justification for mandating Sebago’s constant high lake levels and unnatural outflows. Other state agencies have justified supporting the new plan by citing a benefit to the lake environment.
All Maine residents and groups have had an equal opportunity to comment on the relicensing of the Eel Weir Dam for the last seven years. The Friends of Sebago Lake supports the lake management plan in the water quality certification as a compromise.
The group believes Sappi’s original 2011 lake outflow proposal was better because it would have resulted in historic natural seasonal lake levels and more uniform outflow, which would also benefit the Presumpscot River and Casco Bay estuaries.
It is difficult for Sappi to adhere to the 1997 DEP plan, which requires specific water level targets on prescribed dates. Often, Sappi either has to release excessively low flow volumes through the turbines or spill water wastefully to meet lake level targets. The yo-yo changing of outflows and the resulting harmful impacts on the water quality and ecosystem of the two estuaries was never recognized in the 1997 plan.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is still accepting comments, and the Eel Weir Dam will be operated under the 1997 plan until the commission rules on the state water quality certification and issues a new license.
The FERC relicensing process has been delayed because of legal filings. One marina owner, Charles Frechette of Sebago, has appealed the state water quality certification to the Board of Environmental Protection, citing negative economic impacts to his business.
Douglas Watts of Augusta, an expert on anadromous fish history and restoration, has filed a lawsuit in Maine Superior Court against the DEP’s Sebago Lake water quality certification. Watts’ suit includes numerous claims that the water quality certification violates provisions of the Clean Water Act and Great Ponds Act.
One claim argues that fish passage should be required at the Eel Weir Dam. Other claims state that the new DEP lake management plan does not restore the “natural character” of Sebago Lake’s shorelines and beaches and the indigenous fishery habitat.
Decisions on the management of Sebago Lake will ultimately be in the hands of the judicial system and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, not Sappi or any particular group of citizens.
Roger Wheeler is a resident of Fryeburg and president of the Friends of Sebago Lake.
Comments are no longer available on this story